Xerjoff Mamluk Review (Chris Maurice) 2012 + the But/And DRAW

 

Xerjoff Mamluk oud stars by Chris Maurice

And  ©Chris Morgan

 

About 10 years ago, I had a realization: everything that comes before “but…” is irrelevant.

For 2000 years of dialectic rhetoric, we’ve been taught to fragment our figments of thoughts into contradicting notions, as a proof of mental prowess and power of context (gosh, I, myself, define myself as a contextual thinker, so there’s that). In other words, showing off how many angles you understand about an issue is common, accepted, and expected if you want to be taken seriously, no matter if the conversation is about high concepts or picking colors for your pantry paint.

Why, then, the irremediable habit of always having to pick a path? Why is imbalance or partiality so hard to assume, adopt, and use as an intellectual tool?

 

Best Xerjoff Oud Stars

And  ©Paola Saetti

This year, with social distancing in place, I had another realization: it’s not that what comes before “but” is irrelevant. IT’S THE “BUT” THAT MAKES IT SO.            

Replace “but” with “and”, and the whole construct becomes alive with possibilities. “I can be soft at times, AND I am a warrior”; “The song is sad, AND it is beautiful”; “She’s right, AND so are you”. The benefits of “yes, AND” are not new; to stand proof we have concepts like “opposites attract”; the esthetic of the ugly (think Baudelaire, if not more recent currents in positive modelling); the devil’s advocate; the silver lining, the golden cage; juxtapositions, contrasts, oxymorons, even jokes.

It’s all there:  even when society is forcing us to use the “but”, WE LOVE THE “AND”.

best black and white photos

And ©Street Hunters

Despite my faulty childhood knowledge that allowed us to call each other mameluci whenever we were scared, whiny, or soft at play, I now know Mamluks were a major part of the military force in the Levant starting in the 9th century. Slowly rising through arduous martial arts training and meticulous study of court protocols and Islamic sciences, the Mamluks became a governing dynasty in Egypt… BUT they were glorified slaves. Yes, slaves–higher in status than the household slaves; higher even than the common Egyptian citizens; educated, rich, and “true lords”; freed and then employed; but a slave cast nonetheless, marred by a painful past made irrelevant by the golden cage of their present.

You were made a slave, BUT look at what you’ve been given now.

 

street inspired perfumes

And ©Sebastian Jacobitz.

Mamluk as redefined by Chris Maurice is a rare case of spot-on marketing: “delicate brutality”, they say, and I couldn’t agree more: this is hardened but not sharp, intense but sweet, heavy but simple–just like, say, a brutalist piece of silver jewelry. The opening of Xerjoff Mamluk  is very sweet and somewhat liquid-crystalline, honeyesque, with transparent drops of syrup and citrusy resins. As they redistribute, the body becomes slightly cloudy and further from the nose; a wave of opaque florals take center, alongside a (salty) caramel and what seems to be a very dry, light wood. When the base settles, the whole composition is catching texture and volume and becomes grave: used leathers, dust, animal sweat, and a tinge of iron-y saltiness (think blood-in-the-mouth) bring this into wild territory, like a tainted legacy one cannot escape.

Brutal, indeed… but AND sensitive.

 

Xerjoff Mamluk review

Photos, collage, creative direction, and digital editing by a_nose_knows for Xerjoff Mamluk.

Official notes: musk, jasmine, bergamot, vanilla, honey, benzoin, agarwood, osmanthus

Other perceived notes: dates, salt, flowery accord, suede, peach, dry woods, dust, metallic bits

Disclaimer:  Tester of Xerjoff Mamluk provided by Europerfumes. Thank you much.

dana sandu, Editor

 

Xerjoff Mamluk

Xerjoff Mamluk  via Xerjoff

Xerjoff Mamluk was composed in 2012 by Chris Maurice and is part of the Oud Stars Collection.

Thanks to the generosity of Europerfumes the USA distributor, we have a 50 ml TESTER of Xerjoff Mamluk (ONLY IN THE USA) for one registered reader (you must register on our site or your comment will not count). To be eligible, please tell us what you enjoyed or found interesting about dana’s review, if you’ve tried any from Xerjoff Oud Stars collection before. Draw closes 9/28/20

Available to purchase or sample at Luckyscent.com here

This is our Privacy and Draw Rules Policy

Follow us on Instagram @cafleurebon   @a_nose_knows  @official_europerfumes @xerjoff

We announce the winners only on our site and on our Facebook page, so like Çafleurebon and use our blog feed…or  your dream prize will be just spilled perfume.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


55 comments

  • Andrei Artimon says:

    Really love the house and everithing they do , i have many of they re offerings , i have alexandria 2 as the oud favourite , new york , usa.

  • YES! I loved this review focusing on how we can be so many things at once. Especially the delicate brutality thing, I resonated with that. Snaps for Dana. I’ve never had the opportunity to smell anything from that xerjoff oud stars line, but I would love to. This fragrance sounds beautiful and weird, which is right up my alley.

    California, US

  • I have not tried any from Xerjoff Oud Stars Collection but its def on my list! I find the “tinge of iron-y saltiness (think blood-in-the-mouth)” interesting. A perfume almost needs something like this to counter the sweetness. I live in the USA.

  • Intrigued by this article BUT it takes a few readings to understand AND I would like to know more about Mamluk.
    Images are great and I love the idea that Xerjoff Mamluk seems very complex. Fars is my favorite and I really love Xerjoff Ouds.

  • I have not tried any of the Xerjoff Oud Stars collection before. I liked this part of dana’s review; “he opening of Xerjoff Mamluk is very sweet and somewhat liquid-crystalline, honeyesque, with transparent drops of syrup and citrusy resins. As they redistribute, the body becomes slightly cloudy and further from the nose; a wave of opaque florals take center, alongside a (salty) caramel and what seems to be a very dry, light wood. When the base settles, the whole composition is catching texture and volume and becomes grave: used leathers, dust, animal sweat, and a tinge of iron-y saltiness (think blood-in-the-mouth) bring this into wild territory, like a tainted legacy one cannot escape.”. I live in the US, thanks for the draw.

  • Please enter me in your giveaway… I really love Xerjoff fragrances, but I have yet to try this one and smell it. Everything about this fragrance sounds enticing to me and I would love the opportunity to win it! I love his description of the fragrance… breaks it down in a way that makes it very easy to read and relatable. I like how this fragrance opens a little citrusy, then the florals come in for the mid, thin closed with kind of a raw leathery musky and dusty vibe. Everything about the fragrance sounds sexy and really excites me! I have never tried any of Xerjoff’s OUD Stars collection before, but I think that needs to change!! Thank you for the opportunity and I’ve got my fingers crossed!!

  • Haven’t tried Xerjoff Our Stars collection before but have heard great things about them! I definitely love the bottle design, and the combination of bergamot, honey, bezoin & oud sounds wonderful.
    Florida, USA

  • Really nice how you described: simple and sweet. Exactly how I feel about it. This is the best caramel scent available nowadays. Between the whole collection, Mamluk is the best one to me.

  • I remember smelling Mamluk few years ago and liked it. It was caramelly and brutal as the perfumer intended. USA.

  • I can see the relationship to Egypt in the description of the notes: honey, jasmine, leather and dust. It sounds like a timeless fragrance and I get the “delicate brutality” of the composition. I’ve not tried any of the Xerjoff Oud Stars collection but would love to try this! Commenting from the US.

  • This perfume sounds AMAZING. Much of my perfume collection is one or the other – in-your-face, aggro OR delicate and light. I also really enjoy how this post wasn’t a straight-up review – it was a JOURNEY. (An excellent one).

  • Oh wow. The beginning of the review is so intriguing and right! Never thought about it that way, but Dana is so right. Live the notes in this perfume and appreciate the perceived notes too. I feel I can imagine it a much better. I’m from Illinois, US.

  • This article had me thinking. I like that dana lists her perceived notes. I’d love to try a salty peach! Thanks for the opportunity! Mich USA

  • What interested me the most about Dana’s review was the description of the opening. I would love to smell what the liquid-crystalline feeling that was talked about actually exhibits itself as. I have not tried any Oud Stars yet but I would love for this to be my first. Yes I am in the USA.

  • israelfriedmann says:

    I consider it to be the ideal perfume to give to my wife.
    From what I have read, it has some very interesting and mysterious notes.
    It is the perfect style of perfume that she loves.
    That it would be a bit difficult for me to buy it.
    Thank you for the draw. Miami, FL, USA

  • I absolutely love how Dana incorporated grammatical English to show the power of a perfume (I am still in awe of her writing ability). This fragrance sounds mind-blowing. I love the house of Xerjoff as their perfumes are of the highest quality and are works of art. I have not tried Mamluk, but a fragrance that can be “intense but sweet, heavy but simple” sounds absolutely amazing. My favorite Oud Stars is Alexandria II (which is also my favorite perfume of all time, a true masterpiece). I would love love love to get my nose on this fragrance! Kind regards from Illinois, USA.

  • I’m a fan of Xerjoff – Uden, Starlight and Nio to name a few, but haven’t tried any of the Oud Stars.
    Thank you for the excellent review, has me interested for sure.
    Pennsylvania USA

  • I enjoyed what Dana said about using and rather than but, it makes sense. I also found the history she mentioned about the Mamluks interesting as well as the description of the perfume Mamluk, “delicate brutality”. From Xerjoff’s Oud Stars Collection, so far I’ve only tried Alexandria II and really enjoyed it. From CT USA, thanks for the generous draw.

  • Hashim Madani says:

    What appeals to me about Dana’s Mamluk review are the heart notes; that ‘wave of opaque florals’ and the salty caramel. I’ve tried Alexandria II from the Oud Stars collection and it’s just wonderful, too good. I can’t say the same thing about my decant of Ceylon, unfortunately. It has an overwhelming burnt, charred note that destroys any joy one would want from oud. VA, USA

  • Dana review was captivating as usual.
    Xerjoff sure is both high end, and at the same time up to date brand. I find it important to be well in touch with the modern day era , virtual reality presentations is not something you can see every day. I do remember Sebastian said it in one of his videos on YouTube.
    Challenging fragrance for sure, sweet, caramel, salty with moderate dose of animalics. Interesting to see how Mamluk would work on me.
    For clubbing I have Lira , my favorite Xerjoff .
    Oud Stars Collection i have not tried yet.
    Fantastic draw. In USA

  • I really enjoyed the discussion of the interplay between but/and, and how this translates into the two competing concepts of delicate and brutal in Mamluk. I haven’t tried much from Xerjoff, and nothing from the Oud Stars collection yet. CA, USA.

  • You had me at “delicate brutality”. What’s not to love about a sticky sweet anamalic fragrance – especially a Xerjoff. Thanks for this opportunity USA

  • Wow another Xerjoff giveaway. I have such respect for the brand.
    I’m really vain, and wearing Xerjoff is a special experience . I feel untouchable like Eliot Ness .
    My favorites are Lira and Opera . Love them equally.
    I have not smelled it , or any of OUD STARS collection , but I can relate to Mamluk because of how kinky it is .
    I’m so excited for this giveaway, USA
    Regards

  • redwheelbarrow says:

    Lovely review. I have not tried this one yet but the seemingly contrary scents sound just gorgeous. I love your description of how we can be many seemingly discordant things at once. I’m interested in how the sweet honey melds with the florals and grave notes you describe. Thank you for the draw. I’m in the US.

  • What I loved about Dana’s review, was the effusive and overabundant verbage she used to explain the contrasts in the fragrance. Also, I always enjoy a good history lesson, which she tied nicely to the contrasts in the fragrance.

    I haven’t tried anything from from the Xerjoff Oud Stars collection.

    I live in Waldorf, MD, USA.

  • m.r.everything says:

    Mamluk was on my list to sample when I recently did a little sample haul from Luckyscent, but was beat out by about 10 other Xerjoff’s. Not that I still don’t want to try it, badly, but others from the same brand were higher on my list, including Alexandria II and III from the Oud Stars collection. I got both of them and really enjoy them. Mamluk is yet again at the top of my list, number 1, since it was right there anyway, but now that Dana has reassured me that I should be trying it with her beautiful words. I love the “but” & “and” analogy as this was a great way of thinking about how we use these 2 words in different settings! Mamluk is one I definitely need to get my nose on, maybe even blind buy! There is a thrill in blind buying for me… I love it as I do my research beforehand, and usually know whether I am going to like it or not. I have not had a “bad” blind buy to this day! Thank you Dana, for your thoughts on Mamluk, and for getting our brains thinking! Your opinion matters to me and I appreciate you giving us food for thought…. A huge thanks to Europerfumes for your generosity and for this awesome opportunity! You are always so generous and support more giveaways than I can count! You guys are truly appreciated more than you know! As always, a huge thanks to Michelyn, for putting this all together and bringing us this amazing content and these super generous draws! Sending warm wishes and gratitude from Delaware, US. Good luck all and stay safe friends!

  • Enjoyable read as usual , Dana imo is my second favorite reviewer on Cafleurebon .
    Xerjoff is one best niche brands ever created. Of course I can’t say i love all they got , but undoubtedly well blended perfumes , variety is pretty big, so every fragrance lover should be able to find pleasing to his taste fragrance. At this moment I own 6 Xerjoff bottles . My favorite one is exactly Mamluk 🙂
    It’s not by any means for everyone, it’s sweet and cozy , but also ruff and a bit skanky . NEVER blind-buy it, without sampling. You may very well love it, but you could also find it repulsive. Mamluk to me it’s made for the connoisseurs, and not to please the masses, the whole Oud Stars line is. Ceylon and Indochine are maybe the two you could get away with.
    If compliments is what you’re looking for, look elsewhere. There are dozens others pleasing and well made Xerjoff fragrances to choose from.
    I know all , but two from Oud Stars line . The two i don’t know are Alexandria Imperiale , and Alexandria Orientale , both exclusives.
    All the profiles I already follow on Instagram.
    USA

  • I loved how dana’s review commented on both language and the experience of perfumery. Because we often smell notes simultaneously, fragrances can be both sweet and sharp, metallic and soft, masculine and feminine. And she showed how Mamluk may be a perfect example of this. I have read about Xerjoff fragrances for a long time, but have not tried any. In the US, in NC.

  • Haven’t tried this popular house yet. Still on my wishlist. I like that it is intense but sweet. Dries down somewhat complex. Brutal and sensitive. I wanna experience this beauty! IL, USA

  • John Michael Jones says:

    I really enjoy Dana’s reviews. I got a chuckle on, “Despite my faulty childhood knowledge that allowed us to call each other mameluci whenever we were scared, whiny, or soft at play, I now know Mamluks were a major part of the military force in the Levant starting in the 9th century.” I too grew up thinking a mameluc was the complete opposite of the actual meaning. I would LOVE to try this fragrance. Xerjoff is one of my favorite houses! I’ve tried all BUT this one! Good luck from Boston, Ma.

  • I’ve never tried any of the Xerjoff Oud Stars collection. I am interested in this particular fragrance due to the different notes and their particular/peculiar juxtaposition. Thank you for this review and thanks to Europerfumes for making this draw possible. I’m in the USA

  • I’ve never tried any fragrances from Xerjoff Oud Stars collection so I am very much hoping to will this giveaway. I enjoyed most the connection of this fragrance to the idea of “delicate brutality”. I think that that is such an interesting concept to connect to a scent. Hoping I can try to make this connection for myself!

  • Thank you Dana for another interesting and thought provoking review and Europerfumes for the giveaway 🙂 I like the idea of a brutal AND sensitive fragrance 🙂 Mamluk sounds multi-faceted and quite intriguing. I am in the USA

  • Love Oud so will most likely love Mamluk. Interesting background by Dana Sandu on mamluks as glorified slaves in Levant history. Haven’t tried anything in Xerjoff Oud collection, yet. Thanks for the review and the draw. Writing from the USA.

  • Love Oud so will most likely love Mamluk. Interesting background by Dana Sandu on mamluks as glorified slaves in Levant history. Haven’t tried anything in Xerjoff Oud collection, yet. Lovely notes, beautiful bottle.

    Also liked how substituting And for But can make a big difference, and I tried it, and it works!!

    Thanks for the review and the draw. Writing from the USA.

  • The first time I ever heard of a Mamluk was in the context of slave warriors followed by the Seljuks and the Janissaries. I haven’t seen the other 2 names used in fragrance, but they all have a cool exotic connotation. As for the scent itself, I wonder how it stacks up against Bianchi’s Dark Side (animalic honey). I would love to try this one along with Al-Khatt as they’re often mentioned together.

    And I don’t know about the delicate part, but I can appreciate “brutal” in your face fragrances if they’re well done.

    PA,US

  • It was interesting to read about Dana’s childhood name Mameluci in refer relation to the name, Mamluk. Also saying the fragrance has delicate brutality, I would love to try. I Love Lira, by Xerjoff, and thank you for the chance to win. California

  • Interesting Fragrance. Sounds nice and a bit odd. Haven’t explored much of Xerjoff. I’d like to try this and many others from the House. Thanks for the draw, Ca

  • I am new to this house and this review makes me very excited to try their perfumes. I love all the notes in this perfume – jasmine, musk, vanilla, honey, and osmanthus especially. Brutal AND sensitive sounds intriguing!
    California, USA

  • Little history about word Mamluk but have nothing to do with the frag it self but enjoyed reading it. Mix musk and honey will get you lovely smell. Love to test it and try it if Im lucky to win. Im In Ca USA

  • I find Xerjoff to be one the top 5 brands of high end perfumery. One of my the first niche purchases was Lira early 2012… early March I think.
    Doesn’t matter is you like safe , daring or sweet, Xerjoff portfolio is big , and you’re covered .
    Mamluk attracts me sweetness and funky facets , without going over the board .
    As I said Lira was my first Xerjoff purchase, and I still love it, but it’s not my favorite one, not anymore, Cruz del Sur II is , followed by Golden Dallah and then comes Lira.
    Alexandria II is the only Oud Stars i know.
    Cheers from VA

  • Wow, what a great description – “delicate brutality”. I’ve never heard a fragrance described in that way. The notes combination really is interesting. I’ve never tried anything from Oud Stars collection. And I only own one Xerjoff – Golden Dallah.
    I live in the USA.

  • Thanks for review!
    I remember, when I tested Mamluk I was wondered and fascinated same time- beautiful honey and oud with gentle fecal nuance. I really love this perfume.
    From Xerjoff Oud Stars I like Gao too.
    USA

  • So interesting article!!!
    “Delicate brutality”- well said for this perfume full of contrast! Soft sweet honey and animalic woody. I see this perfume mostly on man.
    US

  • I always enjoy reading dana’s reviews, they’re always full of excellent philosophical musings and interesting factual tidbits. It would be great to sit down and have a chat with her one day. The Mamluks were certainly interesting figures in history with tragic life stories, as most of them originated as kidnapped children from Georgia and other Caucasian ethnic groups. So I can see where the “delicate brutality” the conjoining of two opposites comes into play. I haven’t really tried many fragrances from the Oud Stars collection, but I did recently get a sample of Al-Khatt and totally loved it. Fars was another one, but it didn’t impress me as much. Thanks so much for the chance to try Mamluk! It sounds quite unique. Oregon, USA.

  • Michael Prince says:

    Dana did an amazing review of Xerjoff Mamluk. She described it brilliantly how this fragrance is dense and opulent, gourmand and sensual, and so is a combination of so many different facets. A delicious honey, resinous, gourmand sweetness combined with florals and animalic undertones. I haven’t tried anything from the Xerjoff Oud Stars collection, but I would love to try this fragrance. I am from Ohio, USA.

  • When I think about Xerjoff pictures of Mefisto always comes to mind. Being a barber my love for aromatic and citrusy fragrances comes naturally. Lavender is prominent, but don’t push it into mature territory. Super classy, yet not overly aggressive fragrance.
    Mefisto is more dressed up day time occasions scent, but Mamluk feels like a super sexy one , for a club or bar. It’s both sweet, salty and just a bit funky.
    I’ve never smelled, or even seen Oud Stars fragrance.
    Thanks to Dana again , and to Europerfumes for the giveaway.
    USA

  • I like brutal fragrances. My skin chemistry soaks notes up in an instant, so I appreciate an assault that doesn’t fade away. I like Al Khatt from this house. It’s animalic for sure. I loved dana’s description of the dusty and metallic notes. I think I’d enjoy Mamluk for sure.
    I live in the USA.

  • Mamluk I expect to smell like Salt Caramel Cake, and I imagined eating it while sitting on old and dusty leather couch.
    Somehow Mamluk reminds me of most long term relationships, sometimes they are like a salted caramel , some other days like old leather mixed with dust. I try to keep mine sweet all the time 🙂
    I’ll keep telling this story on every Xerjoff giveaway, THE best Xerjoff I’ve smelled called Italica. Exclusive to Harvey Nichols , and they do not want to ship it to US . On top of all it’s not even available at xerjoffuniverse , which was a shock to me. Smells very, and I mean very similar to a traditional Toffee Almond Cake with spelt flour, unsweetened cocoa powder , almonds , buttermilk , strong brewed coffee, dark rum , bittersweet chocolate , salt. It’s a traditional Italian cake. I’m pretty sure the cake was the inspiration behind Italica. One of the best realistically smelling gourmands , and top 3 gourmands in my collection, and I have over 80. It was really hard for me to get it , because I had to find someone to get it for me in UK , and bring it to the States.
    No , Oud Stars Line is completely unknown to me.
    Appreciate Dana review, and the giveaway campaign
    USA

  • Almost all Xerjoff fragrances are multifaceted , and Mamluk is no exception.
    Very sweet, syrupy, resins with caramel and woods , but then leathrs , dust and sweat. Not for everyone, but to me , undoubtedly a stunner . I have to check it out.
    Honestly I was not even aware of OUD STARS, but I’m proud of owning Naxos 1861.
    Generous giveaway, thank you. USA

  • Dana’s reviews are always inspiring. Brutal AND sensitive indeed! The reviews show what I love about fragrance, so many different sides and components all drawn together by the perfumer’s artistry. I’ve never tried anything from this house before. I live in the USA. Thanks for the giveaway!

  • Great review by Dana! I enjoyed reading about delicate brutality and how we are somewhat conditioned. I am very interested in learning more about the Mamluk’s. This fragrance sounds amazing! I was intrigued by “this is hardened but not sharp, intense but sweet, heavy but simple–just like, say, a brutalist piece of silver jewelry.” I have never tried anything from the Oud Stars line. Thanks for the giveaway and I live in the US!

  • I have never tried this house but those notes are so appealing. These reviews make me long for the time when browsing and shopping were possible. I’m going to make a point to try AND instead of BUT.
    I’m in the US