New Perfume Review: Kerosene Fragrances Broken Theories + The Light in Heartache Draw

1small dreams Claudio L'Estremo Montegriffo

Small dreams by  Claudio L’Estremo Montegriffo (digitalized MC)

Dark corners of a room seem to creep and reach out as the midnight clouds steal the last remaining shards of moonlight.  Memories of smoky dreams are lost within your mind.  Ruminating over the scent of mystery and nightfall, the fire you went through drifts along the air, the spices of heartache linger on the skin.  Assured, you know morning will come, the darkness will subside, and the theory that everything remains dreadful will be smashed and broken.”

nude in broken mirror Stephen Carrol

Nude in Broken Mirror  Stephen Caroll

This is the backstory of The House of Kerosene’s latest release, Broken Theories, which is a sweet and spicy Oriental fragrance.  I happen to love scents like these, which combine dry tobacco leaves with incense and spices, with a hit of something citrusy or tropical at the start.  If you love Slumberland’s Kiste,  or Ex Idolo’s Ryder, then Broken Theories will absolutely appeal to you.  I think these three fragrances make up my Holy Trinity of What Pam Wants Everyone Especially MenTo Smell Like.  According John Pegg is the perfumer and founder of the House of Kerosene.   “For the scent Broken Theories, the inspiration was wrapped around creating an atmospheric mood in fragrance. Developing a scent that is sad with memories, yet there’s sweetness in the fragrance that lifts the mood, to look forward to days of a better future. I guess I wanted to create with more of a moody mind sense and at the same time staying true to my style with lots of woods and warmth”.

John Pegg of House of kerosene cafleurebon B&W

John Pegg House of Kerosene

We have reviewed and followed John’s  scents since their launch in 2012, and Broken Theories is the second perfume of 2015 (following Unforsaken). His fragrances are bold statements, always seeking to push past expected and tired tropes within the genres, and drop the wearer down in an unfamiliar country armed with only a match and machete for company.

BrokenTheoriesbottlepic

Broken Theories by Kerosene

John is an entirely self-taught perfumer, and his vision is singular, muscular and a fantastic palate cleanse, especially now that Fall is here and the onslaught of Spicy Orientals are threatening to bury us all; a poorly crafted Oriental scent is to perfumery what the horrendous  Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte is to your morning wake-up call.  Fragrances like Broken Theories help to elevate the entire genre and help you remember why you love this classification to begin with.

in dreams stephen carroll 

In Dreams Stephen Carroll

The scent kicks off with blood orange and tobacco, with the tobacco taking the lead on the introductions.  Blood orange has never been one of my favorite openers, but here it is expertly placed to balance the austerity and dryness of tobacco. There’s richness and a bruised fruit ripeness at the start, and that little snap of citrus helps to keep your receptors from shutting down prematurely as you take in the rest of the fragrance.  The heart is a swooning, sweet carpet of vanilla beans and sandalwood, with spices  etching a pattern into the hand-woven kilim  rug.   The entire scent really blooms out largely here, into delicious warmth that will envelop your entire body.  The tobacco feels hand-rolled in vanilla.  I remembered why I still love changing my scent wardrobe to follow the seasons.

emerging stephen carroll

Broken Theories carries one of the best top note to heart note transitions of any scent I’ve sampled this year.  It’s nearly cinematic.  The drydown switches gears back to the original austerity of the tobacco notes, only this time its incense and oud.  I couldn’t really pick up the oud in this fragrance, except that there was something keeping the incense from getting too invasive and High Churchy under my nose, so that may have been it.  There’s definitely a Verse-Chorus-Verse feel to Broken Theories in its development, from the opening bruised-fruit blood orange against the tobacco to the burnt offering Oud next to the incense scepter in the drydown.

through a glass

Through Glass Stephen Carroll

That’s kind of the hidden joy in this scent – the way the beginning and end notes are texturally paired so perfectly against each other, with that chest-filling sigh of sweetness in the middle.  John Pegg is a master at orchestrating his scents, and it’s enormously satisfying to keep checking your wrist as they unfold.   As my palate has grown, I’ve truly come to appreciate the architecture of the scents I sample as much as the notes and feel of them, and if you’re the same, Kerosene perfumes will provide you with all kinds of fun surprises.

light through window

Light through Window (google)

Broken Theories is a fantastic release, and very well-made on all levels.  And despite the ominous backstory, I’m wearing it for rambles on country roads, and at table with family at Thanksgiving.  Because indeed, nothing SHOULD remain dreadful, and the Fall season is all about that hidden sweetness in the air, and that muzzy warmth contained in the layers of your clothes.  Broken Theories is that exact warmth from a bottle, and I need it now.

Notes: Blood orange, tobacco, spices, vanilla beans, sandalwood, Oud and incense

Pam Barr, Senior Contributor

Art Direction: MC I used many of the works of Stephen Carroll, a self taught photographer who constructs fictional tableaux

Disclaimer:  I received my sample from Kerosene

KeroseneSamples

Thanks to Jonn Pegg, we have an international draw for a registered reader (you need to do this folks and be sure to use your registered name)  of deluxe sample set of Kerosene Fragrances (12 x2 ml of each fragrance in the collection).  To be eligible, leave a comment with what you enjoyed about Pam’s review, your favorite Kerosene Fragrances  and where you live.  Draw closes on Sept. 19, 2015.

We announce the winners on our site and on our Facebook page, so Like Cafleurebon and use our RSS option…or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


36 comments

  • Very nice review. I enjoyed everything about Pam’s review, and the pictures are interesting and artistic too. I have never had a chance to try any perfume of Kerosene Fragrances, so I would be very glad, if I could try the sample set. Thanks for the draw. I’m a registered reader. I live in Europe.

  • Great review – highly evocative writing and gorgeous graphics!! I’ve only tried one Kerosene fragrance (Black Vines) so I haven’t a favorite yet. Judging from the notes of this one, it might be it! I’d love to samples the whole line!! In the US, registered reader.

  • I have known about John since he was a perfumista like all of us and actively engaged on forums such as basenotes…I am interested because Pam says it has one of the best openings she has smelled this year and moreover tobacco oud and incense are among drydown notes and i love all these notes…my fav. John’s creation is R’oud elements. thanks for the wonderful opportunity to try all through sample set. I am in the US

  • Beautiful review. I NEED this frag, like yesterday! Agree with Timea, the graphics go quite well with the review, it’s all just awesome. My favorite Kerosene frag (right now) is Unforsaken. It is quite a beauty. I’m in the US. Thanks for the draw.

  • “Tobacco rolled in vanilla” is such a great mental image. This new Kerosene fragrance sounds wonderful. My favorite is still Copper Skies. Although I do love the discontinued Whips and Roses in the gorgeous red bottle. I live in the US.

  • What I enjoyed most was this line: “the onslaught of Spicy Orientals are threatening to bury us all, a poorly crafted Oriental scent is to perfumery what the horrendous Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte is to your morning wake-up call.” Very funny. Pam also has a great talent for parsing the different stages of a scent and experiencing it as a narrative: one thing happens, and then another. Wish I’d had the pleasure of trying some of the Kerosene fragrances, but I haven’t. U.S.

  • I just loved Pam’s reference to the “orchestration” and “architecture” of Broken Theories and of John Pegg’s fragrances in general. I enjoy paying attention to structure in fragrance, and Pam just perfectly described that pleasure.

    I’ve tried several fragrances from Kerosene, but since I was fortunate enough to get a decant of Kindred a few months ago, I will choose that one as my favorite!

    I am in the US.

  • Claire spriggy says:

    I love how this is described musically ie “verse chorus verse” and “orchestrated ” as I often find myself imagining fragrances as music or at least tones. I’ve only tried 3 of the line and Unforsaken had to be purchased, it’s a delicious gourmand that manages to be refreshing and tropical. I’m in the uk and would be chuffed to bits to win the sample set.

  • Pam writes well. She made a type of perfume I usually don’t like sound great. I realized that I got a smile when I read “drop the wearer down in an unfamiliar country armed with only a match and machete for company.” I enjoyed the image this creates. I had already heard that John Pegg was self-taught. There are simply so many fragrances that I have not gotten to Kerosene, though I have heard good things about the line. In the US.

  • I haven’t had the pleasure of trying any Kerosene fragrances, but what a great opportunity to with this generous draw! I love that Pam can where this anywhere… that bodes very well for a scent. I’m in the US. Thanks again!

  • Very enjoyable and descriptive piece. Very thorough and makes we want to try this one. I still love Unknown Pleasures from Kerosene. USA

  • Another swoony review, Pam, I’m definitely buying what you’re selling! I am looking forward to trying this one, it’s like everything I love about perfume all wrapped up in fall. Of the Kerosene scents I’ve sampled, my favorite is Black Vines, it’s very fun to wear. Thanks for the great review and generous opportunity, everyone, I’m in the US.

  • Very nice description of the notes and its transition; from top to base. Vanilla, Sandalwood and Tobacco sounds great; I have difficulty with prominent Ouds, so a muted Oud in this composition is very welcome. I like Unknown Pleasures, could like Black Vines too (no opportunity to try it yet though). I live in Singapore

  • I really enjoy hearing about John’s descriptions and inspirations for his various creations and this newest fragrance sounds very appealing. My favorite Kerosene fragrance so far is Unknown Pleasures. I live in the USA. Thanks!

  • I enjoyed Pam’s review, great pen, she always write in a very appealing and evocative way. I am very much interested in experiencing notes like incense and tobacco and as Pam says the opening of this smell must be something to remember. Unfortunately, I never had the chance to experience any Kerosene perfume. I am a registered reader living in EU.

  • What a lovable choice of words and images! I felt surrounding atmosphere of some lieder by Schubert, the same wistful hope, graceful and sadness,
    the discrete beauty of the range of grays.
    I follow for some time the growing popularity of Kerosene on blogs and reviews, but I never tried his fragrances, it is time to close this gap!
    I live in Italy.

  • As the weather begins to cool, my love for white florals gives way to my passion for Orientals. I like the description of orange and tobacco. This sounds like the perfect scent to welcome autumn, football, and fireplaces. I have only tried a couple of Kerosene Fragrances but my favorite was Copper Skies. Thanks for a great review. I am in the USA.

  • Thsi sounds perfect for fall! I love tobacco and sandalwood, and the “Nude in a Broken Mirror” is so striking. I have not tried any Kerosene fragrances, and I am in the US.

  • Pam’s review was beautiful, sad, evocative, making me think of that never-ending and alone time of 4am when no hope is left. But not so with this fragrance; the ever changing notes of sadness and despair turn to hope, light and the fact that the wheel of life is ever changing – nothing ever stays the same. Just beautiful imagery in the review.
    Unfortunately i have not tried any Kerosene fragrances so i hope that via this draw, that i may have the chance. thanks from the UK.

  • When Pam says, “Broken Theories carries one of the best top note to heart note transitions of any scent I’ve sampled this year”, I believe her. Now I want to experience it. Copper Skies and Unknown Pleasures are two I enjoy from this line. I’d love to try the entire sample set. 🙂 USA

  • what an interesting review, I love the idea behind Broken Theories. I have heard of John Pegg and kerosene. I really like the image of tobacco rolled in vanilla.I think this would be great and now I am psyched to try all 12. looking at his website Unforsaken also sound great
    I like names that tell a story
    Usa reader and I think I registered under Maria

  • I like how Pam describes the transition of the fragrance, and the beautiful accompanying photographs. My favourite would be R’OUD ELEMENTS though I have yet to sample Kerosene fragrances. I live in South Africa

  • I am completely enchanted by the image of “Nude in Broken Mirror” by Stephen Caroll, just a perfect image for such a thoughtful review.

    I haven’t had the good fortune to try any Kerosene fragrances yet but Black Vines seems very interesting, and I live in the USA

  • “… the onslaught of Spicy Orientals are threatening to bury us all; a poorly crafted Oriental scent is to perfumery what the horrendous Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte is to your morning wake-up call.” I’ve got to admit that what thrilled me most about the review was Pam hating on the ubiquitous pumpkin spice! But seriously, I love the “masculine” fragrances, and Broken Theories sounds very appealing. I have not yet had the pleasure of experiencing any Kerosene scents yet. I’m in USA.

  • I enjoyed reading Pam’s description, especially “the way the beginning and end notes are texturally paired so perfectly against each other.” Living in the USA, I would really enjoy being about to fully sample John Pegg’s work.

  • Great article! John is an amazing perfumer, and I’m a huge fan of his work. I also think the bottles look incredible. My fave fragrance from the house would have to be Unknown Pleasures. I absolutely love that juice and it’ll be in my collection forever.

    I’m in Canada.

  • This is my favorite part of the review : “Broken Theories carries one of the best top note to heart note transitions of any scent I’ve sampled this year. It’s nearly cinematic. “.

    I did not have the lucky chance to try any of the Kerosene Fragrances creations til’ now but I hope I will.

    I am a registered reader from the EU.

    Thank you very much! Wish you all the best!

  • That blood orange and tobacco combo on top interests me a lot. I love both of those notes but don’t think I’ve ever tried them in the same fragrance. This would be a great one for the cooler weather. The only scent I’ve tried from Kerosene was Unforsaken and it was fantastic. I’m a Canadian reader and thank you for the draw!

  • I like that Pam seems so perfectly attuned to John’s vision for the scent, but keeps her own assessment of it focused and clear – nicely done! I haven’t sampled any Kerosene fragrances yet (and am sorry I missed the chance to try Whips and Roses…). I’m in the US; thanks for the draw.

  • I love the photos!! So haunting. The descriptions are so poetic which makes me really want to try them all!! I have never heard of this line, so obviously I don’t have a favorite, but I would like to!! Thanks. Roxann

  • I love Unknown Pleasures, which is the only scent I’ve sampled so far– sets are my favorite, I’d love a chance to try them all!
    The thing about ubiquitous pumpkin spice/ Spicy Orientals is that it’s great if you love warm spicy stuff because there are so many choices; the problem is many/most are indeed poorly crafted.

    It’s exhausting to wade through it all, so I definitely appreciate thoughtful reviews. Like this one, especially: ” There’s definitely a Verse-Chorus-Verse feel to Broken Theories in its development, from the opening bruised-fruit blood orange against the tobacco to the burnt offering Oud next to the incense scepter in the drydown…..That’s kind of the hidden joy in this scent – the way the beginning and end notes are texturally paired so perfectly against each other, with that chest-filling sigh of sweetness in the middle. ”
    Thank you

    I’m in USA.

  • Rincoglionita says:

    Pam’s comparison of bad Orientals to pumpkin spice latte made me laugh, and I appreciate her thoughtful, evocative descriptions. I’ve yet to try anything from the Kerosene house, but Broken Theories sounds perfect. I’m in the US–thanks for the draw.

  • I love “what Pam wants everyone especially Men to smell like,” because I am very much of the opinion that men and women oughta smell different! I have heard a lot about this house and have never put my nose to any Kerosenes but have been DYING to do so! I m in New York City in the US – fingers crossed!

  • Pam wrote a wonderful evocative review. She makes this new Kerosene fragrance sound delicious. My favorite Kerosene fragrance is R’Oud Elements, but I really only have tried 3 fragrances until now. I’m in Europe. Thanks for the draw!

  • Incredible review once again Pam. I like this fragrance because of how daring and masculine it sounds. I wonder how the vanilla is in the scent. Nonetheless, great creation by John! My favorite from the house so far is Pretty Machine. I am in Canada and thanks for the draw!

  • Pam really got me in a sweet melancholic route, I could follow all through the colder seasons! Therefore, Broken Theories is a must-try!
    I am wrapping myself with the idea that a broken heart is just another way to let the light into your soul! It is another opportunity, not an end.
    I always find Kerosene fragrances I know to be evocative of certain powerful states of mind, at some certain game-changing points of life. I love Fields of Rubus and Unknown Pleasures.
    I am in Bulgaria (EU). Thank you for the chance!