The Three Etat Libre d’Orange Perfumes You Should be Wearing + Hermann A Mes Cotes, Fat Electrician and Afternoon of the Faun Draw

Etienne de Swardt at Esxence 2014 Photo by Tama Blough

Etienne de Swardt, declared his independence from “business as usual” in 2006. Freeing himself from the predictable sterility of   market driven fragrance and beauty, he formed his own perfume house – Etat Libre d’ Orange, where he brought to life a new sincerity and freedom of expression in fragrance.   For more than a decade, Etat Libre d’Orange has been creating evocative, challenging scents that push the limits of perfumery while maintaining a sense of ironic whimsy, wrapped around distinctively luxurious fragrance profiles. 

Etat Libre D’Orange scent blotters

There are currently 34 scents in the line (going on 35; we announced You or Someone Like You earlier today) – so many I adore that I find it challenging to decide just which ELdO fragrance to purchase or wear.  Should I choose the provocative, the irreverent, and the seductive?  Am I looking for references to Impressionist music, art house theatre, French symbolist poetry or Romantic prose?   Recently, Editor-in-Chief, Michelyn Camen, asked Etienne to choose three fragrances from Etat Libre d’Orange that he believes ÇaFleureBon readers should be wearing; fragrances that epitomize the style and ethos of the House.  Etienne was kind enough not only to offer his choices but also to tell us something of the stories behind  why and of each perfume. 

   

 Victor Hugo Ink Blot Drawings 1876

Hermann A Mes Cotes Me Paraissait Une Ombre (2016) by perfumer Quentin Bisch  

 “Hermann because it’s related to my grand mother, she was a teacher of French literature and when I was a kid she used to read loudly this poem of Victor Hugo. Very epic souvenir.  So I presume that part of her lives in the scent and this poem, this is my allegiance to the departed, the gone with the wind long ago and their echoes still blowing in the wind.  A praise to their eternal samsara everywhere, I become very animist turning 46.” – Etienne de Swardt

Victor Hugo pen and ink Voilures

“À quoi songeaient les deux cavaliers dans la forêt” – What Two Horsemen Were Thinking in the Forest – is the twelfth poem in Victor Hugo’s collection of poetry entitled Les Contemplations.  For me the words of this romantic poem and the listed notes of the Hermann fragrance create a consensus of scent and poetic imagery.

The first stanza reads: “The night was so black and the forest very dark. 


By my side, Hermann seemed to me like a shadow. (Hermann A Mes Cotes Me Paraissait Une Ombre.)

…The clouds in the sky looked like marble.

The stars flew through the branches of the trees

Like a swarm of firebirds.”…

Later, the poem references “green solitude”, “fountains singing” and “bushes whispering”, suggesting a fantastic and surreal olfactive landscape. The perfumer uses several aroma-chemicals to recreate this dreamlike, otherworldly atmosphere. The jus itself is the color of shadow.   

  Digital Portrait Antonio Mora

My first breath of Hermann is of black current and Pepperwood™, an ingredient that smells at once coldly metallic, woody and peppery.  The aquatic/ozonic effect of another raw material, Calypsone®, suffuses the fragrance with a black, cool, watery darkness fortified by the wet earth scent of Geosmin.  This dark, cold opening continues into the gothic heart of the fragrance.  Here I find galbanum lurking in the shadows with hints of spicy geranium and rose absolute.  Here also, Petalia®, a Givaudan captive molecule, gives a rosy, fruity, spicy sheen to the gloom. 

Digital Portrait Antonio Mora Forbidden Trees

There is very little that is natural about this beauty.  In fact Hermann is almost totally unnatural – or should I say super-natural.  As time goes by the fragrance retreats deeper into the shadows, becoming darker, colder and even a bit menacing, reminiscent of dreams of magical forests, cool tombs and withered roses.  After eight hours a remnant of patchouli and a wraith of Ambroxan linger on my skin. Notes: Blackcurrant buds, black pepper, galbanum, calypsone, geosmin, frankincense, pepperwood, petalia, rose absolute, patchouli, ambroxan.

Erik Estrada, dressed in his CHiPS uniform in Times Square in 2010.

Fat Electrician (2009) by perfumer Antoine Maisondieu

Fat Electrician, because we bow to non-sense & fun at Etat Libre d’Orange as long as it stays ultra qualitative. The curse of beauty, dedicated to vain narcissism, Greek modern tragedy and burlesque. “Nothing is forever” said the fat lost angel when divorced twice with too many bills and kids ;-)” – Etienne de Swardt

Fat Electrician comes on the scene offering something like marzipan, cherries and berries tinged with the scent of singed and burned plastic and myrrh.  To my nose the initial spritz is also very pink and pointed, not heavy but with a focused intensity, replete with vanilla, the bitter green smokiness of olive leaf and the scent of some sort of machine lubricant.  This bright and promising, if somewhat lascivious youth, matures into a vetiver like no other – warmly dark, floral, grassy and creamy, retaining a bit of the early tangy fruit that becomes riper and more seductive with age.  I have to say that Fat Electrician is one of my all time favorite vetiver fragrances. The initial sillage is quite pronounced. Eventually, after about six hours, Fat Electrician begins to fade on my skin.  What remains of the initial, vain youthful intensity and middle aged burlesque is a simple, fragile, memory of vanilla, vetiver and resinous opoponax.  Notes: Vetiver from Haiti, chestnut cream, olive leaves, myrrh, vanilla, opoponax.

Nijinsky as the faun. Taken by Baron de Meyer

 

The Afternoon of a Faun (2012) by perfumer Ralf Schwieger

“The Afternoon of a faun, because of my mentor Jacques Damase, a famous art dealer and publisher, a tycoon of the 20th century, friend of Cocteau, Aragon, Picasso and other famous 20th artists. He was mad at me in 2012 when I did not think about celebrating the 100th year anniversary of the Russian ballet danced in 1912 at theatre du chatelet with Nijinski sublime and decadent. Jacques to yell at me: “Etienne shame on you. You have to celebrate beauty, dance and poetry and close the final synesthesia through a perfume” and I invited Justin Bond to play the muse for Ralf.” – Etienne de Swardt

Pablo Picasso Tête de Faune (Head of a Faun)

The poetry, art, dance and music associated with the name of this perfume are so much a part of my life as a musician that no matter how hard I try, the sound of Prélude à l’après-midi d’un faun by Claude Debussy, the ballets Afternoon of a Faun by Vaslav Nijinsky, Jerome Robbins and Tim Rushton and the words of the symbolist poet Stéphane Mallarmé color my understanding and perception of the fragrance. 

Pal Merse A Faun

My first impression of Etat Libre d’Orange, The Afternoon of a Faun is the smell a languid hot afternoon in a meadow: “…the motionless and weary swoon of stifling heat ” that begins with citrus, pepper, cinnamon and immortelle. The top notes dissipate slowly as bits of moisture invade the dry air.  The scent to of iris and dewy moss swirl with incense and jasmine, part of an ethereal and slightly humid melody that, in my imagination, flows from the panpipes played by the faun. As the fragrance develops, a leathery dry rose replaces the delicate moist iris.  This effect remains in place for several hours.  The Afternoon of a Faun leaves the stage after six hours with a bow to jasmine, rose and benzoin. This perfume is a luminous dream of dance, melody and seduction, an enigmatic pastorelle set in French Symbolism. Notes:  Bergamot, pepper, cinnamon, incense, rose, immortal flower, iris, jasmine, myrrh, moss, leather, benzoin.

Many thanks to Europerfumes for supplying the testers of Hermann, Fat Electrician and The Afternoon of a Faun.  My opinions are my own.

Gail Gross, Sr. Contributor

Art Direction: Michelyn Camen, Editor-in-Chief

Today we have a readers’ choice draw! Thanks to the generosity of Etat Libre D’Orange, we have  a reader’s choice of a 50 ml bottle of Hermann A Mes Cotes Me Paraissait Une Ombre 

OR Fat Electrician

OR The Afternoon of a Faun

available to one registered reader in the EU, USA or Canada (be sure to register or your comment will not count). To be eligible please let us know what appeals to you about these three fragrances based on Gail’s reviews, your favorite perfume from Etat Libre d’Orange , where you live and what you thought of Etienne de Swardt’s three choices. Which three EDlO do YOU think everyone should be wearing?  Draw closes 2/9/2017

We announce the winners only on site and on our Facebook page, so Like Cafleurebon and use our RSS feed…or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


44 comments

  • The appeal of these fragrances is the inclusion of unusual and unexpected elements–and their names! My favorite fragrance from ELDO is Remarkable People, I think it is a unisex, spicy, comforting winter fragrance that is suitable for most occasions. I have tried only Like This also from this house, but it did not cause me to purchase. The choices by the reviewer are intriguing and interest the reader into sampling. If possible, I would very much like to try The Afternoon of a Faun–a hot afternoon that turns into a dance? yes, please! I live in the US

  • Fat Electrician–not just because the notes sound lovely (vetiver and chestnut cream are very unisex) but also because everyone should experience the joy of answering “Fat Electrician” when asked what are they wearing.

  • How exciting that ELd’O has a new fragrance out! I am always curious what they are up to. Even though I haven’t found many of theirs that I would wear, I always want to test them out because they are so interesting. I find them to be the most philosophical of niche houses. My favourite is Fils de Dieu, but I do also like Fat Electrician. Great top three choices, as they are all quite different. Out of these three perfumes, I’m most interested in The Afternoon of a Faun. It sounds perfect for me, with the spices, incense, moss, and leather. Wonderful! I live in Canada, thank you.

  • Ooooo, I love Fat Electrician. I have just a sample from the sample set but one of my favorite Vetivers (which is a favoured type of mine)! There are some other greats in the line including Like This and Jasmine and Cigarette. Lovely draw!

  • I am super excited about thisfragrance! I wanna smell this vetiver and chestnut combo! I love this house they do thingns different and I really admire them for that! I live in New York City 🙂

  • Another great combination interview-review by Gail! I like Etienne’s choice of the three to wear. If I were to win, I would gladly take Hermann!

  • I like a lot of creations from this house, really don’t want to pick a favorite. Because I only ever had a sample of Fat Electrician I’d love to win the bottle in the draw here. US

  • What I like about ELd’O fragrances are the stories they tell me, the journeys they take me on. I think these were great selections by the perfumer as exemplary of the house but my favorite is Tilda Swinton Like This. I have a sampler from this house and after revisiting the three mentioned here, I would like to enter for a full bottle of The Afternoon of a Faun. I think that everyone must sample all they can and make selections based on what speaks to them individually. I am in the US. Thank you and Mr. de Swardt for the chance.

  • I love the idea of Hermann being supernatural. Like a boost from the other side making it more amazing. I’ve smelled some from this line, but not a lot of experience with it. I can recommend that everyone should be wearing “La Fin du Monde”. That is my favorite of the few I know. Should I win, my choice would be Hermann. Thanks for the draw. I live in the US.

  • cardinalmind says:

    Jesus Christ THIS IS MY FAVORITE BRAND!!!
    – Okay Calm Down cardinalmind. First off I’m from the Philippines but is currently living in California, USA. ELDO’s products are very hard to find in the PH, I’ve only stumbled upon them when I was in the CBD part of Makati. They are in a higher-end department store, place with the other niche and rare brands. And it was a love at first sniff! I’ve seriously bought a botte of Fat Electrician without regrets. That was 2011 and today 2017, I’m on my third rapidly depleting bottle. No that badly named Philippine Houseboy didn’t faze me from buying their bottles, as I know they like creating publicity and gay undertoned names.

    As such I’m choosing to get a bottle of Fat Electrician. But if they send me either of the other two instead of it, I will still be happy.

    Etienne’s three choices perfectly encapsulates them. Some are brash, unadulterated fun ones only a niche or independent perfumers can make while others are a new ways to tackle a frequently used path in perfumery. I think Gail’s descriptions are right on the mark and beautifully put the words I can’t say. Thanks for the chance.

  • I agree with Gail that Fat Electrician is the best vetiver scent, I have a small sample only but I adore it, the sweet gourmand opening is really cool. Love This is my favorite perfume from this house.
    I ‘d love to win a bottle of Fat Electrician.
    Thank you for the draw! (EU)

  • marcopietro says:

    I think it’s appropriate that choice of three fragrances to illustrate the eldo approach to independent perfumery. They illustrate very well some values of their concept: revitalization of memory, fun with a bit of nonsense and madness, attention to cultural vanguards. Some of their perfumes are brave and irreverent, but they are always excellent fragrances. I like many of them including the three reviewed. I love Fat Eletrician, The Afternoon of a Faun, Tom of Finland , Fils de Dieu and many other… it’s so difficult to choose only one! Everyone can find its ideal eldo to wear.
    The Afternoon of a Faun is my choice.
    Thanks for the generous draw!
    I live in EU.

  • There’s a lot of variety between these three fragrances which is most appealing. I don’t have any fragrances from this house so I don’t have any favorites. For me, Afternoon of a Faun sounds most appealing, even though I really love vetiver and Fat Electrician would be welcome as well. Thanks for the draw. I live in the USA

  • I do appreciate the non-conformism of the brand, which has renewed a lot of codes in the perfume scene.

    My favorites perfumes from État Libre d’Orange are Rien and Like this. But I just know about half of the total releases of the brand by now…

    I would love to win The Afternoon of a Faun, just because I love Debussy’s music !

    I’m in the EU. Thanks for the draw !

  • fazalcheema says:

    The story behind Hermann A Mes Cotes Me Paraissait Une Ombre inspires me the most because Etienne is paying tribute to his grandmother who loved Victor Hugo. I was also very close to my grandmother (not my dad’s mom but his first aunt from father’s side) so I can personally related to Etienne’s story, too. This fragrance also seems quite abstract and makes good use of some beautiful synthetic materials. The Afternoon of a Faun is also great selection but I already own it. I also remember attending the NYC presentation of The Afternoon of a Faun in 2013 or was it 2014. My favorite from the house is Jasmin et Cigarette and second is The Afternoon of a Faun.

    For this draw, my choice will be Hermann A Mes Cotes Me Paraissait Une Ombre. I am in the US.

  • The description of the Hermann A Mes Cotes with it’s trademarked notes has me most interested in that one. I’m always in search of the unique. I haven’t smelled all of Etienne’s choices to form an opinion of them. The ELdO I love the most is Rien. For the draw I’d love to win the bottle of Hermann A Mes Cotes. 🙂 USA

  • I have smelled a few from ELDO and I like their approach, although I didn’t like everything I have tried. From these three reviewed here, Fat Electrician is the one I’d chose; I did try it, because I am a vetiver fan and this was one that popped here and there as recommendation. The other two sound fine, but not as exciting as Fat Electrician, at least for me.
    However, my favorites from ELDO are Rien and Rien Intense Incense as they are so raw and sexy and bold. A popular one that didn’t do much for me is Tom of Finland; I find it too perfume-y, too over the top and not so leathery.
    Thanks for the draw, I live in EU.

  • Iuno Feronia says:

    I love this perfume house and the sometimes very strange interpretations, but I love to wear some of the scents. The afternoon of a Faun is exactly what I am longing for… winter is Lasting a Little bit too Long.

    Thanks for the draw, I live in the EU.

  • This is great that etat Libre D’Orange owner Etienne de Swardt actually chose the three. I would go with Fat Electrician. I have Afternoon of the Faun as well as Like This and Rien (which is my favorite). Hermann sounds intriguing so out is a difficult choice
    I had no idea Victor Hugo was also an artist btw
    I live in Canada

  • This is one of those times when knowing the inspiration behind them actually make the fragrances seem so much more profound and tempting. These all sound good to me, though I’m leaning towards Afternoon of a Faun for its cinnamon and its Russian ballet reference. I haven’t tried that many from this house, but I think Like This is very cozy, and Fils de Dieu is great as well. I live in Canada.

  • Very interesting review. I have never had a chance to try any of Etat Libre d’Orange. But I suppose it’s a really interesting, unique and good brand. If I would be as lucky to win, I would very like to win and try The Afternoon of a Faun. This fragrance sounds incredibly good. Thank you for the chance. I live in Europe.

  • I’ve smelled a number of scents from this house and have a hard time choosing a favorite. I’d like to try The Afternoon of a Faun. I’m in the US, thanks for the draw.

  • I Love Fat Electrician, Jasmine et Cigarettes and Fils de Dieu , I’d like to try afternoon of a Faun as it’s one of the few I haven’t sniffed yet. I’ve always considered them to be a unique and ingenious brand and I’ve really enjoyed Gail’s review! I am in the UK

  • doveskylark says:

    The thing about Etat Libre d’Orange is that I read the notes of all the fragrances and I think I’d never wear those notes and then I instantly think that’s precisely why I SHOULD wear those notes. Everyone needs to do exactly the opposite of what we think we should do–at least once a week. I love Gail’s description of Hermann a Mes Cotes. It certainly does sound like a supernatural creation. I love wearing Rien from this line. It is leathery but in a plasmatic way.
    I would choose Afternoon of a Faun. I remember being obsessed with the movie about Nijinsky when I was a kid.
    I live in the USA.

  • I like unconventional names for fragrances and I think everyone should try Fat Electrician, which would be also my choice if I win. Thanks for so interesting article. I live in the EU.

  • I really liked the description of Hermann A Mes Cotes Me Paraissait Une Ombre, I like darker scents and this is just up my alley. This is for me.

    I believe Fat Electrician would appeal more to the crowd.

    In USA.

  • Judging only by the name, I think I might blindly choose Afternoon of a Faun for myself, but the notes decided and my choice would be Hermann a Mes Cotes… because of blackcurrant buds. From the three, I have tried only Fat Electrician and I quite like it, although it is not a big love. I don’t have a favorite ELdo fragrance yet.

    (EU)

  • ntabassum92 says:

    I like the inspiration behind them, especially the first two and how they are so commingled with the arts. I think it’s beautiful that his mother read him such a wonderful poem and that he now has a perfume that he can connect with that. My favorite ELDO perfume is definitely Like This. I’m in the US. I like Etienne’s three choices, although Fat Electrician doesn’t agree with me personally – but I can see it’s appeal and value. The three ELDOs I wish others were wearing would be: Putain des Palaces, Tilda Swinton Like This, and Dangerous Complicity. If I won, I would pick Afternoon of a Faun 🙂

  • Miss Almond says:

    “The motionless and weary swoon of stifling heat… that begins with citrus, pepper, cinnamon and immortelle” is my favorite phrase from the three reviews. The image of a lazy sunny summer afternoon sounds perfect now, when there is so much snow outside.
    My favorite Etat Libre d’Orange perfume is Tilda Swinton Like This. I live in Europe, thank you for the draw. If I win, I’d like Afternoon of a Faun.

  • ELdO is one of the most intriguing brands which gave me a wide variety of experiences while trying its perfumes: from a pure shock and a thought “never come close to this perfume again!” (Secretions Magnifiques) to the feeling that I’ve just found a real beauty in a bottle (Rien). I haven’t tried any of the three reviewed. I think I’d like Hermann A Mes Cotes best. I live in the EU, thank you for the chance.

  • I love the amount of nonsense and absurd in this brand’s creations! Although I have not tried so many of them I can tell they always surprise me. The name “Fat Electrician” makes me roar with laughter. I have never smelled any electrician, let alone a fat one, and I would love to smell this perfume.

    I am in the EU and my favorite ELDO is Eau de Protection.

  • Hikmat Sher Afridi says:

    Thanks for the wonderful review. The review for “The Afternoon of a faun” is appealing to me. My favorite perfumes from Etat Libre d’Orange is Tom of Finland and Rien Intense Incense. The three ELDO which I think everyone should be wearing…….difficult to say as all of ELDO are appealing, anyhow Tom of Finland, Rien Intense Incense and The Afternoon of a faun come to my mind first. If I am the winner I’ll choose “The Afternoon of a faun”.
    Thanks to the generosity of Etat Libre D’Orange and Cafleurebon for the opportunity to participate in the draw by letting my relative NY, US address.

  • Fat Electrician was one of my favs from ELDO, and become the definite number one after the insightful Chandler Burr talk about it. Althought based from this review I’m eager to smell the poetic supernatural Hermann…
    The Afternoon of a Faun was in fact the most surprising choice of these three.

    Greetings from Switzerland and thank you for the draw.

  • I like Fat Electrician very much. Everyone should try it becuse it is unlike any other fragrance. A real revolution, and this name! Great idea.
    I would like The Afternoon of a Faun for myself. As a fan of Ralf Schwieger I am going to try this as a blind choice and I am sure I won’t be disappointed.

    Thank you for your generosity. I love your draws. I am in the EU.

  • So interesting choice of three so different fragrances. Each of them sounds like something I could like but I think I will choose Hermann A Mes Cotes Me Paraissait Une Ombre. It is the most mysterious and romantic of the three.
    I live in EU. My favorite Etat Libre are Jamsin et Cigarette and Sex Pistols.

  • cinnamon tree says:

    I think I don’t have a favorite ELDO. I tried a few and they are all… strange. Pretty and unsettling. Like real art, they evoke controversy.
    I live in Europe. Thank you for the draw, I would pick the Afternoon of a Faun if I win.

  • The notes of Fat Electrician look promising and I’m a big vetiver fan so I’d love to sniff this one.
    Never tried any ELDO perfumes before.
    Thank you for the chance. USA

  • Wow, each of them look and sounds exciting, and I mean not only the notes but the names too. Please enter me for Hermann A Mes Cotes Me Paraissait Une Ombre. “Black, cool, watery darkness” and gothic style of the fragrance are what I like in perfumes. I live in Poland, EU.

  • What a difficult choice. I am torn between chestnut cream and a great load of absurdity in Fat Electrician and my love for ballet and Nijinsky, which would make me choose The Afternoon of a Faun. And Hermann… has the best name. Poor me, too much good to choose from 🙂

    Everyone should try each of them. They all sound more than interesting.

    I live in the EU. Thank you for so generous giveaway, in which I would finally choose The Afternoon of a Faun.

  • After reading what Quentin Bisch wrote: “[Hermann…] is my allegiance to the departed, the gone with the wind long ago and their echoes still blowing in the wind”, I knew I will choose this scent. It captures my recent mood perfectly. Every day I search for the way of bringing back the time and people that are no longer present, and I hope to find beauty in this sadness. Thanks so much! EU.

  • laureneboucher says:

    I loved hearing about the stories behind each fragrance. I can see from the back stories and the review that each fragrance really does tell a story. I have never tried an Etat Libre d’ Orange fragrance but from the reviews of these three the Afternoon of a Faun sounds lovely to me. Truth be told though all three sound very interesting to me. I live in the US. Thanks for the draw!

  • What a great house ELDO is. I’d love to try Herrmann. I’m in Canada and thank you so much for the draw!