Miss Balmain by Germaine Cellier “The Scent of Sedition”

  Vintage Miss Balmain review

Vintage Miss Balmain ad, Rene Gruau 1968

These days, it’s not uncommon for classic fragrances to become lost amidst the shuffle of new releases which expands incrementally with each approaching year. Due to the rapid pace of life and ever-advancing technology we, the public – find our attention span to be briefer; we’re more easily distracted, in general.

Art reflects the era/generation in which it is created; that which continues to resonate with us remains a staple heedless of the passage of time. As this applies to every creative venue imaginable, it also holds true for perfume. We may glimpse a bird’s eye view into a particular era simply by experiencing the fragrances composed at any specific time. 1967, the year in which Miss Balmain surfaced – was a time of social unrest and change which is reflected in this exquisitely rebellious perfume – carrying alongside it a steady wave of conservatism: a decade of vehement contrasts.

  Women's right to choose

sisterhood campaign via the British Library

Examples of these contrasts are legion: civil rights moved forward with bold steps, embodied by the emergence of the Black Panther movement; race riots took place with increasing regularity. Women stormed the 60s in pursuit of equal rights, sexual liberation, and sisterhood; 1967 was part of the second wave of feminism. LGBTQ rights saw San Francisco assume pride of place as an epicenter for human rights and sexual orientation. That summer’s three-day Monterey Pop Festival foreshadowed the Woodstock of 1969. U.S. President Lyndon Baines Johnson was in office; both the Vietnam War and the Cold War were in full force, and the Space Race was at its zenith.

Germaine Cellier

Germaine Cellier via Wiki

You may justifiably ask how Miss Balmain fits into this tempestuous time, or today’s world. To begin with, its very name is a misnomer: there’s little “miss” about it. In current day terms, the fragrance is comfortably genderless, and it most certainly is not girly, flirtatious, or frou-frou – any more than the original, elegantly bitter-mordant 1947 Miss Dior (created by Jean Carles and Paul Vacher 20 years prior) is. Miss Balmain may have been marketed to attract a more youthful clientele, but the proposed wearer bears nothing of the ingenue about their person.

 Vintage Miss Balmain Lois chiles

Lois Chiles in a Miss Balmain ad GETTY

Miss Balmain demands an individual of strong, decisive character – someone fearless and a mite reckless, truth be told. Unlike many other leathers, it doesn’t include violets, for one (as Mme. Cellier’s 1953 Jolie Madame does). As was fashionable at the time (and still is currently), it commences with a blast of aldehydes, brilliant citrus and spice (coriander and carnation), followed by a heady indolic bouquet which includes gardenia, narcissus, jasmine and jonquil – ripe with divine decay – in the company of orris and rose. Thujone, a powerful herbal fresh material found in clary sage, wormwood and various members of the juniper family – contributes that accent which ‘seasons’ florals with its piquancy (a helpful example of this aspect is to be found in original Miss Dior; it takes the form of clary sage). Miss Balmain’s base is out of this world, brimming with depth and mystery: leathery notes so dear to the nose, a darkly brooding amber burnished with winey patchouli, castoreum’s sweet/dry/tobacco-inferred muskiness, the inky, smoky intensity of oakmoss in companionable collusion with vetiver’s smoke-inflected verdancy. It comes as no surprise that, in the drydown – Miss Balmain assumes vestiges of a freshly-stubbed fine cigarette, the inside of a leather purse or bag littered with loose blond tobacco: this is part of its appeal, and a quality which feels familiar and undeniably sophisticated. There is an effortless, je m’en fiche (read: “I don’t give a damn”) quality to Miss Balmain, a wonderful inherent wildness that prowls subversively, despite being cloaked in refinement. An original for the original.

Miss Balmain 1967

 via wiki

Miss Balmain was the last perfume created by Germaine Cellier at the Roure Bertrand Dupont (now part of Givaudan) fragrance house where she and the brilliant Jean Carles (Canoe, Ma Griffe, Tabu, Shocking de Schiaparelli) fought like cats and dogs. Despite their bickering, there clearly was a measure of lurking admiration, as both Miss Dior and Miss Balmain share similar scented tendrils: both are verdant, with the Dior opening being greener and the drydown mossier yet bright – as opposed to Miss Balmain’s more effulgently floral introduction and darkly brooding denouement.

The timelessness of such a fragrance happens to be entwined with today’s turbulent landscape of change: in 2023, as in 1967 – we find ourselves in the midst of transition on a large scale. It’s remarkable that Miss Balmain feels as relevant today as it did then – iconoclastic, irrepressible and wearable for seditious souls wherever they may find themselves.

~ Ida Meister, Deputy and Natural Perfumery Editor 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


15 comments

  • Oh my, what a treat! Both the history (fragrance history, as well as the larger kind!) in the review and the very generous giveaway. I have never smelled Miss Balmain, but would love to. Germaine Cellier seems like a person to know more about… And of course, the list of notes is exciting: there are a couple perfumes I love with coriander and aldehydes in the top…
    I’m in WV, USA

  • I really enjoyed the in-depth history review of the era that Miss Balmain was released. I’m quite surprised to see such a complex list of notes. Citrus and leather is my favorite combination fragrance wise and I’m interested to see how it held up to the test of time and in comparison to newer and more current fragrances. Thank you Ida for hosting such an amazing giveaway and the deeply informative post. From TX, USA.

  • Regis Monkton says:

    I very much have an interest in perfumery history, so I’d like to try this vintage formulation of “Miss Balmain”. I appreciate learning about perfumer Germaine Cellier. I’m very interested to see what this fragrance is like, and I’m interested to see if I’ve smelled it before (or at least something like it). I appreciate Ida’s generosity and I appreciate her description of this fragrance. I live in MD, U.S.A.

  • wallygator88 says:

    THanks for the cool review, Ida. It’s so much fun to read about this historic fragrance from Germain Cellier. Her creation with Vent Vert is also well known

    . In particular, I loved reading about the green, herbal parts and the drydown of the fragrance. The heavy notes, leading to an ashtray quality sounds intriguing.

    Cheers from WI, USA

  • I can almost always tell from the first words of a review if it is one by one and only Ida Meister. Poetry in prose, I love reading Ida’s reviews, to enlighten myself of the olfactory art of a perfumer or a perfume, and to relish myself with some rich literary text. I also am thankful that every once in a while, she offers a sample of the reviewed perfume from her own collection. Miss Balmain is intriguing as it reflects the sixties, when it was designed. I enjoyed reading about the history of the perfume and the perfumer behind it. “The most divinely dirty ashtray of a perfume one could ever wish for.” Of course I would love to check it out. Thanks Ida for yet another excellent review and your generosity in offering this draw. I am in the continental United States.

  • Thank you for the interesting history lesson and introduction to Miss Balmain. I have much to learn about classic fragrances, so this type of review and retrospective is both entertaining and informative. Your description of the base really struck me; leather, amber, oakmoss, vetiver, patchouli, and castoreum are all quite tenacious, and the suggestion of a fine cigarette is a unique flourish. Thanks for the review, Ida.

    I’m in the continental US. Thanks for the giveaway!

  • I used to wear Balmain back in the late 70’s and would love to experience this. The notes are very interesting and love the vintage feel!

  • bigscoundrel says:

    The timelessness really intrigues me. I’d love to win this as a gift for my gf. New Jersey USA

  • foreverscents says:

    I always wait with bated breath for reviews of vintage perfumes on this site. I was born in 1967, so I have always wanted to try Miss Balmain. I love Ida’s description of a purse with scattered loose blond tobacco. I love fragrances like that. I have a small bottle of Jolie Madame, which I wear when I need a confidence boost. I would love to win a decant of Miss Balmain before I begin my search for a vintage bottle. I live in the USA.

  • sephrenia300 says:

    Great review Ida! What appeals to me about Ida’s review of Balmain Miss Balmain is the idea of a strong decisive leather that doesn’t include violets but rather includes an indolic bouquet of flowers in the heart – jasmine narcissus and gardenia. I prefer indolic flowers and am not a big fan of violets, but I absolutely adore leather. So this sounds like the perfect fragrance for me! I live in the US.

  • Ida!!! WOW!!! ❤️❤️❤️ How Gorgeous!!! I love Germaine Cellier and her landmark work! I’ve never smelled Miss Balmain! Your Beautiful description sounds Heavenly! ❤️❤️ I love how Germaine Cellier’s perfumes so skillfully use green and aromatic materials with touches of leather & animalics. The particular floral bouquet in Miss Balmain sounds like something I would fall for! ❤️❤️❤️ Thank you for the best description!! Thank you for your kind generosity and the wonderful opportunity! ❤️ USA

  • The article really captures the character of Miss Balmain a true original fragrance. The historical perspective is captivating as we live through these turbulent times. I need great fragrances like Miss Balmain to get me through the days.

  • There is so much to be said of the bold high spirited women of the 60’s. Those perfumes my mother adored and wore: a different one every day. She owed the man who would come to our house every week to collect his money and introduce my mother to another masterpiece fragrance: his suitcase filled with trasures of perfume samples. I don’t know if she had this one, but the notes described sway in my momery along with the Winston tobacco smoke in my mother’s kisses.