New Perfume Review: Etat Libre d’Orange You or Someone Like You (Chandler Burr and Caroline Sabas) 2017 + You Could Be For You Draw

Chandler Burr (photo Chandler Burr)

You or Someone Like You, the newest release from Etat Libre d’Orange, has been on my mind (and wrists) a lot lately. You or Someone Like You, like almost every fragrance I’ve tried from Etat Libre d’Orange, fascinates me for a number of reasons. I love the ethos of the house: “…luxurious, provocative, sometimes ironic, often subversive, and always elegant.”  With You or Someone Like You I am especially intrigued by the fact that Etienne de Swardt, founder and creative director of Etat Libre d’Orange, handed over complete creative and artistic control of the project to journalist, author, perfume critic and curator of olfactory art, Chandler Burr.  I consider Chandler’s Burr’s fragrance books, The Emperor of Scent (2003) and The Perfect Scent: A Year Inside the Perfume Industry in Paris and New York (2008), to be required reading for anyone interested in the art of  olfaction and fragrance.

 

Chandler Burr, Etienne de Swardt, Mx. Justin Vivien Bond and Ralf Schweiger February 8, 2013 at  Museum of Art and Design NYC (photo: Etat Libre D’Orange)

Chandler Burr is well-known for his reviews as perfume critic for The New York Times (2006 – 2010) and for founding the Department of Olfactory Art at the Museum of Art and Design in New York City in 2010 to name a few of his accomplishments. The fact that Chandler Burr has written about hundreds of fragrances and has an intimate knowledge and understanding of the world of perfumery made me even more interested in what he would bring to a fragrance of his own. 

I was eager to experience the work of Chandler Burr and perfumer Caroline Sabas and was challenged by what Chandler Burr, in the role of creative director, had to say about You or Someone Like You: “The raw materials are completely irrelevant. The work is the work. If you need to know what it’s made of, don’t wear it; You is not for you.”

You or Someone Like You Book Cover

In 2009, Chandler Burr wrote the novel You or Someone Like You set in  the Hollywood Hills of Los Angeles, CA. The female protagonist and central character of the novel, Anne Rosenbaum, is the muse for the new eponymous fragrance. Although I did go over the press release for the perfume I have not read the novel. I approached You as I approach most of the fragrances I review, purposefully avoiding lists of perfumer’s notes before taking my first sniff. With an “open mind” and few preconceived notions or expectations, I believe I am more likely to judge the work for what it really is (to me) and not for what it is suggested to be.

David Hockney, Celia in a Black Dress with White Flowers, 1972 ©

So what is You to me? I noticed that there was something pleasantly familiar about You. You or Someone Like You smells very much like someone I know and love. But who? You has all of the sparkling and confident characteristics of a strong, self-assured woman (or man). You projects an ethereal and joyous quality that makes me reach for it again and again.

A Lawn Being Sprinkled, 1967 David Hockney©

You or Someone Like You opens as a cool, crisp, vaguely green herbal cologne and develops into a veil of mint, translucent white flowers and perhaps wet rose leaves or buds. Mint can be a very tricky note in fragrance, as it can recall the scent (or flavor) of toothpaste, chewing gum or a variety of personal care products. In You, though, the mint effect is simply – for lack of a better word – exquisite.  After about an hour the mint (or whatever it might be) morphs into something like eucalyptus and pepper, eventually drying to a honeyed jasmine or perhaps dilute, delicate honeysuckle over a wet, clean, slightly rosy musk. 

The Group XI 1984, David Hockney©

You or Someone Like You is never overwhelming and lasts for about six hours close to my skin. While You is not always me, You or Someone Like You is a fragrance I enjoy any time of the day or nightand feel comfortable wearing anywhere. I believe that many of you will too. Listed Notes: Rose, mint and herbs.

Disclosure: I am  grateful to Etienne de Swardt of Etat Libre d’Orange for the generous lab sample of You or Someone Like You.  My opinions are my own.

Gail Gross – Editor

Art Direction: Michelyn Camen, Editor in Chief -I chose the art of David Hockney, often called the father of British pop art who moved to Hollywood Hills in 1984. 

Thanks to the generosity of Etat Libre D’Orange we have one 50ml bottle of You or Someone Like You for one registered reader in the US, Canada or the EU (be sure to register or your comment will not count). To be eligible, tell us where you live, your favorite fragrance from Etat Libre d’Orange or your favorite book by Chandler Burr. Do you think that You could be for You – or someone like you? Draw closes 3/17/2017.

We announce the winners only on site and on our Facebook page, so Like Cafleurebon and use our RSS feed…or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume.

 

 

     

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


47 comments

  • I live in the US and I have never tried and fragrance from Etat Libre D’Orange, but I would really love to try You or Someone Like You, it sounds like a lovely fragrance.

  • I’m in Canada. I have a few favourites from Etat Libre d’Orange but probably at the top is Fat Electrician. I really need to read Chandler Burr’s books soon!

  • BostonScentGuy says:

    I love lots of ELDO scents: Like This, Jasmine et Cigarette, Charogne (though it can be hard to wear), and Afternoon of a Faun are a few. Not familiar with Chandler Burr’s books…but gotta say that his quote about this scent not being for those who like knowing what’s in their scent is a bit pretentious! I do think I would love this scent, however…it sounds distinct and unique, but subtle and also “uncomplicated.” Thanks for the draw! I’m in the US.

  • I’m in Romania (EU).
    I’ve sampled some of the fragrances in their lineup, and my favourite was Divin`Enfant. 🙂
    haven’t read anything by Chandler Burr.

  • cardinalmind says:

    This site has been extremely generous and I’d like to get this chance to gift this to someone who made me happy before. Yes it could be nice to have it for myself but its even better to share something with someone and know that they really like it. I live in the US.
    My favorite one from ELDO will always be Fat Electrician. I’ve only read “The Emperor of Scent” from him but I like it nonetheless.

  • Hikmat Sher Afridi says:

    Great article & fascinating review! You or Someone Like You is a welcoming fragrance. YOU OR SOMEONE LIKE YOU is that define or represent you. My favorite ELDO fragrances which I enjoy wearing are:TOM OF FINLAND and RIEN.
    Thanks to the generosity of Etat Libre D’Orange and Cafleurebon for the opportunity to participate in the draw by letting my relative address in US.

  • I’m not very familiar with ELDO, but I think this would be a fragrance that I would like to try. I have not read anything by Chandler Burr. Thanks for the draw. I live in the USA

  • GrandmaGaga says:

    My favorite fragrance from ELDO is probably The Afternoon of a Faun. Although I am always meaning to, I have not read any of Mr. Burr’s books. I appreciate the generous giveaway. I am from the US.

  • There are so many ELDO I own. Favorites being Hermann, Rien and Tom of Finland with fat electrician in the running too. I have read the emperor of scent about Luca Turin and vaguely remember something he did open sky I think it was called. Is that still around ?
    It’s interesting that Gail doesn’t really look at notes when she gets a fragrance but she must know a lot about perfume herself. I am not sure if You is for me but I am interested in finding out.
    I live in LA

  • The name of this perfume is sure to evoke memory of certain someone in everyone’s life. It can be a childhood friend, the next door girl or a special crush.

    The note and description speaks to me. I would like to try it.
    In WA,USA

  • fazalcheema says:

    This looks like interesting fragrance. Gail is right about mint being a challenging note as it can remind us of many things we use everyday such as toothpaste and chewing gum. I like the painting by Hockney in the article. My favorite from ELDO is Jasmin et Cigarette of whom I own multiple bottles. I am in the US.

  • Wonderful review, which certainly created a lemming for me. I have been looking for mint that doesn’t evoke Listerine; this fragrance definitely sounds like a winner.

    My favorite ELDO scent is “Like This”.

    I am in the U.S.

  • I find Hermann à mes Côtés me Paraissait une Ombre quite good, others are rather ‘interesting’. This You scent could easily be for me, I like mint! To be sent to Germany, if I won.

  • I love Fils de Dieu and would really like to try more of ELDO’s fragrances. I’m in the Netherlands.

  • I love ELDO. I don’t have a ”signature perfume” (I wear and try too much weird stuff for this), I can actually imagine wearing nothing but ELDO fragrances for the rest of my life. The only other house that comes even close is Guerlain, and that would be harder.

    My two firmest favourites are Jasmin et Cigarette and Vierges et Toreros. Though I like ”Like This”

    I love this review. And I’d love to try mint done well.

    I live in the UK (Scotland).

  • Really interesting review. You or Someone Like You sounds very nicely, I would like to try it. I have never tried any of Etat Libre d’Orange perfumes, and I have not read any book by Chandler Burr. Thank you for the chance. I live in Europe.

  • Iuno Feronia says:

    Nice and interesting Review. I like this perfume house although I cannot wear all of their perfumes. You or Someone like you sounds very likeable. I haven#t read any article or book of Mr Burr untill now but next Holidays are coming up.

    Thanks for th draw, i Live in the EU.

  • ntabassum92 says:

    I am in the US, and my favorite fragrance from Etat Libre d’Orange is Like This. I think You or Someone Like You could definitely be for me, that mint sounds amazing. I love mint in food, and it rarely smells like toothpaste to me, so I can’t wait to try this one. Thanks for the chance!

  • I enjoyed the review! My favorite ELDO fragrance is Putain des Palaces, the only one I own so far. By others comments, I clearly need to sample
    More!

  • Favorite ELDO creation is Rien in a close fight with Jasmine et Cigarette.

    I believe it is for me and I love the name of this perfume. ELDO’s names are always original and in tune with the fragrances somehow.

    I am a reader from the EU.

    Thank you! Wish you all the best!

  • Great review! I have ordered a sample of “You…” and was so pleasantly surprised! Green and delicate, very luminous and fresh. A perfect fit for spring 🙂 I love ELdO for its conceptual and artistic approach, and most above all for its great sense of humour!

    My favorite fragrance from the line is Putain des Palaces.

    I live in France! Thank you for the draw 🙂

  • My favorite ELDO is Tom of Finland. I loved both of Chander Burr’s books equally. I’m hoping this new ELDO can be for me. USA

  • I love many of ELO’s fragrances, but particularly L’après midi d’un faune. “You” is for me, I am sure: its mint note would complete my Spring.
    I live in the UK (EU).

  • Based on the review, I think this could be for someone like me 🙂
    Although there are quite a few I like from ELDO, my favorite is the duo Rien/Rien Intense Incense, they are so well blended, bold and sexy!
    I live in the EU.

  • I don’t get into the city very often to put my nose around many niche level fragrances. In the years as my nose has developed I do enjoy the higher quality that the Designer level leaves me wanting MORE… Many reviews praise this house of Etat Libre d’Orange! I would love to have a chance to try a creation from this praised house! I do live Illinois. THANK YOU

  • I’m a fan and owner of a bunch of ELDO fragrances, and have a different favorite for each mood, but if I had to pick only one, I’d pick Bijou Romantique.

    I’m in the U.S. Thank you!

  • Gail is using the best way to sniff perfumes which is not looking at the listed notes. I try to do this all the time. In this case you are not going to be confused with the listed notes and more you focus on the perfume. Had a chance to try “Like this” and “Rien” from the house; Both are very good perfumes. By the way thank you for introducing painting and books. Live in TX, USA. Thanks!

  • I think it’s for someone like me, because I love mint and the season is coming! My favorite ELDO perfume is Rien.
    I live in EU.

  • I’m in the US and I own a few ELDO scents, so my favorite varies depending on season and weather. Recently, Rien has been in fairly heavy rotation but ask me next week and it’ll probably change 🙂

    As to mint, as tricky as it is, I absolutely love it, particularly in that opening of Geranium Pour Monsieur, and I would love to try this one as well.

  • i still have a bad smell in my — ah — nose (?) from cafleurebon’s first introduction of this scent and chandler burr’s unsufferable arrogance on display there. on that count, i will pass on this one.

  • I’m in the U.S., and my favorite Chandler Burr book is The Perfect Scent. I look forward to sniffing You or Someone Like You.

  • This has caught my attention since I first heard about the fragrance on Cafleurebon. I would love to try this – I have not read any Chandler Burr books, but loved buying the Chandler Burr Series fragrances and wearing something completely without a name until the reveal. That was a lot of fun and great experience. So often we prejudge by name only. Probably not just in perfumes either. I have some samples of Etat Libre d’Orange frags but off hand do not know which ones. I’m in US and registered. Thank you so much.

  • Great collaboration, I’m really looking forward to trying this perfume by ELDO. My favorite so far is Jasmine et Cigarettes and I love all three books by Chandler. Perfume needs to be recognized more as an art form!!
    I’m in the UK

  • Musonda Mwewa says:

    I live in Orange, Connecticut, USA.

    I only know of Secretion Magnifique.. …so I guess that would be my favorite from the house. Haha

    I I would be for YOU OR SOMEONE LIKE YOU because of its cool crisp mint like nature. Even though L’eau Boisee is my only experience of vetiver and mint, and I’m actually wearing it now, I’d love to add a cool crisp fragrance of this house’s elegance to my collection.and it would be great to experience all the fragrance.

    Thanks

  • I like the impression I have about this fragrance after reading the review. I am recently using a lot of good old Sex Pistols, I like its energetic freshness.
    Thanks for the draw. I live in the EU.

  • cinnamon tree says:

    Great name and so interesting combination of rose and mint. I remember drinking rose and mint tea once, it was a wonderful experience.
    I live in Europe and I’d love to try Tou Or Someone Like You.

  • I live in the southwest US and feel very interested to experience a perfume evocative of this part of the world. The scent from Etat Libre d’Orange I find most wearable is Like This. I definitely could be for You or Someone Like You. A copy of the novel is on its way to me now. Quite exciting. Thank you for the entertaining review and for the generous draw.

  • I love the name of this fragrance. So different. and the notes sound amazing. Ive not tried any fragrances by Etat Libre d’Orange but would really love to try this one. Thank you for the wonderful generous opportunity again. Im in the USA.

  • As a big fan of ELdO I have many favorites: Like This, Rien, Jasmin et Cigarettes. I am so curious about You or Someone Like You and I’d love it to be Me or Someone Like Me. Very good name for a perfume for someone who is as possessive about fragrances as I am. Thank you for the draw. EU.

  • I just received a small decant of La Fin du Monde and I’m really enjoying it. Thank you for the great review and generous draw!!
    I live in Europe

  • And another rose. Yes, someone like me definitely would smell of roses (and of herbs, as a pleasant background). Thank you so much for the draw!

    (EU)

  • My favorite Etat Libre is recently Rossy de Palma Eau de Protection – I love it!
    I enjoyed the review of You Or Someone Like You very much and I hope to be lucky this time.
    I live in Europe. Thank you for so generous draw.

  • My fav ELDO is Cologne. Just simple, classy, and exquisite. Love that one. I think the mint in this one is perfectly balanced. I look forward to getting my nose on it. I’m in Canada and thanks for the draw.

  • doveskylark says:

    I would love to see if the mint and jasmine notes would work on my skin. I love Rien from ELDO. This line is so much fun. I just try their fragrances for their names, not the notes.
    I live in the USA.