Sarah Horowitz Parfums Pride And Carnation Review (Sarah Horowitz-Thran) +The Flower of Life Draw

Sean Connery as James Bond in Goldfinger              

Carnation – the flower of life, love and remembranceCarnation – the preferred boutonnière of dandies and dancers, stars and statesmen.The delicate, unmistakably spicy aroma of the carnation (also known to many as "dianthus", the flower of the gods) has been incorporated into myriad perfumes for at least a century. Today we have become so familiar with the scent of carnation, either by way of skillfully created accords or expensive carnation absolutes that many of us have come to take for granted this wondrous, fragile flower.

 Carnations, illustration from "Laurels From Browning", 1906, from Gail's collection                  

 A list of carnation perfumes reads like a history of olfactory art. I adore the scent of the flower, full blown, wafting from the likes of Krasnaya Moskva (1913- 1925), Caron Bellodgia, (1927) and DSH Perfumes Oelliets Rouges (2003). Olfactory classics such as Guy Laroche Fidji (1966), YSL Opium (1977) and Dior Poison (1985), to name but a few, rely on carnation for a spicy punch or a bright green edge.  There is no doubt that the scent of carnation in perfume is at once playful, innocent and provocative.  It can even be downright salacious.

 Pride and Carnation Bottle Art by Gail ©                     

All that being said, I wondered, when I first heard of Sarah Horowitz Parfums Pride and Carnation, if anything original could possibly be said or done with this old floral favorite.  My first whiff instantly revealed that Sarah Horowitz-Thran's newest perfume, her homage to the legendary JAR Golconda, is indeed a rare, original, beautifully crafted and balanced carnation. More than a solifore, Sarah Horowitz Parfums Parfum Pride and Carnation is, simultaneously, a fresh, sultry, rich, glimmering, lustrous, velvety-smooth take (Yes!  All of those things!) on the flower of the gods.

Sarah Horowitz Thran of Sarah Horowitz Parfums

 A Limited Edition Banq de Parfum,  Pride and Carnation, named for Sarah Horowitz-Thran's engaging, very personal and self-reflective first experience of JAR Golconda (see Sarah Horowitz Parfums Smell-o-Vision for the full story) opens with a wet, slightly green and spicy carnation, fresh from the garden or the florist's cooler. This bright and gentle wake-me-up wafts just enough peppery sweet clove and cinnamon to put a smile on my face and a twinkle in my eye. Within moments the sparkle of Sarah Horowitz Parfums Pride and Carnation melts into warm, cozy relaxation as an aura born of Moroccan roses, stargazer lilies and what seems to be jasmine lends rich and sensual warmth to the dewy, cool carnation. 


Marilyn Monroe with Carnation Cecil Beaton     

Everything that is most alluring and satisfying about carnations and full-bodied florals simmers in the heart of Parfum Pride and Carnation. I simultaneously sense the ruffled edge of the spicy bloom and a hint of the smooth indolic, intimate warmth that characterizes the lush aromas of white flowers. The perfectly proportioned bouquet that is Pride and Carnation lasts for hours, never overpowering, remaining gently pervasive throughout the dry down, supported by nuances of golden amber and resting on delicate suggestions of benzoin and the subtle, deep, dark mysteries of labdanum.

 Newlywed actors Humphrey Bogart and Lauren Bacall attending wedding reception at the home of novelist Louis Bromfield. Time Magazine

Even though the unabashed floral quality of Pride and Carnation might seem to suggest a strictly feminine scent, I would love (and intend) to smell Pride and Carnation on my man!

Notes: Carnation absolute, Moroccan rose, Stargazer lily, cinnamon, clove, amber, labdanum and benzoin.

Disclaimer: Many thanks to Sarah Horowitz Parfums for the generous samples of Banq de Parfum Pride and Carnation Eau de Parfum. My review is based on my experiences of the Eau de Parfum as well as the Parfum Extrait, which I purchased myself.  My opinions are my own.

Gail Gross – Senior Editor

Art Director-Michelyn Camen, Editor-in-Chief

Pride and Carnation is a limited edition Banq de Parfum and the recipient of two CaFleureBon Best of Scent 2018 awards (Gail and Ida)

Thanks to the generosity of Sarah Horowitz Parfums, we have one 30 ml bottle of Sarah Horowitz Parfums Pride and Carnation for one registered reader in the Continental US only. To be eligible, please leave a comment saying what appeals to you about Sarah Horowitz Parfums Pride and Carnation, based on Gail’s review. You can also tell us about your favorite fragrance from Sarah Horowitz Parfums or if you are inclined to wear carnation perfumes. Draw closes 1/13/2018

Follow us on Instagram: @cafleurebon @azarsmith7 and @sarahhorowitzparfums

We announce the winners only on site and on our Facebook page, so Like ÇaFleureBon and use our Blog feed…or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume.  

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


31 comments

  • I’ve been fascinated by carnation for years. My current favorites are Caron’s classic Bellodgia, and Guerlain’s Metallica. I love that Gail indicates that this has a long life. (US based)

  • In Germany carnations are often used at funerals, so i was a little off out when I noticed there are many carnation fragrances out there. And after trying some of them I can freely admit that I adore carnation fragrances. I also find carnation fragrances to be warm and very unisex.
    Thank you so much. I am in the US.

  • Carnation is truly a unisex note, imho. I didn’t know that it was in Dior Poison. All of the other ingredients sound like they would blend well together, especially the clove and cinnamon. USA

  • Oh my! I love the scent of carnations, and a favorite of mine is L’Artisan’s Oeilllet Sauvage. I like carnation so much that I bought my DH Serge Lutens’ Vitriol d’Oeillet as a blind buy! Among other things I like about this review is the photo of Sean Connery with his carnation boutonniere, oozing elegant sex appeal. I am in the continental US. Thanks!

  • Carnations are a beautiful flower and I love the scent of them. I agree that they are warm and can be unisex. To have a perfume from Sarah Horowitz based off of that would be wonderful! She makes the best perfumes and I should know because I have a few of them. I am in the continental US.

  • Carnations are a beautiful flower and I love the scent of them. I agree that they are warm and can be unisex. To have a perfume from Sarah Horowitz based off of that would be wonderful! She makes the best perfumes and I should know because I have a few of them. I am in the continental US.

  • hotlanta linda says:

    Great writing, as always! I love the richness of the scent expressed here. I`ve many of SHP scents by the bottle because my nose can`t pick! 🙂 We are in the USA.

  • patrick_348 says:

    I like the description of the scent as not too assertive but long lasting. That is just the balance I prefer. Carnations produce a lot of scent memory for me, so I think I would enjoy the fragrance. I am in the US.

  • Thank you Gail for the wonderful review. I’ve been interested in this perfume since I saw Sarah’s video about it since I really like a carnation note. At the moment I am wearing SHP’s Perfect Gardenia to bed most nights.

    There is carnation blended into many fragrances I like, but two that come to mind especially are Diana Vreeland Devastatingly Chic and CdG Red Carnation, and of course a good vintage Opium.

    I’m in the Continental US. Thank you for this generous draw.

  • Grandiflora says:

    What appeals to me most about Sarah Horowitz Parfums Pride and Carnation, based on Gail’s review is the true appreciation for the carnation. Every description made me appreciate this little flower even more. If Sarah really has found “a fresh, sultry, rich, glimmering, lustrous, velvety-smooth take (Yes! All of those things!) on the flower of the gods”, I definitely want to experience it! Based on this review, and my own research, I would say my favorite fragrance from Sarah Horowitz Parfums would probably be Perfect Love. I’m definitely inclined to try a carnation perfume, as I’ve never owned one before. I do adore the carnation flower though! I’m in the U.S.

  • ” A velvet smooth take on the flower of the gods”…..wow!!! I would love to try this!!! I haven’t tried any SHP fragrances yet but now have a new house to explore. thank you for this draw. USA

  • Thank you for the review, Gayle. I do indeed love the scent of carnations and my go to scents are by DSH Perfumes and Etro Dianthus. This scent showed up on more than one of Cafleurebon editor’s best lists so I am very intrigued. I’m also curious as it was inspired by the JAR scent which I never got to try. Thanks for the chance!
    I”m in the USA

  • doveskylark says:

    This review made me think how nice it is fro a man to wear a carnation on his lapel. I wish that tradition would come back. I just love the idea of the opening of this perfume being like opening a florist’s cooler. I do love carnation scents, especially Fidji.
    I live in the USA.

  • A carnation fragrance! This one sounds so lovely and I loved all of the pictures, Marilyn and Sean, they make it all that more intriguing! A velvet smooth, sounds great! Thank you Gayle for the great article. I enjoyed reading it. I live in California,

  • Don’t think I’ve smelled a carnation fragrance yet. I see that most like
    The scent and this fragrance has a warmth to it and lasts long. Haven’t tried a fragrance from this House yet. Thanks for the giveaway. U.S

  • With The description of this fragrance by Gail, I can’t wait to try it!! It sounds amazing! I love carnations and stargazers and spices! I’d love to win a sample! Thank you

  • What appeals to me of the fragrance is the magic and beauty of the scent of Carnations. I love stargazers and carnations. I thank you Cafleurebon and the team that bring such great fragrances to us. I live in CA, USA.

  • I adore carnation fragrances because of their scent. It’s refreshing and reminds me of my grandma. They are very warm and I believe it’s unisex also.
    I live in California.

  • I would love to try this and add a carnation to my scent library, and the decryption (yes! All those things!) seemed… joyful! The images were also great, and I would love to smell this on my partner. I wouldst love to be able to grow carnations in my garden, much preferable to getting them from the store. Thank you for the great draw, I’m in the us.

  • Registered CONUS resident
    What appealed to me was how she compared the perfume’s texture to the flower’s rough edges, also how she intended to spray down her man!
    Only ever tried Perfect Cocnut Milk which based on the fact that I now have some..she’s batting a thousand with me so far. Love to get my nose on this.
    Love carnation perfumes especially SL Vitriol d’Œillet and especially Oeilliets Rouges by DSH which I also own in the pure parfum! I’m a carnarion fanboy for sure!

    smell swell & be well,
    VP xox

  • Wow carnation! That’s a beautiful flower and a challenging note for perfumers to work with. When done correctly, it’s sooo amazing and the texture it exudes is out of this world.
    I’d love to get to know this how and this masterful perfumer!
    Thanks for the draw I’m at the USA

  • Thanks for another great review, Gail! I love this part of your review as I love carnations- ‘More than a solifore, Sarah Horowitz Parfums Parfum Pride and Carnation is, simultaneously, a fresh, sultry, rich, glimmering, lustrous, velvety-smooth take (Yes!  All of those things!) on the flower of the gods.’ I haven’t tried any of her perfumes yet so I hope I win. Thanks for this opportunity. – CA, USA

  • Thank-You Gayle for the delicious review and so much Thanks to Sarah for creating this lovely sounding Parfum and donating a bottle for one of us to try so generous. I think the mix of carnation absolute with cinnamon amber and Morrocan rose oooh I can almost imagine it. The description has me wanting it and with the smooth long lasting quality you describe I’ve gotta have it! I have Caron and Diana V but I’d love to try this, Many thanks again to Sarah Horowitz for giving us here a chance.

  • I don’t think carnations get enough love!! I have them in my garden and they bloom for such a long time. I never thought of their scent as their best quality, but I’d love to try what Sarah can do with this flower. I have not smelled any of Sarah’s fragrances. I don’t have a carnation dominant fragrance in my collections. Thanks for the chance. USA.

  • I don’t generally wear floral scents, but I love carnations – I’d take a bouquet of carnations over roses any day. I never quite understood why carnations didn’t have the cachet of their pricier cousins. As far as I’m concerned, they have a more complex scent, they last so much longer, and they’re every bit as attractive. I’d love to give this scent a try, so thanks for the review and draw! I live in the U.S.

  • I got a sample of this and I LOVE IT! It has a nice spicy note to it, along with carnation and it’s absolutely gorgeous! I’d love to own a full bottle of it! My favorite fragrance is The Now.

    I live in the USA.

  • Loved the description “Pride and Carnation is, simultaneously, a fresh, sultry, rich, glimmering, lustrous, velvety-smooth take… on the flower of the gods.”

    I am a faithful wearer of Bellodgia and look forward to sampling Pride and Carnation.

    USA

  • Gail’s description of Sarah Horowitz’s Pride & Carnation having “full-bodied florals” is alluring. Carnation with its fresh spiciness is always interesting but it’s easy to pass over the softer floral components of it. So getting that “ruffled edge of the spicy bloom” and the indolic hint — I adore indolic components of flowers like lilac, tuberose, jasmine; the earthy alongside the lush floral— is a neat hat trick. Carnation flower and its theatrical associations has particular meaning for me in my ancestry. I would love to see what Sarah has conjured here. Thanks Gail for the marvelous description. I live in New York City.

  • There isn’t a note in this fragrance that I don’t adore. This sounds like something I would absolutely love. Thanks to Gail for a wonderful review, and thanks to Sarah Horowitz for creating Pride & Carnation. I can hardly wait to try it. Thank you for the draw. I’m in the USA

  • I’m interested since the description sounds multidimensional. I’m not too familiar with the carnation note though. But a spicy and indolic approach makes me think of jasmin a bit?
    Im not familiar with the house, and im not sure which fragrances I have which have a carnation note.

    im in the US. thanks for the draw

  • I have not experienced Sarah Horowitz Parfums, but Gail’s description of Pride & Carnations opening of “the florist’s cooler” has me sold. I can smell and feel the cold wetness of it. I’ve owned fragrances that claim a carnation element however I am unable to discern such. So I want to get this on skin. Thanks for the giveaway California