Jorum Studio Carduus and Nectary Review (Euan McCall) 2019 + Progressive Botany Vol.1 Collection Draw

Jorum Studio Progressive Botany Vol.1 collection reviews

Waving Barley photo by Jacob Meister©

“Life encompasses the 3 Bs: it is brief, brutal and beautiful.” ~ Ida

That brutal beauty, so heartless that it takes away our breath – can be unearthed in Edinburgh perfumer Euan McCall’s labor of love, his own Jorum Studio (and Jorum Laboratories, which created Senyokô’s singular perfumes) recent collection Progressive Botany Vol.1.

Jorum Studio Arborist, Carduus, Medullary-ray, Nectary, Phloem and Trimerous by Scottish perfumer Euan Mccall

Jorum Studio Progressive Botany Vol.1 collection via Jorum Studio

Euan generously sent me the collection of six fragrances (15 mls each) for my perusal. I was overwhelmed by the gesture, presentation and quality of these botanically inspired perfumes. It has taken me awhile to digest, sit with and explore them in order to corral my impressions and emotions. As it happened, two wildly dissimilar scents reached out and grabbed me by the throat: Jorum Studio Carduus and Nectary. I either cannot or will not decide which to review, so I’ll review both.

Jorum Studio Carduus review

Jorum Studio Carduus courtesy of Jorum Studio

 Jorum Studio Carduus: “‘Nemo me impune lacessit’ (‘No one can harm me unpunished’, in Latin) – the Order of the Thistle. The defiant motto of Scotland, an ancestral virtue.” ~ Jorum Studio (Also the motto of the Royal Stuart dynasty. The Stuart Victoria tartan is pictured here in the background. ) Carduus nutans is the musk thistle.

 Scottish perfumes

photograph of thistle outside Edinburgh in The Duns along the Tweed River by Jacob Meister©

Jorum Studio fragrances reveal a love of indigenous landscape. Carduus appeals to me precisely for that reason; I’m enchanted by the quotidian and I long to smell Euan’s environs. This fragrance encompasses aromatics which festoon pastures, hillsides, are native to Scottish terrain. What could be more emblematic than the Thistle? Or the evocation of botanicals flourishing along the roadside, nibbled by deer and livestock?

Jorum Studio Carduus is nothing if not earthy. It sings in authentic herbal tenor graced with haunted woods and fleurs fanées. The initial sweetness springs from that touch of honey and heliotrope with its powdery/almond note. Bracing, nose-tingling herbs awaken the senses soon after – a profusion of chamomile, clary sage, marjoram with its whispers of soft anise, deertongue with its complex scent profile including tones of salt, bitter dry hay and tonka (Deertongue’s lore is as delightful as its scent. Rumor has it that it will ensnare a new lover and increase sexual desire.). Local plant life is pressed into service and the list is extensive: meum, for example – is plentiful and its umbrella-like tops resemble wild carrot with its feathery foliage much like dill (it’s also eaten as a root vegetable). Vetch, a flowering plant/legume; tormentil (the rose’s relative), which blooms upon the heath; sea holly with its coriander-like aroma. Euan’s inclusion of clove bud is just piquant enough; pepper assumes a sweet/tarry smoky/leathery facet which waxes companionable with drier notes. A touch of tobacco and cocoa is followed by cherrywood and mahogany notes. The florals re-emerge at various intervals in Carduus’ unfolding, a wisp of tuberose and rose accented by intensely fresh eucalyptus-like myrtle. At some juncture the perfume’s quiet naturalism takes a turn in the manner of the sanctity of daily things. Carduus smells holy to me because it rings true to nature. I love it for the affectionate veracity in each drop, lightweight, enduring as tradition filled with character and a decided twist.

Notes: Chamomile, Bengal Pepper, Honey, Clary Sage, Sea-holly, Marjoram Tea, Myrtle, Rose Absolute, Vetch, Clove Bud, Hart’s Tongue (fern),Tuberose, Musk-thistle, Heliotrope, Tormentil, Mahogany, Cocoa Absolute, Tobacco, Meum, Deertongue, Cherrywood

Jorum Studio Nectary review

Jorum Studio Nectary via Jorum Studio

Jorum Studio Nectary: the glands in flora responsible for producing the honeyed liquid which attracts pollinators. That’s a grand starting point.

Oh, the prickle-eye bush; it pricks my heart full sore!

And if ever I get out of that prickle-eye bush, I’ll never get in it anymore.” ~ traditional folk song

Sea Holly grows in Scotland

photograph of Sea Holly outside Edinburgh in The Duns along the Tweed River by Jacob Meister©

So we intone each and every time – but when I stumbled upon Euan McCall’s brambly wild garden, I resolved to remain in the comforting folds of its savagely beautiful gown. Nectary is a disorderly floral created with a gardener’s eye and wisdom emanating from the inherent loveliness of chaos. Why the bramble (prickle-eye bush)? Bramble is also known as the blackberry; pollinators are attracted to its blossoms and butterflies adore them. They grow like wildfire in the British Isles, protected by their dense mantle of spiny thorns – just as the rose is. There exists a fairytale relationship between these two.  Jorum Studio Nectary’s appeal mirrors that of ballad and lore; much like Parsifal or the rescuing prince, one must overcome obstacles in pursuit of the Grail, the Other. Only the courageous may heal the kingdom, wrest wholeness from a complete lack of order… Nectary is an about-face in contrast to Carduus. We’ve swung from pastoral to mythical, all the while entrenched in the botanical realm. There seem to be so many interweaving tendrils that my mind leaps from one to another and I’d like to attempt to take you along with me.

Great scottish painters

Edward Burne-Jones the Rose Bower from Briar Rose series via wikipedia

Enter rose and the berries: rose being such a complex creature that there are olfactory links between the two and it’s delicious when they converge. Rose is lonely and seeks out blackberry (aka bramble), but its season ends in early autumn just as cranberry season continues this thread with increasing tartness. We’re still in Scotland, mind; the countryside is dotted with herbs, plants utilized as medicine. These include the hardy selfheal – eaten raw, boiled, in salads and teas – it thrives in fallow areas, gardens and abandoned places. Selfheal might find itself in the company of roseroot, aka rhodiola rosea – a rose-scented flowering plant used in traditional medicine to ameliorate depression and anxiety; they frequent similar locales. How intricate the tale becomes! Our exquisite rose is now wreathed in berries and herbs; peaches from summer’s orchard have wended their way to her cottage door and lie abed with slumbering rose.

Jorum Studio Nectary by Euan McCall

Pre-Raphaelite Society painting of The Knights and the Briar Rose, Burne-Jones

Seasons pass as rose sleeps; massive walls of thorn surround her cottage. Somberly sensual oud joins forces with beach-found ambergris and sylvan/river creatures (deer representing musk, Scottish wildcat referencing civet, the beaver, castoreum). Dusky labdanum’s leathery amber deepens the olfactory palette laced with incense (olibanum). We too lie in wait with rose: who will approach to break the spell? Is there a Parsifal in the offing? Was the bond between rose and bramble akin to that of Sweet William and Barbara Allen in the ballad? I leave you with these possibilities to ponder.

The one certainty I have is profound admiration for Euan McCall’s work and an unrestrained love for Nectary, beautiful as Jesus’ crown of thorns.

Jorum Studio Progressive Botany Vol 1 perfumes

 

Barbara Allen was buried in the old churchyard
Sweet William was buried beside her,
Out of sweet William’s heart there grew a rose
Out of Barbara Allen’s a briar.

They grew and grew in the old churchyard
Till they could grow no higher
At the end they formed a true lover’s knot
And the rose grew round the briar.”

Notes: Bramble, Cranberry, Peach, Rose Absolute, Oud, Ambergris, Roseroot, Olibanum, Selfheal, Castoreum, Civet, Labdanum Absolute, Musk

Euan, I cannot thank you enough for my sample set. I cherish it.  My nose is my own…

~ Ida Meister, Senior Editor and Natural Perfumery Editor

Jorum Studio Arborist, Carduus, Medullary-ray, Nectary, Phloem and Trimerous

Photo by Ida©

Thanks to the  incredible generosity of Euan McCall of Jorum Studio we are offering a complete sample set of the Progressive Botany Vol.1 collection (6 x 15mls), which for one registered reader in the EU, USA or Canada. You must register here or your comment will not count. To be eligible, please comment upon what appealed to you in Ida’s review of Jorum Studio Carduus and Nectary and where you live. Draw closes November 13, 2019

Follow us on Instagram @cafleurebon @idameister @jorumstudio @jorumlaboratories

(Photographs of Scotland courtesy of Jacob Meister taken last summer in The Duns.)

This is our Privacy and Draw Rules Policy

We announce the winners only on our site and on our Facebook page, so like Çafleurebon and use our  blog feed…or  your dream prize will be just spilled perfume.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

÷ 1 = 5

53 comments

  • Shamrock1313 says:

    Oh my goodness – all the great scents that trigger fond memories – they have ’em covered for sure. Sounds fantastic.
    Pennsylvania USA

  • Really intrigued by the rose, oud, civet, musk and labdanum. The rose and bramble analogy is apt. from UK

  • Intrigued by both but the rose and oud combo in nectary fascinates me as well as the ballad of Barbara Allen. Thanks from UK

  • My, what intricate read, I loved the convergence of poetry, art, botanical (folk)lore and perfumery.
    Greetings from London, UK

  • Love the description of these as capturing the indigenous scents of the environments. USA here.

  • Ida, thank you for the review. Both Nectary and Carduus appeal to me, perhaps Carduus slightly more. These reviews provided two guiding points to perhaps obtain a feel for the nature of this house – I have yet to sample anything from this brand. Canada

  • I liked the increase sexual desire part. Hehe If it were certainly true. Also loved the poem of the briar and the rose growing together to form the lovers knot. How very romantic. Both scents sound wonderful and to have all 6 would be grand. USA

  • I spent a year in the borders of Scotland in college and wandered all the way up to the Orkneys. I am interested in the old magic and mystery of these fragrances. Herbs and wildflowers and overgrown hills and heath. USA.

  • I liked Ida’s vivid description of nature that inspired these fragrances. I already have Trimerous (excellent!). Thanks for the generous draw. I’m in the U.S.

  • I enjoyed this review that combines fragrance, botany, art, and poetry. The two scents seem beautiful and I would be thrilled to try all of them. I am familiar with Euan McCall’s other work so I am even more excited about this wonderful opportunity. I live in the USA.

  • I was transported on the hills and countryside of Scotland, reminding me of the botanical inspired novels. Love to try them! Ana, Romania, EU

  • This review touched me almost on an emotional level. We all cherish, miss and relate to nature in one way or another. Be it fresh and humid forest trips as children or spending the summer holidays with scorching, dry heat in the grandparents’ house in the countryside or going to a cottage in the hills during autumn, a time when, at least where I am, the air is sweetened by the ripening fruit waiting to be picked and turned into jams, marmalades or strong alcoholics. Anyway, I find that these kind of “perfumes” that are naturally found in the environment, are more emotional and appealing than the best bottled concoctions ever, because they transport you somewhere, sometime. This is why I appreciate it so much when a perfumer tries to capture that in their creations. It’s just special and a way to be transported somewhere where you normally couldn’t, in just the blink of an eye (or a sniff of the nose?). By the sound of Ida’s review, Euan managed that successfully. I am from the EU and would love to sample all these special beauties.

  • Wow, what a wonderful proposal! Both fragrances sound evocative, complex and able to build a magical connection with nature.
    Jorum studio is a novelty for me and a beautiful discovery to be tested as soon as possible. Thanks for the nice review!
    I am in Italy.

  • i liked how “indigenous” these two fragrances sound, even if not necessarily so. deertongue’s lore was amusing. as was the “fairytale” between the bramble & the rose. appreciative from california

  • Wow, very interesting to acknowledge that perfumer that created scents for the very exquisite Senyoko brand, has another line, dedicated to wild, brutal, authentic, holy beauty of Nature. “Inherent loveliness of chaos”. So many unknown plants mentionned here, then also capturing legends and artworks, need to explore more at their website and instagram.
    Amazing very generous prize for the readers, please, count me in.
    Thank you, I am from the EU.

  • Discovering new fragrant worlds, what a beautiful portrait of Scotland, both fragrances are very interesting, CARDUUS with honey, tobacco, cocoa, NECTARY with rose, amber, labdanum, I admit it, I don’t know which to choose, every aspect of these fragrances fascinates me, probably because I’ve never been to Scotland. This set is fabulous. Thanks Ida for this new scented temptation.
    Linda – EU

  • squeaky the pin says:

    What an evocative review. Very intriguing and the botanical sense of place really appeals. I would love to win, thanks for the opportunity.

  • squeaky the pin says:

    What an evocative review. Very intriguing and the botanical sense of place really appeals. I would love to win, thanks for the opportunity.
    I’m in the U.K.

  • I would be so delighted to try these. I love botanical and naturalistic scents and Carduus and Nectary were so beautifully and appealingly described by Ida, that I need to try them. And the others included in the sample set as well! If it’s so true to nature in reality, they must be wonderful. Thanks! From EU.

  • Thank you so much Michelyn, Ida and all those involved in bringing this review to life. What an absolute pleasure to read and hear others impressions. Thank all of the Cafleurebon readers for showing interest in what we are doing at Jorum Studio and beyond. An honour and a privilege! Best, Chloe & Euan x

  • Captured by the unique description of the two fragrances reviewed here. Would love to try all six in the line. US

  • What a beautiful olfactory tribute to the flora of Scotland! I love the prose as well. It really sets the stage for the fragrance journey Euan McCall wants us to take. I would love to try! I’m in the US.

  • I loved the review and was totally engaged in the words.”The one certainty I have is profound admiration for Euan McCall’s work and an unrestrained love for Nectary, beautiful as Jesus’ crown of thorns.” USA

  • I loved Ida’s description of Nectary as a “disorderly floral,” which made me want to sample it all the more, as did her description of so many of the native botanicals that I hadn’t heard of, like deertongue, rosefoot, selfheal, musk thistle. Equally pleasing was her describing the connection between blackberry and rose. These fragrances sound like the complete opposite of synthetic aromas. I am in the US, in North Carolina. Thanks for making this drawing available.

  • “Brutal beauty” is such an intriguing way of describing perfumes! Have never been to Scotland but it sounds like these fragrances might just be able to take us there. I prefer natural smelling perfumes so I will probably like Carduus given it “rings true to nature.” I am also a fan of rose and berry scents, especially a darker rose, thus the oud and olibanum notes in Nectary might also be my cup of tea. Regards from Boston USA.

  • My goodness, this entire line is absolutely fascinating and uses quite a few notes unfamiliar to my nose (deertongue, meum, vetch.) It would be a real treat to smell my way through this collection!
    I enjoyed the inclusion of poetry in this article as well.Ida’s writing here is itself poetic, and has caused me to feel a pang of nostalgia for a place I have never been: the mark of a true writer!
    US

  • redwheelbarrow says:

    These both sound amazing! I’m drawn to the Carduus because it has so many interesting sounding plants that I have never even heard of. I love earthy scents so much. This is the first time I have heard of this house and my curiosity is definitely peaked. Thank you for this review and the draw. I’m in the US.

  • As a gardener, I’m always searching for something earthy and different in fragrances. These are very interesting! Thanks for another wonderful review and draw. USA

  • Having visited Scotland several times, it is a joyous experience to know that the beauty and smells of the countryside have been carefully gathered to produce something so gorgeous. Ida’s reviews transport into the fragrances themselves. These sound divine. I’m in the USA

  • I so adore Ida’s reviews. Veritable poetry in motion. Couldn’t help but daydream at her description of Carduus. Absolutely any perfume that contains tobacco, mahogany and clove (some of my favourite notes) is one I absolutely must try. But the contrast with the herbs is what intrigues me most. Very interested to know what ‘deertongue’ smells like! Canada.

  • Both perfumes scratch completely different itches, but bound by roots set in Scotland. How evocative, especially the added tidbit of roseroot having been used to alleviate depression. I read the poem that ends the review twice; so lovely. I live in the USA.

  • Elizabeth T. says:

    I loved especially the description of Carduus. I love the description of all the notes, indigenous ones especially (meum indeed! I’d never heard of this one.) I would love to get a smell of Scotland. I’m in the USA. Thank you for this generous draw!

  • Oh how this speaks to my Scottish soul.
    “We’ve swung from pastoral to mythical, all the while entrenched in the botanical realm. There seem to be so many interweaving tendrils that my mind leaps from one to another and I’d like to attempt to take you along with me.” Thanks for the tag-along leap, Ida.
    I have admired the work of Ewan and wish him much success.

  • I’ve never tried this brand but had the chance to sample Senyoko and they are exquisite! After reading another beautiful review from Ida, I think I’m drawn to Carduus.
    I live in France, thanks for the draw

  • Nectary sounds like a delightfully exciting floral. I also love the description of Phloem from this collection: “…a diabolical assemblage of odourants that should oppose, but somehow attract… hallucinogenic vapour with a marbled psychedelic development”

    Cheers from USA

  • When I came across this brand some weeks ago I was so intrigued, especially Arborist. But I was put off by the price tag tbh. So I would love to win the sample set to Germany, thanks for the draw!

  • This is exciting! I follow Jorum Laboratories on Insta. Their photos have really made me want to smell what they are cooking up! I love the artwork and poetry in this review. I am in KS, USA.

  • Very interesting review! Tahnk you Ida.
    Usually, I do not like herbal perfumes, but this perfumes sounds very complex and naturally beautiful.
    USA

  • Lovely review Ida! I traveled to Scotland a few years ago and fell in love with the place. I did a distillery tour with few friends and along with the whisky tasting, saw some beautiful scenery. I would love to experience it again through this fragrance set! I live in the US

  • These note breakdowns in these fragrances are just majestic – especially in the first one. These are a great way to get into a scent profile that I normally shy away from (florals). Commenting from USA

  • These unusual botanical notes sound so intriguing and I love the concept of using Scottish regional botany as a basis for perfumes ( I have deep ancestry in Aberdeen and Edinburgh, which also attracts me to these perfumes).
    Thank you for the wonderful descriptions, Ida, and thank you for this draw. I’m in the US.

  • Michael Prince says:

    Ida, great review of Jorum Studio Carduus and Nectary. What appealed to me about Cardus is that it encompasses aromatics which festoon pastures, hillsides, are native to Scottish terrain…with a beautiful honey, heliotrope, and almond combination along with other pleasant notes. Nectary has a ton of fruity notes and resins that make it sound really interesting. I am from the USA.

  • I love earthy fragrances. She captured the essence of each fragrance beautifully and I also love the pictures attached.
    I live in USA.

  • Ida, you did it again.. to my heart:-) Life encompasses the 3 Vs for me: it is vibrant, volatile and vivacious” . Maybe it’s because my name starts with this letter. I live in Romania

  • This collection sounds wonderful. I like that it uses earthy natural smells native to Scotland. It sounds like a line worthy of exploration. Thank you for the very poetic review, Ida.

  • Ida, what a glorious review! The images you use in your reviews always catch my attention. Also, these notes – I’ve never heard of Roseroot, Selfheal, Musk-thistle, Muem – just crazy!
    I need to see if I can pick up samples of this.

    Thanks so much!

    Love from Madison, WI, USA!

  • Everything from Jorum Studio sounds amazing. I’m particularly drawn to the idea of Carduus – of this incredible scent that evokes the Scottish countryside. I feel a longing connection to Scotland from my college days and miss it, the smells, and the colours. I have one perfume i’m obsessed with that transports me to a remote location. I’ve experienced very few perfumes that are able to conjure up this fully formed reality. They tell a story, rich with emotion. When it happens there’s a special sort of magic to it. Hearing about the notes in Carduus I’m already halfway there, imagining the story of the Scottish heritage and it’s terrain. I’m longing to try it!
    I’m in the UK.

  • I enjoy true to nature fragrances and Carduus sounds like it hits that high mark quite clearly. Ida’s review makes this sound delicious. USA

  • Excellent review by Ida who describes the scents of the environment of Scotland and nature that sound so beautifully capture. I would love to try these fragrances as I am so interested. I live in CA, USA. Thanks for the draw!