New Niche Fragrance Review: Serge Lutens La Vierge de Fer + Lily Amongst the Thorns Draw

SL La Vierge de Fer Marlene Header CaFleureBon

There is speculation that the famous Medieval torture device that came to be known as “The Iron Maiden” may not have been Medieval at all, nor used at the time for torture. We have all flinched at depictions of its use in horror movies; the decorative, human sized cabinet filled with sharp spikes, the screams of the victim the last thing you hear as the door swings shut. To name a perfume La Vierge de Fer is bold; the connotations are going to be pretty dark. Serge Lutens is famous for applying unusual naming protocols to his perfumes, accompanying them with inspirational text that can be enigmatic. La Vierge de Fer is no exception, as evidenced by the last paragraph of the description: “… For that, not fearing incest, we will embrace it. In this way, she will give birth to our most beautiful monsters. That is how, a little rusty by dint of doubts, my steps have rejoined La vierge de fer (the Iron Maiden); that lily amongst the thorns.” I was grateful for the “lily amongst the thorns” portion of that paragraph, because it explains the whole perfume.

lily among thorns gail vass

Lily Among Thorns by Gail Vass

When I first received my bottle of the perfume, I dabbed some on to get a preliminary impression, which I often do when I have a new perfume in front of me. My immediate reaction was that it was a lily version of Fracas: a dense and rich floral with a vintage feel. Not foreboding in the least, and not reminiscent of menacing torture devices. I wasn’t even sure if it lived up to the full-bodied reputation of the Serge Lutens line. Not content to experience the perfume only by dabbing, I decanted some into a spray bottle, and that was the trick.

A_Lily_among_the_Thorns_by_rigelblack

A Lily Among the Thorns by Rigel Black

Although still not menacing, I understood the “lily amongst thorns” concept much better. The fragrance blooms on skin, big, bold, a little fruity, with a hint of rose and spice and lots of heady lily. I imagine this to be akin to heavy floral perfumes of old, and the word “thick” springs to mind, bringing to life the heavy, waxy blooms of lilies. Were it not for the bright, fruity aura, this scent could head into funereal territory pretty quickly. As it is, it’s quite enchanting, and I feel a bit glamorous even in my current loungewear.

a rose between the thorns val kenyon

A Rose Between the Thorns by Val Kenyon

Despite its powerhouse first hour or so, La Vierge de Fer is a bit disappointing as far as longevity goes, on my skin. I can usually hang on to Serge Lutens perfumes for quite a while, but this one goes strong for a couple of hours, then dribbles down to a vague, typical lily, then is gone. One could wear it to make a grand entrance at a party, then eventually blend in with the crowd. Of course, this is my personal experience, and yours may be different. That said, I do like it. It isn’t my favorite Lutens, but it is well-done and consistent with the more recent offerings in the line.

I received my bottle from the generous people at Serge Lutens. La Vierge de Fer is a Serge Lutens Paris exclusive.

Tama Blough, Senior Editor

We have a draw for our US readers for a 5 ml decant. Please let us know what draws you to this perfume, and remember to let us know you are in the US. Draw ends October 29, 2013.

We announce the winners only on site and on our Facebook page, so Like Cafleurebon and use our RSS option…or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


33 comments

  • I’m in the US and a fan of both Lutens and lilies; tuberose hates me, but lilies and I get along, and I think it’s worth sampling every Serge perfume because they’re almost always interesting. Thanks for the review, and the draw.

  • Tama ~ I whole heartedly agree with your beautiful review. Many time SL fragrances and Lily fragrances and I do not see eye to eye, this one is gorgeous on the skin, I cannot stop sniffing my arm 🙂

  • Lilly and more lily! That is worth sampling and then throw in the Lutens factor and there is no doubt I want a sniff.

  • I love Lily perfumes. Uncle Serge ,ay be hit or miss with me but they are always interesting.
    I am in the US.

    Thanks!

  • Thanks for the review. I am falling behind (by about 3 years) on trying SL’s newer offerings. I love florals, but on me they are always very ephemeral. I guess that’s what keeps us spraying and interested…to experience that first rush again and again. I am in the USA

  • Doreen Stelton says:

    lusty lilly! so intoxicating. maybe it’s a good thing it doesn’t last too long… US< here.

  • I adore so many of Serge Lutens line and even the ones that don’t agree with me I admire and appreciate. Lily is a tricky note on me and I’m still searching for my perfect lily frag. Maybe this is it! I am in the U.S. Thanks for the draw!

  • I admire Lutens so much, I just need to try this-even if lily is difficult for me, this one may just be “the one”
    I have an US address

  • wefadetogray says:

    I am in the US. I love lilies and I like to try all Serge Lutens whether they are really for me or not.
    Thanks 🙂

  • Fazal Cheema says:

    Lutens has always been known for fragrances that hit you hard at the very first sniff and it is arguably the first Lutens fragrance that is so nonLutens in some aspects. I am in the US

  • With a hint of rose and spice like you said that sounds interesting.I would like to try ut. I live in the USA

  • I can’t believe the timing of this article! Yesterday was my birthday, and I received a bouquet featuring Casa Blanca lilies! The scent is so amazing and soft, unlike Stargazer lilies, which I love, but the dense scent can be slightly overwhelming. I like the idea of white lily with rose and spice! I would love to try this. I am in the US. Thanks for the draw!

  • I love lily perfumes in general. My favorite is DK Gold, which is also a rich lily. I’d love to try the Lutens, and I live in the US.

  • Sarah Lathrop says:

    I live in the U.S. and would love to try this perfume because I am a huge fan of Serge Lutens fragrances. I am not always a lover of floral perfumes, but this one sounds deeper and more interesting than most floral compositions. Thank you for offering to give out a sample!

  • I love lily and Serge Lutens’ perfumes are always interesting! There are many that I enjoy. I am in the US.

  • I carried a huge bouquet of Casablanca lilies as my wedding bouquet and have yet to find the perfume equivalent. I would love to try this and live in the U.S.

  • Hmm, rich and thick, lily, hints of rose and spice. Adore Serge’s spice and flower offerings. La Vierge de Fer seems different, unusual. Dark, but not dangerous. I’d love a sample, please. I am in the USA.

  • I’m in the US and have yet to really satisfactorily explore the lily note. Although I liked Serge’s Un Lys, so I’m interested to see how this compares.

  • I am head over heels with big florals especially tuberose, i.e. Tubereuse Criminelle, so I am always eager to try other big floral scents. Maybe this one will rock my world as well. Im in the US and thanks for the opportunity.

  • Your description of this being thick and heady, reminiscent of vintage heavy florals, is what is drawing me to this. That just crosses many of my t’s and dots i’s. I have recently really started liking heavy lily scents, and would love to try this lush lady. I live in the US.

  • Six months ago I’d have said I didn’t like floral perfumes, but it turns out I love arum lilies. I’m in the US. Thanks!

  • I love the smell of lilies, but have yet to find one that’s as beautiful to me as DK Gold. Would love to see if this does the trick! I’m in the US.

  • Very intriguing review! I would love to try this; I adore lilies and almost anything by Serge Lutens! I have and love Un Lys so I am curious to see what this latest take on the lily is. I live in the U.S.