New Natural Fragrance Reviews: JoAnne Bassett Rose Kiss & Rose Smoke + Two Roses Perfume Draw

cafleurebon JAB rose joanne 2

JoAnne Bassett

JoAnne Bassett is a natural perfumer and aromatherapist who is truly a pioneer in natural perfumery and who flung open the doors of this genre for the world to see, and sniff, since the millennia turned. Her catalog is impressive, as are her perfumes. Her two newest releases are a beautiful duo of rose anointing oils, just in time for summer weddings, falling in love and celebrating the Queen of Flowers while she is still in full bloom. All JoAnne’s scents are natural. Not that they use a few oils and some other “stuff”-these are all natural essences, a great deal of which were grown organically by the perfumer herself, in a base of organic alcohol. One of the reasons she took the leap from aromatherapy to perfumery is to be able to create and blend Nature into her art and take others on perfumed journeys and help to open people up to the subtler energies in the flowers, fruits, spice and woods.

Sergio Lopez - Heliotrope

Sergio Lopez heliotrope

Without any synthetic compounds to “confuse” the nose, Ms. Bassett has once again created something beautiful with these two scents. I was not always the biggest fan of rose in perfumes and loathe smelling “rose-in-a-blender” scents. I am always a bit skeptical of rose perfumes; especially if the perfumer in question has already released some rose perfumes. Though there are many types of roses, most perfumes always seem to have that same accord to them that smacks of something somewhere between Avon’s (bombastically shrill, and thankfully discontinued) Roses, Roses, a lotion sold when I was a lad called “Rose Milk” and just plain old rose essential oil. Here the words of the Bard come to mind: “Would a rose by any other name, smell as sweet?” The answer, here, is a resounding YES.

sergio_lopez_painted_roses_studies_

This duo is not your typical day/night pair or even his/hers, both are unisex. It shows us two very distinct sides of the rose, with the rose(s) used and dramatic orthogonal accenting notes, while shining a spotlight on its beauty, complexity and richness. These are perfect for weddings, commitment ceremonies or anything that involves sharing and showing love. They can be worn alone, or layered together. They would make an awesome gift to give to someone you loved, instead of real roses which will wither fade and die eventually. This is something that will keep that loving feeling alive, in a way no true rose ever could: you can enjoy it whenever you want, and instead of enjoying just the smell of some short-lived flowers you can waft their true beauty and share it with others.

SergioLopez-Goldyla

Sergio Lopez Goldya

Rose Kiss centers around Egyptian Damask rose absolute (rosa damascena) and captures her floral and fruity nuances without forgetting about the greens and the stems. It radiates an aura of rosiness, yet never gets overpowering or too much to bear; as some rose perfumes can, even naturals. This is the aroma of the sun-warmed rose still on the bush, not the cut rose stripped of her foliage and placed in a cold glass vase with water. Her warmth and softness shine through as do her subtler, more oriental, qualities. Though the notes are listed as if this were a linear fragrance, it has some development. Sheer warmth and bright floral notes pervade then move softly aside, but are not completely out of the picture, as a deliciously dynamic duo of French vanilla and cocoa absolutes emerge-adding that “golden glow” and a soft dry sweetness and drawing out its more carnal and sensual qualities.

Sergio_Lopez-Chromatella_6x12_Painted_Roses_forweb

Sergio Lopez  Cromatella

Described as “sweet, and slightly musky” on the company’s website, this lists no musk whatsoever. What the perfumer has done with Turkish Oman frankincense and balsam is gorgeous. The colder smoother incense resin is balanced and held in check by the green woody balsam and neither is too sharp nor too medicinal. They way in which Ms. Bassett has lovingly enmeshed all the raw materials is really most impressive. The natural sheer muskiness of the roses themselves, heightened by heavenly resins and edible sweetness, make Rose Kiss sexy, but never common. Mature, but never old or dated, with an eternally youthful heart this perfume takes the timeless association of roses with love and romance, bottles it and seals it with a fragrant lingering kiss. Sillage: above average. Longevity: good.

SergioLopez_Rose_Noir_6x6_Painted_Roses_forweb

Sergio Lopez Rose Noir

Rose Smoke lists no “smoke accord” or even any birch or vetiver, yet it presents as this delightful slightly dirty smoke infused rose. Even though this flower has been scorched on its edges and been covered in smoke it still smells fabulous. The rose featured here is Rose de Mai (May rose). A softer gentler rose than the Damask, this rose has a creamy texture to it that may not smell as strongly as its Turkish cousin but is denser and richer. The intrinsic charm of this particular rose is magnified with the sweet aura of French vanilla and the dark earthy tobacco absolute. The smoke stains and charred edges cannot hide the true beauty of this bloom as she opens, thick and full, to embrace you lovingly and sincerely.

Sergio Lopez-Gemini-Molineux

Sergio Lopez Gemini Molyneux

When one hears of a new “rose duo” being released, one thinks: two iterations of the same rose…with minor changes here and there. What is unique and wonderful about these perfumes is the key rose note is different in each one, as are the modifying sweeter notes. What remained the same was the balsam and frankincense pairing that kept them both exotic but down to earth. In Rose Smoke the resin pair helps add the woody smokiness and the sweetness of the other notes is actually turned down a notch. The May rose is shier, not quite as pretty as and more retiring than the Damask; yet, I find it infinitely more interesting and definitely more lovely and charming. I vacillated back and forth the entire time I was testing and wearing these oils to decide which one was my favorite. After multiple wearings, this one eventually won out. Sillage: average. Longevity: very good.

cafleurebon JAB rose book 8

When I received these delightful oils for review I also received a copy of JoAnne Bassett’s new book “Sacred Scents”. As I sniffed my rose-coated wrists again and again while reading her words, it made me feel what the author was saying. Part story, part memoir, part spiritual treatise this book was like sitting and chatting with the author/perfumer herself. She speaks of the virtues of natural perfumes, her own personal journey to perfumer and tries to peer behind the curtain at why scent is so powerful to us and how it can be harnessed for personal growth and spiritual happiness. It is a quick read, but quite profound. I am one of those who, when sniffing a great scent, try and imagine just what the perfumer must have been thinking….now, we know!

Disclosure: Reviews based on samples of rose duo anointing oils and a proof of “Sacred Scents” sent to me by JoAnne Bassett.

cafleurebon JAB rose duo 3

JoAnne Bassett Two Sides of the Rose

Thanks to Joanne Bassett we have a draw for a coffret of these oils one for the US and one for the rest of the world. To be eligible leave a comment on which one you believe will be your favorite and if you are a non USA reader. The draw ends July 20, 2013.

We announce the winners only on site and on our Facebook page, so Like Cafleurebon and use our RSS option…or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume.

John Reasinger, Senior Editor

Art Direction Michelyn Camen, EIC- I chose the beautiful work of Bay Area Artist Sergio Lopez's Painted Roses Series which are available for sale or learn more about his work at the Modern Eden gallery click here

Editor’s Note: JoAnne’s book Sacred Scents is available in a Kindle edition for those who like their books in digital format.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


70 comments

  • Chris Schaefer says:

    They sound wonderful. I think that I am drawn a bit more to the Rose Smoke.

  • Monica H. says:

    I was captured by Ross Kiss from the review but normally would go for something smoky like Rose Smoke =) Good thing the draw is for both! I’m international and thanks to Joanne for offering it to us!

  • ElizabethN says:

    Oh my, these sound beautiful. Rose Smoke sounds a little more like my type for its tobacco and creamy rose. Thanks for the draw!

  • Leathermountain says:

    Rose Smoke sounds like me. Then again I am always up for a great surprise! In US.

  • Chapeau Clack says:

    Tobacco is a big favorite, so Rose Smoke it is. Although Rose Kiss sounds absolutely delightful. How lovely that both are included in the draw, thank you, JoAnne, for such a generous offer!
    I’m international.

  • Joanne always captures me with her Fragrances. I like rose but a toned down rose. I would have to agree with Monica on this one good thing it is for both. I would however choose the Rose Smoke. Thanks to Cafleurebon and Joanne for such a great opportunity. Love Sacred Scents as well..

  • Oh, such beautiful descriptions for both of these! Rose Smoke is just barely edging out Rose Kiss. Thanks for the draw.

  • Rose Smoke is more my style, given that I love a good incensey smouldering scent. I’m international, by the way!

  • These sound lovely! I think either could be my fave, but I’ll go with Rose Kiss. Thanks for the draw! Live in the US.

  • Beautiful! And I want to read her book!
    Rose Kiss delighted me but both sound amazing! Thank you!

  • Rebecca Morgan says:

    I love rose incense, so I think Rose Smoke would be my favourite, but they both sound lovely. I’m international 🙂

  • Sherri Volf says:

    I would love the opportunity to try some of JoAnn’s creations! They sound amazing. I’m living in Europe and honestly have no idea where to sample any natural perfumes and am grateful for this fantastic draw. Rose Smoke sounds so intriguing!

  • Rose Kiss, I believe. I have to say that I love all the naturals you’ve been featuring! I live in the USA.

  • The art work for this review is so beautiful!

    I believe I will pick Rose Kiss. What a great draw! I live in the U.S.

  • I think I would slightly prefer the Rose Smoke, but the Rose Kiss also sounds lovely. It doesn’t matter which one I get if I win, either one would be fine.
    I live in Europe.

  • Both sound great but since I prefer Rose de Mai to Damask I would probably like Rose Smoke better. I find Rose de Mai somewhat muskier with facets that remind human skin and sweat.
    Non US

  • Rose Smoke sounds fabulous, very rich and unusual.
    The book is now on my radar too!
    I am international

  • i think I might like Rose Smoke. I’m still looking for a great combo of rose and smoke. I’ve tried a few, but they always seem to be heavy-handed in one way or another.
    I’m in the EU

  • I think I would like “Rose Smoke” better
    thanks for the draw
    I’m international

  • Fazal Cheema says:

    i am definitely interested in rose kiss because it has rose damascena which is probably what makes nombre noir so beautiful as well. i am based in US

  • PatriciaC says:

    Rose smoke i think would be more for me but hard to tell both sound so wonderful. This is a wonderful article and wonderful draw! U.S.

  • I enjoyed this review, especially Michelyn’s choice of art by Sergio Lopez, which is so feminine and sensual! Both of these scents sound wonderful; but my first choice would be Rose Kiss. I like the idea of these anointing oils! I live in the US- thanks for this great draw!

  • Mmmm, I do love my rose scents, and these sound delicious! I believe Rose Kiss might be my favorite of the two–rose, vanilla, and cocoa, OH MY–but who knows? I’m in the US.

  • I think Rose Kiss might be my favorite, but I am intrigued by Rose Smoke. I am in the U.S. Thanks for the draw.

  • Rose Smoke sounds totally for me, rose + tobacco!
    I’m non US
    Thank you for the draw

  • I think Rose Smoke would be the one I would love most betweeen both..I am an international reader..
    Thank you for this draw

  • Michelle U says:

    Rose Smoke could be a favorite! ^_^

    Thank you for the draw! Wish you all the best!

    P.S. I am from the E.U.

  • I live in the U.S. and, while both sound wonderful, I think Rose Smoke would slightly edge out Rose Kiss…my quest for the perfect rose continues! Thanks!

  • I think I would prefer Rose Kiss but I could be wrong and would love to find out 😉 I am in the US.

  • hmmm – I have the tendency to favor a more smokey musk note so I would probably go with the Rose Smoke. however, I am typically not a fan of rose scents and must say that I am intrigued by the write up you have provided for both the Smoke & the Kiss… thinking I might like to mix the two together as I believe it was suggested somewhere?!? now *that* sounds loverly! tyvm for the US draw 😉

  • Mmm tobacco absolute!!!!!! I would love Rose Smoke, however both sound absolutely (because they are made from absolutes haha) lovely.

    I am in the US.

  • Christine B says:

    Your review makes both sound lovely but Rose Smoke is the one that most appeals. I am an international reader.

  • I am excited about both of the perfumes, but since I have to choose I’d love to try Rose Smoke! Thank you, and I am in the US.

  • Both sound interesting and wonderful. I think my favorite might be Rose Kiss. I live in the US. Thank you for the drawing.

  • This is a tough call, but I think I’d probably pick Rose Smoke. I would love both. Thank you for another draw. I’m in the US.

  • It is truly a toss-up as they both sound enjoyable. I’m slightly leaning toward Rose Smoke. Thanks!

  • It sounds as if the Rose Smoke would be more to my liking. I enjoy the smell of damask rose on the flower but any rose scents that I have ever tried turn to a bad soapy smell on my skin. I am in the US and would be delighted to win. Thanks for the draw!

  • Tourbillion says:

    I think that I would like both scents, but I like the idea of the Frankincense in the Rose Kiss. I am in the USA.

  • Both sound amazing, but the frankincense and balsam in Rose Kiss made me very curious. I live in the UK.

  • d3m0lici0n says:

    Both sound really cool but I think I’d like Rose Smoke a bit more. I live in the US. Thanks for another cool draw!

  • angiefunk says:

    JoAnne is a wonderful perfume, I sure both of these perfumes are stunning. I think I could like both equally. I really think rose kiss could be wonderful due to the frankincense from oman and Rose Smoke due to the smoke and vanilla two scents I love together. Thank you for the draw again JoAnne and John. I live in the US.

  • I vote for Rose Smoke, though it may just be the reviewer’s enthusiasm that ultimately swayed the balance! I live in South Africa.

  • I love JoAnne’s creations, they are trully inspirational!! Rose smoke would be my choice of the two I love a dirty smoky rose!! I live in the UK

  • I pick Rose Smoke. Both sound great, but this one sounds exactly like my type.

    Thanks for the draw. I’m international.

  • Not an easy choice, my friend!
    I’ll go with the Smoke.
    Still Livin’ in America.

  • They both sound gorgeous, but Rose Smoke is definitely the one for me. I am located in the U.S. Thanks for the draw!

  • Not an easy choice, my friend!
    I’ll go with the Smoke.
    Thanx for the chance!
    Still Livin’ in America.

  • They both sound utterly beautiful, and the review is great. If I had to choose, I’d lean towards Rose Kiss. I live in the U.S. Thank you for the chance to try it!

  • As wonderful as they both sound, I think Rose Kiss embodies the delicate balance of the ideal rose sent, conjuring ideas of true love and the sweet yet impassioned promise of forever.. I am in the US, fingers crossed

  • Anything I’ve tried Of JoAnne’s has been lovely. Rose Smoke has me intrigued, so that would be my pick.

  • I live in both, but am going back to Singapore in a week so I’ll call it home for now.

  • I will go with Rose Smoke. Sounds like an amazing fragrance!

    I’m international.

  • Chris Schaefer says:

    I did think that I had commented….but must have gotten distracted. Rose Smoke sounds amazing!