Serge Lutens La Proie Pour l’Ombre Review (Christopher Sheldrake) 2021 + Gratte-Ciel draw

 

Serge Lutens La Proie Pour l'Ombre review

Serge Lutens La Proie pour l’Ombre, part of the Gratte-Ciel collection and its three key notes: licorice, leather and vanilla – Pictures: bottle by Serge Lutens, licorice via Stock photos, leather via Ecoloquest and vanilla via Vanissa, all edited by Emmanuelle Varron.

Writing about a Serge Lutens perfume is undoubtedly one of the most complicated exercises for any journalist as the ingredients are not often fully revealed by brand, so you trust your nose to tease out notes (usually no more than three). The olfactive the storytelling invariably uses a literary tone, full of mysterious symbols in connection with M. Lutens personal history. Serge Lutens La Proie pour l’Ombre, the new perfume in the Gratte-Ciel collection (available worldwide from September 1), is no exception to this. But what does “(Lâcher) la proie pour l’ombre” mean? In literal translation, it’s “losing the substance by grasping at the shadow”. But this French expression actually means the abandonment of a real advantage for an illusory profit (and was popularized by Jean de La Fontaine fable “Le chien qui lâche la proie pour l’ombre”, published in 1688).

And below is Serge Lutens official statement:

 

Serge Lutens La Proie pour l'Ombre Gratte-Ciel collection

 Serge Lutens La Proie pour l’Ombre quote – picture via Serge Lutens, edited by Emmanuelle Varron

The press kit  shares that Serge Lutens La Proie pour l’Ombre was inspired by the memory of his mother. Born during World War II, he was separated from her at an early age which had a deep impact on his life. Serge Lutens uses an old photo he found, showing two unknown women who are  somehow linked to him and his family memories perhaps of abandonment. When reading the text written by Serge Lutens, we journey into the realm between shadow and light once again (as he did in Serge Noire, a common theme throughout work). This contrasting perception, blows hot and cold, epitomizing his latest fragrance created in collaboration with Christopher Sheldrake.

Serge Lutens and Christopher Sheldrake

Serge Lutens and Christopher Sheldrake

Serge Lutens La Proie pour l’Ombre is for me a “true Lutens”. That is, dark, deep, heady and seemingly difficult to pin down. However, the first few seconds remind me of Dior Eau Noire, with an  licorice-immortelle duo. It’s a very brief impression, but it is striking because the perfume created in 2004 by Francis Kurkdjian is a masterpiece for me. The Lutens spirit quickly returns with the immortelle which gains momentum and sets up a leathery, spicy and virile note that seems to nod to Serge Lutens Cuir Mauresque.  As the fragrance develops Serge Lutens La Proie pour l’Ombre opens with draped in soft vanilla, which twists around a  rosy floral note. I also perceive a chocolate facet  which gives an even more delicious roundness to the skin. The  earthy and sweet licorice is still present, but stays in the background, in perfect balance with the leathery and spicy side of immortelle. At the dry down  the vanilla remains, but the perfume doesn’t lose its leathery intensity and  as I always apply perfume before I sleep, it does have  overnight  longevity.

Serge Lutens La Proie pour l’Ombre via Serge Lutens©

I add a few lines to my first impressions: by accidentally spraying the perfume a second time on my skin, at the same place where I did it a few minutes previously, an amber facet disturbs the balance of the licorice-leather-vanilla triptych; I even perceive a very luminous floral note reminiscent of heliotrope. The evolution over the hours is modified as if by magic, much more flowery and sweet, with a very present coffee note in the background, and a resinous dry down close to benzoin.

Postscript: The mystery around this perfume is how it plays with our skin: upon discussion with three people who also had access to the perfume, there are unanimous similarities (the immortelle), but some did not perceive the licorice note at all, and there is debate on the flowery facet (heliotrope, orange blossom, iris?). Is this quest for “hidden” notes, characteristic of Lutens perfume lovers, would also be a kind of losing the substance by grasping at the shadow?

Official notes: vanilla, leather, licorice.
Other perceived notes: immortelle, rose, amber, heliotrope, benzoin.

Disclaimer: Serge Lutens La Proie pour l’Ombre sample graciously provided by rue Saint-Honoré boutique for this review. The opinions expressed are my own.

Emmanuelle Varron, Senior contributor with contributions from Michelyn

 Serge Lutens La Proie pour l'Ombre sample

sample photo by Emmanuelle©

Thanks to Serge Lutens, we have a 1 ml sample of Serge La Proie Pour l’Ombre for one registered reader worldwide (remember, it’s not globally launched yet!). To be eligible, please leave a comment on what appeals to you about Emmanuelle’s review and which Serge Lutens perfume is for you the most “Lutensian. Draw closes 08/16/2021.

 

 Serge Lutens Palais-Royal boutique

Serge Lutens Palais-Royal boutique by Emmanuelle©

“Avant-première” buy or test in Paris, at Serge Lutens Palais-Royal and Saint-Honoré boutiques, Le Bon Marché, Printemps Haussmann and Galeries Lafayette Paris Haussmann department stores.

Available from 1st September 2021, in selective perfumeries and department stores worldwide.

Other fragrances in the Gratte-Ciel collection include Tubereuse Criminelle, and de Profundis

Follow us on Instagram @cafleurebon @monbazarunlimited @sergelutens

This is our Privacy and Draw Rules Policy

We announce the winners on our site and on our Facebook page, so Like CaFleureBon and use our blog feed… or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


32 comments

  • kalexander1710 says:

    I love the darkness of the fragrance and I love vanilla fragrances. And the fact that it can be different on each person is very intriguing. I haven’t tried any perfumes from Serge Lutyens but would love to try this one.

  • Marion Corvi Low says:

    Oh my, has Lutens done it again? Unusual and not for everyone, this is one I think I need to try. As usual, a great and revealing review. I love licorice and vanilla, adding heliotrope (L’Heure Bleue in mind?) A shot or two or three of a smooth leather, a soucon of rose, a drop of amber. I do like Tuberose Criminelle and Sarrasins, so one could say I like the scents that challenge you. Thank you for an early bird chance to experience this illusion..La Proie Pour l’Ombre. I’m in US.

  • The presentation and stories behind this fragrance really appeal to me. The most Lutensian perfume for me is probably Gratte-Ciel. I live in, Poland, EU.

  • I am drawn to this fragrance by the notes described in Emmanuelle’s review, as well as, Serge’s quote, “losing the substance by grasping at the shadow”. So deep, dark, and mesmerizing…and the bottle is gorgeous. I cannot take my eyes off of it. This is one fragrance I will be adding to my collection. Thank you for the review 🙂

  • Wow, Emmanuelle, what a powerful review! ❤️
    Serge Lutens is an advanced experience, for me. I have yet to fully immerse myself in his world (just a slight dip of the toe with a la Nuit).
    Who would not jump at the chance to experience a pre-launch La Proie pour l’Ombre sample!?! If I am lucky enough to win, I’ll take it as a sign to enter the Lutens/Sheldrake universe!
    I love the conceptual inspiration & intellectual/emotional possibilities tied to the sense-experience of this scent. I love this kind of thought-provoking journey of a fragrance. Emmanuelle sums it up perfectly with this question, “Is this quest for “hidden” notes, characteristic of Lutens perfume lovers, would also be a kind of losing the substance by grasping at the shadow?” ❤️ As I have only tried A La Nuit, I don’t think I can judge the most Lutensian fragrance (though I hope to be able to throw my ideas into the hat one day). Thank you for this amazing opportunity! USA

  • Ahh, this sounds like a must sniff! Who could pass up trying “A true Lutens”? I love this house. Especially the older versions of the perfumes. Can’t wait to hunt this down which will be so hard now that Barney’s NYC is no more. Boo.

  • Fraghead Summy says:

    Yet to try fragrances from this house but this one really appeals to me. The very fact that different people smelled it differently is surprising . Vanilla note on the dry down with leather and benzoin gives it a very dark feel and a perfect night time winter frag for anyone. I loved how Emmanuelle still managed to bring out the best despite very limited knowledge of notes . Thank you for the opportunity . USA

  • forrestanez says:

    I have never smelled anything from Serge, but this sounds incredible. I also like that it is kind of an enigma to the nose. Great review! Hawaii USA

  • I add a few lines to my first impressions: by accidentally spraying the perfume a second time on my skin, at the same place where I did it a few minutes previously, an amber facet disturbs the balance of the licorice-leather-vanilla triptych; I even perceive a very luminous floral note reminiscent of heliotrope. The evolution over the hours is modified as if by magic, much more flowery and sweet, with a very present coffee note in the background, and a resinous dry down close to benzoin.

    Postscript: The mystery around this perfume is how it plays with our skin: upon discussion with three people who also had access to the perfume, there are unanimous similarities (the immortelle), but some did not perceive the licorice note at all, and there is debate on the flowery facet (heliotrope, orange blossom, iris?). Is this quest for “hidden” notes, characteristic of Lutens perfume lovers, would also be a kind of losing the substance by grasping at the shadow?

    Official notes: vanilla, leather, licorice.
    Other perceived notes: immortelle, rose, amber, heliotrope, benzoin. A beautiful piece by Emmanuel intrigued by the notes both perceived and actual notes. I love licorice, leather and vanilla sound sumptuous and edible. I would love to try 1834 borneo. A house that I need to explore further. Thanks a million from the United Kingdom

  • Serge Lutens La Proie pour l’Ombre is for me a “true Lutens”. That is, dark, deep, heady and seemingly difficult to pin down. However, the first few seconds remind me of Dior Eau Noire, with an licorice-immortelle duo. It’s a very brief impression, but it is striking because the perfume created in 2004 by Francis Kurkdjian is a masterpiece for me. The Lutens spirit quickly returns with the immortelle which gains momentum and sets up a leathery, spicy and virile note that seems to nod to Serge Lutens Cuir Mauresque. As the fragrance develops Serge Lutens La Proie pour l’Ombre opens with draped in soft vanilla, which twists around a rosy floral note. I also perceive a chocolate facet which gives an even more delicious roundness to the skin. The earthy and sweet licorice is still present, but stays in the background, in perfect balance with the leathery and spicy side of immortelle. At the dry down the vanilla remains, but the perfume doesn’t lose its leathery intensity and as I always apply perfume before I sleep, it does have overnight longevity. A beautiful piece by Emmanuel a house that I have heard a lot of good things about. I am loving the notes especially licorice and leather in particular. I would love to try cuir maresque. Thanks a lot from the UK

  • Serge Lutens was my gateway to a perfume world, Feminite du Bois was the first fragrance I tried and still my favorite one. I have owned and smelt many different Lutens but have difficulties picking the most “Lutensian”.
    I am very eagerly anticipating the launch of the new gem, true Lutens, as Emmanuelle named it. Based on the reviews and notes, I have to try it. I mused at Emmanuelle admitting how difficult is to pin down the Serge La Proie Pour l’Ombre, but still perfectly depicts the development of the fragrance on his skin. Thanks for letting us know about Serge La Proie Pour l’Ombre and the opportunity to sniff it before the launch.

    Greetings from Slovenia.

  • Emmanuelle’s review was great.. & now i know my bf isn’t the only person that puts on fragrances before bed LoL licorice, immortelle & heliotrope seems like a mysterious mix from beginning to end but very intriguing very!! No, i haven’t had chance to try any Serge Lutens Perfume but after this review i most definitely will!! Ohio USA, thanks for chance to win & introducing us & good luck everyone!!

  • This sounds dark and melancholy, two themes I appreciate in perfume. Mr. Lutens’ life is fascinating, such a mysterious figure. I also love licorice notes; I think they add an element of strangeness int perfumery, so this appeals to me. Chergui is the perfume I most associate with the Lutens brand, but is this because it actually epitomizes the brand or because of its great success? Thanks for introducing me to this new release! I would love to sample it. I live in the U.S.A.

  • Great review! In addition to the lovely imagery and incredible powers of description, I enjoyed learning about Serge Lutens and his fragrances, as well as the unusual mystique he brings to his products. This review taught me a lot. I don’t have much experience with Lutens fragrances. Thus, it’s hard for me to say which I find most “Lutensian.” I think it would have to be Chergui by default! Cheers from NC, USA.

  • A new true Lutens! Like Emanuelle I like them dark, deep, heady an hard to pin down. I can’t wait to try this one.
    I’m in EU

  • BostonScentGuy says:

    You definitely had me at “true Lutens.” When I heard the notes list for this, I was both thrilled and nervous, given some of the other promising newer releases that fell flat for me. I love the description of the “hide and seek notes.” That to me is a hallmark of Lutens work–a strange cacophony that arranges itself into a beautiful aesthetic whole eventually. So many Lutens epitomize that for me–particularly Fumerie Turque, Ambre Sultan, Tubereuse Criminelle, and Chergui. Those are some of my favorites. Bois de Violette is more composed and less chaotic, but it’s also hard to not call that beauty quintessentially Lutens given the birth of the brand style with Feminite du Bois. Thanks for the draw! I’m in the US (Colorado).

  • emorandeira says:

    Emmanuelles review is great! I like how he introduce the reader in the Lutens work before beggining… How the brand never makes public all the notes, the mistery behind this brand… Then I LOVE how he describes the New fragrance includong It into the Lutens world. This is amazing!
    I have tried only a fee Lutens but my favourite is Vitriol d’oillet. It is my favourite Carnation perfume and I think It is very lutensian because It is difficult to describe It with words!
    My name is Edgar (parfum_sindromico) and I am writing from Tenerife, Spain (EU)

  • Serge Lutens is known for his artistry when creating perfumes and this one promises to keep that up!
    It sounds like a really “sneaky” perfume, with twists and turns of leather, licorice and vanilla, with several other “distant” notes, such as heliotrope or immortelle seeming to pop up now and then.
    My favorite Lutens is Fille de Berlin, but the most Lutensian maybe is Dent de lait for me. Never really understood that one!
    I am in the EU.
    Thanks!

  • I am always interested in a Lutens release and was immediately sucked in by the mention of the immortelle. Emmanuelle’s mentiom of Cuir Mauresque has me curious. I am a big fan of Lutens L’innommable which is often brought up in the discussion of immortalize, so would love to compare. The licorice makes me nervous but I am willing to risk it. I love in the US

  • I have tried a few Serge Lutens scents and they have all been lovely. The idea of vanilla and licorice sounds mysterious and familiar all at once. I love both and think this would be a perfect fragrance. In maryland.

  • sephrenia300 says:

    Lovely review Emmanuelle! What appeals to you about Emmanuelle’s review is her description of the never-ending quest to tease out “hidden notes” in La Proie pour l’Ombre, and how it resulted in for some a liquorice note, for others a floral accord. I love a perfume that is different things to different people – we can all find our own meaning in them. Above all else, I also love a perfume that makes you think – that makes you work for it!

    If the mark of a truly “Lutensian” perfume is as Emmanuelle said that it is “dark, deep, heady and seemingly difficult to pin down”, I would argue that Feminite du Bois is the most fitting. At once light and dark, feminine and masculine, with notes that seem to hide and emerge amongst others, a playful game of seeking and mystery. I find that Feminite changes not only person to person, but also hour to hour on my own skin – and I love it. It always keeps me guessing!

  • Andrei Artimon says:

    The presentation and stories behind this fragrance really appeal to me. The most Lutensian perfume for me is probably Gratte-Ciel. I live in New York, usa.

  • I liked most about the review the way it was approached by the author – very reflective, receptive and open for the experience. My most Lutesian perfume is “Ambre sultan”

    Living in the EU

  • I loved Emmanuelle’s exploration of the partnership between Lutens and Sheldrake, and the details about the name’s meaning.

    For me the most Lutensian fragrance is the original, pre-reformulation De Profundis.

    I live in Canada.

  • There aren’t many perfumes that have the kind of magical mystery that Emmanuelle experiences with Serge La Proie Pour l’Ombre. I liked Emmanuelle’s review because instead of it being a linear, one-dimensional review (Serge La Proie Pour l’Ombre is like this, and that’s it), she describes her, accidental, serendipitous, discoveries as it changes with multiple sprays, different times, on different people, and so on. It left me with a deeper, more mysterious, sense of what Serge La Proie Pour l’Ombre is all about. I like perfumes that change over time, and change based on one’s own state of mind, etc. As in true art appreciation, then the task of grasping at the substance rather than its shadows becomes a long, sometimes life-long process. I am very intrigued by Serge La Proie Pour l’Ombre based on Emmanuelle’s review. Unfortunately don’t have any experience with Serge Luten perfumes, so can’t choose the most Lutensian. Thanks for the review and draw. From USA.

  • wallygator88 says:

    Thank you for the great review Emmanuelle.

    I love to read fragrance reviews when the notes are not mentioned and the fact that there are other people who have received samples of it is so interesting! Reading the percieved notes and the official notes, one marvels at the ability of our noses to percieve.

    The scent is beautiful – mysterious, seductive and alluring.

    I would love to get a nose on it.

    I think Serge Lutens L’Eau is quite Lutential.

    Cheers from WI, USA

  • constancesuze says:

    Always excited for a new Lutens! I haven’t had the opportunity to test his most recent work, but I’ve heard many good things. My favorites are De Profundis, Rose de Nuit, and Une Voix Noire. And Ambre Sultan. But the most Lutensian has to be Feminite du Bois, no?
    Beautiful review, I was particularly happy to learn about the source of the name. So many of Lutens fragrance names have interesting stories.

  • I hadn’t really thought of the Lutens characteristics until now. Perhaps the one that I’ve tried which best fits your description is Chergui. The dark, deep fragrance with hints of light and contrasts to create the illusion of shadowplay. The comparison to Dior Eau Noire has made me very curious about La Proie Pour l’Ombre.
    I live in Denmark, EU.

  • wandering_nose says:

    The notes in this are so abstract and at the same heavenly seductive! And Emmanuelle has managed to showcase that beautifully by explaining the genesis of the name of the fragrance as well as the personal story from Lutens’ youth. I adore dark fragrances, dark vanilla is my ever fave one, and since licorice, amber, heliotrope and benzoin can only make it better, I would love to try La Proie Pour l’Ombre. I have only tried some of Serge Lutens’ fragrances but of those I have, Chergui and Ambre Sultan would be the most ‘Lutensian’ to me. Thank you from Ireland, EU

  • I’m curious about the chocolate note that is described in Emmanuelle’s review. This sounds like the perfect scent for fall and winter. I haven’t tried any perfume from Serge Lutens yet, and therefore I can’t answer which perfume is the most “Lutensian”. However, if I win and get to try Serge La Proie Pour l’Ombre, It will for sure be the most “Lutensian” perfume in my book. Thanks for the draw!
    I live in Sweden, EU

  • This leather sounds sexy.
    I love Serge Lutens fragrances. I have de profundis, la fille de Berlin and a la nuit.
    But the most Lutensian SL fragrance for me is Santal Majuscule, I don’t have it, but I hope I will.
    From mexico.

  • Elizabeth Adam says:

    Wow, this review is so spot on. I now own a 100 ml bottle, was given 2 samples by my perfumer at the end of august, he also had a sample bottle and sprayed me. The entire experience of this perfume has been addictive, at times difficult to pinpoint, changing, but continuously present. I had to have this! My partner’s first response when I put this on the first time was: what’s that smell? You smell like an ancient kitchen larder of an old mansion. This was not an insult, he was very in fact very accurate. Some might not consider this a ‘Perfume’, but for me at he moment there is no scent to top this one. So I guess I will not be rewarded with the the free sameple. Thank you Serge Lutens.