Penhaligon’s Elixir (2008) Perfume Review “Smoke and Mystery”+ Olivia Giacobetti’s Oriental Journey Draw

redwoods

 Red wood (artist unknown)

One of the reasons we love fragrance so much is that they often present an opportunity to mentally visit distant or imaginary landscapes.  Arab cultural influences such as bathhouses have always struck Western artists as exotic and mysterious; the explosion of oud as an inspiration and ingredient proves this attitude has permeated the perfume world.  But an over-reliance on standard themes lends many of these scents which are intended to transport us like a magic carpet an ironic sameness. One fragrance that rises above the pack of ordinary Orientals is Penhaligon’s Elixir, composed by Olivia Giacobetti in 2008.  By combining accords which are typical of the genre with her own trademark “sheer” style, she has created a unique work of art that gives this well-trodden territory the thrill of a first visit to a new country.

faenaspa

Hammam courtesy of faena.com

Steam rises from a reflective pool; languid half-dressed bodies draped in colorful cloth recline in the heat.  Inspired by the Moroccan bathhouse known as a hammam, Elixir is a modern reinterpretation of a classic Penhaligon’s fragrance, Hammam Bouquet, from 1872.  It bears a resemblance to cologne as well as traditional Orientals, and is a perfect choice for lovers of the latter as the weather gets warmer here in the Northern Hemisphere.

klein1958

 William Klein, Hat and Five Roses, Vogue, 1958

Elixir’s opening is a lush red Turkish rose, supported by jasmine and orange blossom to add dimensionality.  Spices of cardamom, cinnamon and mace give the rose a foreign flair, but spicy roses, however well done, are not uncommon these days.

john singer sargent the sulphur match and penhaligon's elixir

 The Sulphur Match, John Singer Sargent, 1882/Penhaligon’s Elixir, 2008

Elixir, however, performs the alchemic magic suggested by its name by the addition of eucalyptus, a stroke of genius on Ms. Giacobetti’s part because its cool profile contrasts with the warm notes it rests on to create an olfactory illusion. The combination of eucalyptus and spicy rose smells much like the sulfur of a match being struck; the rose is suddenly aflame, and takes on the characteristics of a temple incense.  Over time, the fire cools and a base of vanilla, tonka, and benzoin add an airiness.

 olivia giacobetti

Olivia Giacobetti

Rose and eucalyptus are still discernible, but now they have calmed down to suggest the idea of clean wet skin drying in a breeze. If done with a heavy hand, the incense and spicy rose notes in Elixir could overpower or clash, but Olivia Giacobetti’s light touch puts this fragrance in the desirable company of scents which are wearable and yet provide an evolving artistic experience.  Available in eau de toilette, candle, and bath/shower gel forms, Elixir also presents the opportunity to create the hammam experience at home.  Sillage is moderate, though by layering products in this way it can be easily increased.  Longevity is excellent, reaching ten hours or more for me.  As a study in contrast between hot and cold, familiar and strange, and passionate and peaceful, Elixir occupies a space unlike any other fragrance I’ve tried, and it continues to surprise and delight with each wearing.

Disclosure: Review based on bottle provided by Penhaligon’s for promotional consideration

Nancy Knows, Editor and editor in chief of the fragrance blog Make Perfume, Not War

Thanks to our friends at Penhaligon's London USA we have a 100 ml EDT to one reader in the U.S. or Canada. To be eligible, Please leave a comment with why you would like to win Elixir and your favorite Olivia Giacobetti or Penhaligon's Perfume. Draw closes May 1, 2014

We announce the winners only on site and on our Facebook page, so Like Cafleurebon and use our RSS option…or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


49 comments

  • Jessica Marie says:

    I have been obsessed with the idea of Penhaligon ever since I first read about it on my perfume forum but have never had the opportunity to test them and would love to be entered in this drawing. The description is intriguing, “contrast between hot and cold, familiar and strange, and passionate and peaceful, Elixir occupies a space unlike any other fragrance I’ve tried, and it continues to surprise and delight with each wearing.” I really hope to be able to experience this for myself!

  • farawayspices says:

    I would love to win Elixir because I love a good cinnamon note, and I would love to experience it in a new and surprising way. My favorite Olivia Giacobetti fragrance is Tea for Two.

  • OMG This sounds amazing!! I love the contradiction of it all… it sounds like it would be almost spiritual to smell/wear it.I have not been lucky enough to try any Penhaligon scents yet but so many are on my must try list.I reside in the USA and thank you so much for the generous draw.

  • julesinrose says:

    I really, really want to try this one! I’m such a fan of Olivia Giacobetti’s!! I’m so curious about the combination of rose and eucalyptus and how that smells like a struck match. Ooh, I’m intrigued. As to picking my fave Giacobetti scent, it’s quite difficult. L’Artisan Safran Troublant for sure, though, considering it’s one of the few full bottles of perfume I’ve had to purchase a replacement for.

  • christina loome says:

    This one has been on my list for a couple of months. I’d love to add it to my collection!

  • Kim Morgan says:

    This sounds incredible. I love the fact that it sounds like irony in a bottle: what you expect to happen does a 180. USA resident – thank you for the draw!

  • Why would I like to win this one…. I would love to see how the scent of Hammam stands up in the heat of the SW desert in the summer 😉 As for a favorite of Olivia Giacobettis that is very difficult, I am a fan of Premier Figuier, Idole, Hiris.. the list goes on. As for my favorites of Penhaligon’s I do have a list as well, will just name 2 Amaranthine and Lily & Spice.
    Thanks for the review and to Penhaligon’s London for the draw. I am in the US.

  • I smelled Elixir when it first came out and the scent immediately sent my mind reeling back to when I lived in Scotland, watching a huge bonfire on Guy Fawkes night. I’m not sure why, because the notes don’t actually suggest that, but it was such a strong scent referral. I would love to see if I still get that reaction when I smell it. My favorite Penhaligon is Lavendula. I am in the US.

  • A light spicy rose with a twist? I can neve rhave too many of them 🙂 I have not tried any other Penhaligon or Olivia Giacobetti perfumes. I am in the US, thanks!

  • Oooh this sounds gooood!

    I would LOVE to win Elixir because I am obsessed with orientals. As a perfumer, I even tend to lean towards making orientals naturally since I’m from the Middle East. Making an oriental different these days is a challenge, I’m super curious to smell this!

    My favourite Olivia Giacobetti perfume (among so many, hard to pick one) would be the reconstructed Idole by Lubin, the EDP is really good too. Delicious. Oh and Premier Figuier (can’t help it, it’s amazing)

    Thank you!

  • I love that image of Giacobetti.

    I somehow missed Penhaligon’s when I first became interested in perfume— something about the image of “English perfumery” made met think that the brand would be stuffy and inaccessible. I tried Bluebell and it didn’t work for me, and then I skipped the rest.

    Fast forward a few years. In January, I tried Iris Prima and was stunned. Though I have a handful of lovely Iris fragrances (and variations on the iris theme: rooty, smoky, earthy, pretty, leathery), I found it altogether emotionally evocative and … savvy. Smart. Clever. It’s an iris that is just strange enough to be brilliant– and very pretty. And it made me realize that I really, truly need to try the rest of the range. I totally misread Penhaligon’s. Clearly, they are smarter than my initial thoughts– Iris Prima is one of my favorite frags from the last few years. I’ve been missing out. I really want to try them all and would LOVE to win Elixir.

    And Giacobetti? I have a long list of favorites, but I’d put the also-clever-brilliant-and-slightly-strange IUNX Eau Sento at the top of the list. Driftwood, incense and serenity in a (too tall) bottle.

    I haven’t tried it but would love to smell what Giacobetti and Penhaligons dream up, together.

  • I would love to win Elixir because I love spicy Rose scents in any way shape or form.I love most of Olivia Giacobetti’s perfumes and my favorite of hers which is what started me down this perfume rabbit hole is ….Dzing! Thanks for the draw!!

  • I would love to win Elixir because Olivia Giacobetti is one of my favorite perfumers and I haven’t tried this one. It sounds lovely. Right now, my favorite Giacobetti is L’Artisan Jour de Fete. I’m in the US.

  • Penhaligon’s Douro, Endimion, LP No.9 and Extract of Limes are some of my favorites from this house. I have only tried Elixir by sample and what a scent. It does smell bottle worthy. This would be such a treat to win. Thanks Nancy for a well written article. You captured my thought on this scent nicely. I am in the USA.

  • I would love to try Elixir due to the note combo of incense and spicy rose. It sounds so mysterious and alluring! My favorite Penhaligon’s perfume currently is Vaara. I’m in the U.S. Thank you for the draw!

  • I’ve never smelled Elixir but I do love spicy rose scents. The touch of Olivia Giacobetti means that the perfume won’t be heavy, which I’d like to try, and the dichotomy between hot and cold as described reminds me of one of my favorites of her creations, L’Artisan Passage d’Enfer, with it’s cool lily and hot incense. Thanks for the review and draw, I’m in the US.

  • Lately I’ve been searching for an interesting but lighter rose scent for spring and Elixir seems to fit the bill perfectly, especially knowing it’s a Giacobetti creation. I do love her sheer touch on her perfumes. My favorite from her is Hermes’ Hiris.

    Thanks for the draw. I’m in Canada.

  • Oh, I thought I didn’t want to try this one, and now I really do! Great review, Nancy N. When I lived in London, I’d always stop by the Penhaligon shop for a sniff — interesting and historic and evocative. And my very favorite Giacobetti fragrance is Eau Blanche. I’m in the US.

  • Fazal Cheema says:

    my fav. Olivia Giacobetti’s creation is Tea for Two and Lubin Idole..I know about Hamam Bouquet and wonder how Olivia has reinterpreted it in ELixir…I reside in the US

  • Elixir sounds fabulous–I’ve never tried any of Penhaligon’s offerings, sadly, but I would love for this to be the first! I’m a huge fan of Oriental scents and this sounds interesting enough to keep me happily sniffing my wrist while still being restrained enough to get away with wearing to work. “Sheer” fragrances usually aren’t my cup of tea (I like ’em big and bold!), but I trust in the genius that is Giacobetti because after all, she gave the world my beloved Dzing! and that’s really all the reason I need to try any of her other fragrances. Thank you for this wonderful draw and yes, I’m a US resident.

  • All thos ebeautiful flowers- rose, orange blossom, jasmine- count me in! My favorite Olivia Giacobetti perfume is Philosykos, with En Passant making a close second. I’m in the US.

  • Olivia seems to have a genius touch to her scents, after researching her, she has had really astounding ones with several different brands including Diptyque and L’Artisan Perfumeur, As a man, I would love the opportunity to try one of her unisex scents such as this one, it would seem to make a great addition to anyones cache. Also noted that it was very highly rated and spoke of review wise. Appreciate the draw as always. From the USA. Greg

  • Years ago I sampled Elixir and fell in love with it. It was just the earthy scent I wanted to create a hammam experience. Due to its poor sillage and longevity I never bought it but I continue to love it from afar. I would love to win it so I can maybe try layering and make it last longer. Im in the US.

  • I would love to win Elixir because I have never experienced rose and eucalyptus in a perfume before. Seems like an odd combo, but knowing Ms Giacobetti’s skills at putting together unlikely notes, I know it smells spectacular. I also love Penhaligons sheer and transparent style of perfumery that is characteristic of the house. My favorite Olivia Giacobetti fragrance is Dzing! I’m in the US. Thanks for the draw!

  • I was at Saks and should have bought this. After this beautiful review I may just call and order it by phone. Olivia Giacobett is the most amazing perfumer. I love en passant and passage d’enfer. USA resident

  • I would love to have Elixir because it sounds oddly cooling with all the spices and I am always looking for a spicy perfume that isn’t overwhelming. My favorite Olivia Giacobetti perfume is Passage d’Enfer and I live in the US. Thank you.

  • Elizabeth T. says:

    Thank you for the draw! I have never tried a rose with eucalyptus, it sounds enticing. My favorite Giacobetti perfume is Hermes Hiris. I’m in the USA.

  • Thanks to all for the kind words. Sandy, if ever there is an oriental you will be able to wear in the desert heat, this is it!

    As for the line in general, I completely understand why Penhaligon’s trades on their storied history but they have some very modern, very creative fragrances from the most innovative noses in the business, which might not be readily apparent from the emphasis on tradition in their marketing.

  • carole macleod says:

    Mille is a favorite scent of mine, and it’s the only rose eucalyptus scent I know of-before now! I think Penhaligon’s LP #9 is a genius scent, and i would welcome the opportunity to try this one.

    Thank you for an entertaining read,

    Carole (Canada)

  • Hi, I llive in the US and would love to find a perfect oriental for me hence the big interest in Elixir! Sounds just my alley and I lived in Giacobetti’s Premier Figuier for years. As for Penhaligon’s I love Douro. Thank you!!!

  • I would love to smell roses and eucalyptus together! It’s hard to pick a favorite Penhaligon’s fagrance, but mine is either Castile, Vaara, or Malabah. My favorite Giacobetti fragrance is probably the discontinued Monsoon Season. I live in the US. Thanks!

  • rivercitylizzy says:

    I am intrigued by the combination of spicy rose and eucalyptus–a note I experience as both hot and cool, resinous and bracingly camphorous. Fascinating to put these together!

    My favorite Giacobetti so far is Dzing!– I love the interplay of gourmand notes and well-worn leather.

    I am in the US.

  • I love the idea of eucalyptus cooling down the rose — two scents I adore! My favorite Giacobetti is The Pour Un Ete; my fave Penhaligon’s is Quercus! But this sounds really, really wonderful, this Elixir! 🙂

  • I’d welcome winning the Elixir because of the smoky rose. 🙂 My favorite Penhaligon’s (currently) is Iris Prima. U.S.

  • Valentine girl says:

    Like Olivia Giacobetti, I am a lover of figs, so I have to say that Philosykos & Premier Figuier are probably my favs of hers and I have always wanted to try English Fern & Night-scented Stock from Penhaligon. I would welcome the opportunity to “create the hammam experience at home” by wearing Elixir, as I don’t think I am going to have the chance to go to a real hammam anytime soon! USA resident.

  • Jennifer B says:

    My favorite Penhaligon’s frangrance is Malabah — it’s so pretty! I live in the US. Thanks for the draw!

  • tomate farcie says:

    Olivia is my favorite perfumer. My favorite is Premier Figuier. This sounds like an interesting take on rose and I’d like to try her interpretation.

  • Love the note breakdown on this! Rose and eucalyptus are an interesting combo. I have never tried a Pehaligon’s scent- would love to start! Thanks, I’m in the US.

  • I would love the chance to try Elixir! I didn’t realize this had notes of incense and spicy rose until reading this review– that makes Elixir a must-try for me. Amaranthine is my favorite Penhaligon’s but this sounds so amazing. I’m in the U.S. Thanks for the draw!

  • My favorite Penhaligon fragrances are Amaranthine, Malabah and Artemisia, and my favorite Giacobettis are just too many to count! Eucalyptus and rose wafting in the steam of a hammam… sounds perfect… I’m in the US; thanks for the draw.

  • My favorite Penhaglion fragrance is Lily of the Valley – it reminds me of my mother. I love to wear Orientals and would love to try one that you consider to be ‘above the pack.’

  • Cynthia Richardson says:

    I live in the U.S. and, while I have not tried perfumes frome either Olivia Giacobetti or Penhaligon, I would like to win Elixir because it sounds exotic, but not too girly.

  • Frankly, I cannot imagine how rose and eucalyptus would be together, but I’m sure Ms. Giacobetti has figured out a wonderful way to make that happen. I’d absolutely love to try it!

    My favorite Olivia Giacobetti composition (for this week anyway) is FM En Passant.

  • Over the years I have discovered my joy for rose fragrances. There are so many varieties of rose scents, each one different and great in its own way. Reading the article, I don’t think I ever experienced the combination of rose, spices, and eucalyptus blend, sounds very interesting. The hot and cold symbolism also reflects the change of winter to spring time, but not only in weather but in the way we wear fragrances – winter time we want something warming while passing into spring we looking for cooling scents. I really enjoy the Penhaligons Iris prima, its a beautiful scent that always makes me happy.

    USA

  • Barbara B says:

    I would like to win Elixir because it is by Olivia Giacobetti and has cardamom, cinnamon, and mace!
    Have narrowed down my favorites by her to Idole de Lubin and Tea for Two. Will have to go with Tea for Two because it is one of the few fragrances I have two back-up bottles of!!

  • would love to win Elixir, because eucalyptus in it sounds cool. My favourite Penhaligon’s is Iris Prima!