Instead of our Molecular Moses, Neil Sternberg or our CMO (Chief Molecular Officer) Mark Behnke reviewing this book which really could be subtitled (The Trouble with IFRA ), the task is mine, the former Literature and Fine Arts Major (in fact, I had contemplated an article called Molecules for Morons).
As I mentioned recently on FaceBook to Perfumer Maurice Roucel, I read and re-read Chandler Burr's Emporer of Scent four times before I finally understood Mr. Turin's Shape vs.Vibrational theory of Smell.
It was after the fourth reading that I began to understand a little more about Mr. Turin's reviews in the 2008 BIG White book… Perfumes from A-Z . I now know why he refers to Reimann's Conjecture when speaking about my friend-in- fragrance artist Nobi Shiyoa's 100% Love. Mr Turin has the equivalent of perfect pitch when it comes to smell. Sacre Nobi commisioned Sophia Grosjman to create a fragance for his installation when we went behind the bottle. It is one of my favorite fragrances and when once asked him why it wasn't a commercial sucess, he replied, '100% Love smells good on people who smell good naturally'. But I digress. The Little Book of Fagrance is really Ms. Sanchez's post scripts circa 2011. The Little Book of Perfume consolidate the BEST OF THE BEST reviews from the Big White book's 1800 reviews, and an addition of four vintage fragrances and a wonderful commentary on Osmotheque in Versailles.
I don't want to spoil what made the cut, but of note, is the radical change in the Dior formulations by Edmond Roudnitska, which have watered down his brillaint work . In addition Amouage Homage ("irrestistable'), Histoires de Parfums 1790, all Lauder fragrances, Angel by Thierry Mugler, Parfum de Nicolai perfumer Patricia de Nicolai , the grandaughter of Pierre Guerlain still earns rave reviews (although her New York is "damaged goods" based on the restrictions on oakmosss and citrus) . Guerlain, Caron,and Chanel had mixed reviews. Good news for Fracas and Knize 10 lovers; Ms. Sanchez writes they are even better! Ormande Jaye Woman is still 'great" and L'Eau de Feu issey is still discontinued. Calice Becker's Tommy Girl and Etat Libre de Orange Secretions Magnifique are exactly the same…magnifique. Serge Lutens is still godlike and Patou Joy is still a joy. According to Ms. Sanchez the current version of Calandre outpaces Rive Gauche; this is a reversal of fortune.
Ms. Sanchez named Bertrand Duchaoufour and Jean Claude Ellena the new guardians of fragrance and noted their styles were similar (Bertrand told me that nothing can be further from the truth). Also I believe that M. Ellena is of a different generation whereas M. Duchaufour is in his prime. There is no reference to Maurice Roucel for his work on Feminite de Bois.
There is a lovely credit to Luckyscent but a bit of a plug for the Perfume Court. Department and specialty stores take note.
I did hope that some of the brilliant scents created post 2008 would be included but they were not.
– Michelyn Camen,, Editor in Chief
I am giving away my advance copy of The Little Book of Perfumes to a commentor. Since you have not read it (it goes on sale October 27, 2011); you can preorder on Amazon.com. I would love to hear your thoughts on the first book or which fragrances created post 2008 you would like to see in the next book. Draw ends October 17, 2011.