Commodity Fragrances Book Review (Ketrin Leka) + Autumnal Contemplation Draw

 

Commodity Fragrances Book Perfume

 Gina Litherland Scholar of the Dark Armchair 2008

 

A room without books is like a body without a soul.” ~ Cicero

 

Book by Commodity Fragrances 

 Gina Litherland Conversation with a  Cat©

100% of Meisters (by blood, marriage or choice) concur heartily with Cicero; we are unanimous in this (thank you, Mrs. Slocum from Britcom “Are You Being Served?”). I dare you to cross the threshold of any of our domiciles and NOT be bombarded – or brained – by any number of tomes and volumes organized, piled high or scattered throughout its environs. One of my deepest sorrows two years ago, when they sold our building on M. Street after 35 years – was the necessity of culling a lifetime of amassed books because there would never be enough room for them all. We venerate both the spoken and written word: you can observe us cracking open the spine of a book with greedy anticipation and holding it up to our noses to breathe it in. Each of us; all of us.

Best Commodity Fragrances

 photo by Sebastian©

Commodity Fragrances was purchased by U.S. distributor of niche perfumes Vicken Arslanian of Europerfumes/ Eden Square nearly one year ago. The demand for Commodity Fragrances had exceeded the original company’s ability to keep up. They may not be available in brick-and-mortar stores, but one may currently purchase them online. It’s a way of maintaining artistic integrity as well as the brand’s reputation; while they are no longer on Sephora’s shelves (where most folk, including myself – became familiar with them), you can continue to enjoy any favorites you may already have, or explore them if you haven’t yet done so.

 Book Garden by Gina Litherland artist 

Gina Litherland’s oil on wood painting Book Garden, 2000

 It’s not uncommon that my sense of a perfume sometimes differs from its written copy. Commodity Fragrances Book doesn’t conjure images of either Hemingway or Fitzgerald for me, or the New York Public Library where a good chunk of my childhood was spent with my favorite Tante Sylvia. For me, it is a conceptual fragrance – one which refers to fresh wood pulp, sylvan settings rather than a library. I find it to be a perfect scent commensurate with autumnal contemplation: at first brilliant with bergamot and eucalyptus nestled against the gentle dry amber-tinged leatheriness of Virginia cedar and heavenly rosewood (one of my favorite woods). Alaskan cypress goes by many other names (Alaskan yellow cedar, yellow cypress, Nootka cypress), but when I smelt it, it screamed ‘nootka!’ to me – a very tonic, bracing herbal/terpenic aroma, drily spicy and woody. This tree flourishes in the Pacific Northwest where it is harvested. It’s also known for a pungent grapefruit-like tone which is bright and astringent, making it a fine companion to the varieties of woody components inherent in Book. Amyris, aka West Indian Sandalwood (no relation to actual sandalwood, grown in Haiti and the Dominican Republic) – contributes a sweet balsamic note which fades to a more subtle vanillic woodiness; it pairs well with authentic sandalwood and lends tenacity as a fixative. Along with amber and musk, the perfume lingers indefinitely upon the flesh, even though it tends to wear more intimately with the progression of time. Amber utilized here is more of an arid ligneous sort, not sweetly resinous; the recreation of velvet might possibly include Cashmeran, Iso E Super and/or any of the gentler aromachemical musks. Book‘s drydown reveals a sylvan murmur amidst a pile of drying multi-hued leaves. Artist friend Gina Litherland depicts the mood precisely in her oil painting Book Garden: I want to be that faunal creature conversing with my fox in the forest, where books bloom atop hardy stalks surrounded by an aromatic carpet of autumn leaves – festooned with a foliage crown and an opossum for additional company.

Notes: Virginia cedarwood, bois de rose, eucalyptus, bergamot, Alaskan cypress, amyris, amber, musk, sandalwood, velvet

  Commodity Fragrances Book Tester generously provided by Europerfumes/Eden Square – many thanks!  My nose is my own…

 ~ Ida Meister, Senior Editor and Natural Perfumery Editor

 

 Commodity Fragrances Book review

Commodity Fragrances Book image via Commodity Fragrances website and Unsplash /digital efffects Michelyn

  Thanks to Europerfumes, the new owner of Commodity Fragrances, we have a 100 ml bottle tester of Book  EDP for a registered ÇafleureBon reader in the USA ONLY (if you are not sure if you are registered click here (you must register on our site or your entry will be invalid) To be eligible please leave a comment regarding what you enjoyed about Ida’s review of Commodity Fragrances Book. Do you have a Commodity Fragrances favorite? Draw closes 10/23/2020

Here is our Privacy and Draw Rules Policy.

Available only on Commodityfragrances.com here

Follow us @cafleurebon @ idameister @commodity @official_europerfumes

Composed in 2013 by perfumer Ketrin Leka

We announce the winners only on our site and on our Facebook page, so like CaFleureBon and use our blog feed…or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


47 comments

  • I enjoyed the specificity of the notes in the fragrances, very often aroma chemicals give a muddled generic impression of woods but I’m very curious to smell the nuances of Alaskan cedar and how it complements the other components in the composition. I do not own any commodity fragrances. Michigan, USA

  • How can I ever stop wanting to try fragrances about books consisting of different species of trees? I missed the chance seeing this house in Sephora. I regret not exploring more often. Maybe this could be the first from Commodity that I experience. (USA)

  • I love the smell of books but Commodity Book sounds more interesting especially the notes. I am really glad commodity is back and I was a big fan of Orris

  • isaaclopedia says:

    I looooove Commodity, I used to get samples of their fragrances from Sephora all the time. I was so glad to hear they had come back. I’m a big fan of Book, Moss and Wool. I love how Ida describes each note and she’s dead on. I also appreciate that she points out the fragrance doesn’t smell LIKE a book, rather it smells like the perfect place to go by yourself and escape into a new story. Snaps for this review.

    California, USA

  • BostonScentGuy says:

    I loved how Ida described this without mentioning “Santal 33.” It’s hard for me to smell this without immediately thinking of it, and now that Ida described the nuances of this, it’s helping me see the differences between the Le Labo and this (affordable!) scent. I enjoy Commodity’s “Whiskey,” an ever so slightly smoky but friendly evening “dumb reach” scent. Thanks for the draw! I’m in the US.

  • I really enjoyed the idea that every book consists of different trees which has different scents and this perfume attempts to capture that woody smell which I believe to be quite unique. Unfortunately I do not have a favorite Commodity Fragrances fragrance because I have never tried one before so I am hoping that this can be my first. Reading out of Florida, USA.

  • Loved Gina’s paintings in Ida Meister’s review. Like many bibliophiles, I understand the problem of sorting through and the pain of parting with one’s beloved books. The Book seems to be an intriguing perfume, but if it can make me forget myself in one of my beloved tomes, especially in these distracting times, I am all for it. Thanks Ida for the review and the generous draw. Writing from the USA.

  • I missed Commodity and glad to see the fragrance line is being reintroduced thanks to Europerfumes. Ida’s description of Book as wood pulp rather than library scent is spot on. There’s definitely a healthy amount of wood notes in addition to the cooling eucalyptus and bergamot. I have gin, tonka and leather Commodity rollerballs. Commenting from MD, USA.

  • ThatMulattoDude says:

    Appreciate Ida’s review and generosity for the giveaway opportunity. I’ve really been intrigued about Commodity Fragrances. I concur with Ida’s love of books and how they can enrich our mind and soul…serving as ways to have conversations with sages long past. Best from Virginia, USA.

  • Thanks Ms Ida for another great article. I’m interested in Book because it sounds unique and unisex. The drydown description of “a pile of drying multi-hued leaves” caught my attention straightaway. Mich USA

  • statikstepz says:

    I live in the USA in Florida! What I enjoyed most about this review is the breakdown of what the name of this fragrance really implies… that it is not the smell of say the New York Public Library, or doesn’t bring images of a Hemingway novel… but instead, it is a conceptual fragrance, referring to the fresh wood pulp. So far my favorite Commodity fragrance is Wool, which I own, but I have yet to smell Book, and have been very interested in it as my second commodity fragrance… I have yet to smell it, but from what I have read, all the notes and makeup of this fragrance highly appeals to me and I already know that I would love it!! I love woods mixed with rose, as well as amber and milk that tie it together, and a little bit of citrus to give it that fresh little pop in the opening! Anyway, thanks again for another great review, and I hope I win this one, as it is definitely the one that excites me the most now!

  • I have to try this fragrance!I always loved it’s notes and I was planing to get a sample of it but never got to do it. I love the note breakdown and description by Ida. Just another reminder that I will probably love this fragrance once I finally try it. I’m from Illinois, US.

  • Haven’t tried anything from Commodity Fragrances yet. But it really intrigues me when Ida described it as fresh wood pulp rather than a library.

    Florida, USA

  • impromptu1992 says:

    Autumnal, you say? Count me in. Rosewood is one of my favorites, too. Such waxing poetics. I love Ida’s writing.
    From Texas with love
    Xoxo

  • Such a colorful way of describing the note break down by Ida. Commodity was the house that started my perfume collecting journey. I discovered this house like many others, in Sephora and have collected 90% of the collection thanks to TJMaxx. I really like Book, as many have mentioned it is similar to Santal 33. Book is my last bottle to complete my collection of this house so I would love to have a chance to win this.

  • Shamrock1313 says:

    Oh my, Book sounds just perfect for the Fall. I like every note in it.
    I enjoy Tonka and Nectar very much.
    Pennsylvania USA

  • Honeydew Crenshaw says:

    US reader

    “autumnal contemplation” – not quite cool enough in the south for much autumnal anything, but this shall pass

    I did enjoy the idea of reading books in an autumn forest setting, though – especially with fragrant evergreen woodsy vibes

  • I enjoyed how Ida explained the scent of Alaskan Cypress, amyris, and the velvet accord. I didn’t know what they smelled like before. Only having smelled 2 perfumes with amyris both of which I enjoyed but now I understand why a bit more. I also liked that she explained how what this perfume was to her is different than the brands written copy, which I tend to agree with often times as well. Ive not tried any Commodity fragrances yet though a number interest me Book being one, Tonka another as well as numerous others. Im in CT USA, thanks for the generous draw.

  • I dont have a favorite Commodity fragrance yet. Ida’s description of Commodity Frangrances Book as a perfume that is about the concept of a book was interesting. These notes sound excellent : Notes: Virginia cedarwood, bois de rose, eucalyptus, bergamot, Alaskan cypress, amyris, amber, musk, sandalwood, velvet

    I live in the USA. Thanks for the draw.

  • I’ve spent much of my life in the Pacific Northwest, and had never heard of the nootka tree until Ida’s charming review! Which led me down a rabbit hole of coniferous curiosity. I also really enjoyed the artwork ‘The Book Garden’, and the how it is described in writing. I missed the opossum on the first look and had to look again. Thank you for the draw. (USA)

  • Bryant Worley says:

    What I appreciated was the way she really broke down the notes,, and showed how the notes and accords would produce a fragrance which made us think of the leathery spine of a book,, or perhaps the glue that binds the pages,, or the pages themselves,, pressed from the many varieties of woods listed.

    After reading this spine, it is to my dismay that I have not sampled a Commodity. But,, according to the notes,, these are the ones I’d like to sample: Wool, Gold, Bergamot, Moss, Gin, Nectar, Mimosa, Vetiver, and Orris.

    I live in Waldorf, MD, USA.

  • Bryant Worley says:

    What I appreciated was the way she really broke down the notes,, and showed how the notes and accords would produce a fragrance which made us think of the leathery spine of a book,, or perhaps the glue that binds the pages,, or the pages themselves,, pressed from the many varieties of woods listed.

    After reading this review, it is to my dismay that I have not sampled a Commodity. But,, according to the notes,, these are the ones I’d like to sample: Wool, Gold, Bergamot, Moss, Gin, Nectar, Mimosa, Vetiver, and Orris.

    I live in Waldorf, MD, USA.

  • Mary Stephens Mitchell says:

    It sounds utterly enchanting and “me”. Thank you for the marvelous review, Ida!

  • Thanks for another great review, Ida! I couldn’t quite imagine how a perfume would smell like a book so I appreciate your amazing review. This is what I liked most – ‘For me, it is a conceptual fragrance – one which refers to fresh wood pulp, sylvan settings rather than a library. I find it to be a perfect scent commensurate with autumnal contemplation..’ Thanks for this opportunity. I – CA, USA

  • All the woods! Ida describes this beautifully. It DOES sound perfect for autumnal reflection. I have not tried any Commodity Fragrances. and I am in the US.

  • I adore Commodity Fragrances and I am so happy Vicken bought the company after they went out of business. Book is my all time favorite of the whole line. I just love the cedarwood and sandalwood notes that are most prominent on my skin. It is such a comforting scent. I would love to win a full bottle.

    I live in the USA.

  • patrick_348 says:

    I don’t know any Commodity fragrances, but I loved the way Ida connected the fragrance to the “Book Garden” painting, which seemed to embody exactly the mood and ethos that she was trying to evoke. Her going into detail about the specific wood notes was informative and enticing. I am in the US, in NC.

  • vickalicious says:

    I’m so glad that Commodity fragrances are back! I’ve only ever tried Bergamot, and love that one. Book sounds like a very nice fragrance. I enjoyed how Ida described it in relation to Autumn. I also LOVE the art work that was included with this post! Located in the US.

  • Ida’s reviews are always sublime. I really like the notes in this fragrance I’s really like to try it. I too, am a bibliophile, so this review resonates even more. May thanks to Ida for a lovely review and many thanks to Europerfumes for making this draw possible. I’m in the US

  • Like Ida, one of my favorite notes is rosewood, and here it sounds positively heavenly. Combined with Virginian cedar and Alaskan cypress (there’s a geographical thing going on here), this is clearly a bois-centric fragrance, reflecting what Ida termed as “sylvan settings”. My favorite Community scent is “Vetiver” and I’m based in the US.

  • Like Ida, I love books, libraries, bookshops (especially antique bookshops). My favourite part of my Medieval History degree was going to the British libraries manuscript room to do palaeography. I have never tried a Commodity Fragrance and I liked that Ida describes the background of the House. I wish that this was still available at Sephora, because I would love to try this. (NYC)

  • Wooden cabin , reading books, getting up late and drinking black tea with slice of grapefruit. I so need long vacation, doing things I enjoy when I rest . Ida review was so realistic , I almost felt I’m in the cabin
    Thanks
    USA

  • Thanks Ida, for this beautiful review!
    So many my favorite ingredient in this perfume _ rosewood, cypress and sandalwood !! and with Cashmeran and Iso E Super – this perfume sounds fresh and beautiful woody fragrance.
    USA

  • Thank you Ida for the wonderful review of Book, the fragrance. I loved the way the photos of people reading is woven into the beautiful words about your life and the great ingredients of Book. The woods and musk sound amazing. I have Commodity Tonka. California

  • Michael Prince says:

    Ida, great review of Commodity Fragrances Book. I am glad that Commodity line was able to stay open and continue providing unique offerings that showcase one specific note or accord in this case book. A green eucalyptus note along with various woody notes along the lines of a woody pulp, and a balsamic sweet amber vibe in the base sounds perfect for the fall. I would love to try Commodity Book. My favorote commodity fragrance is Tonka. I am from Ohio, USA.

  • wallygator88 says:

    Thank you for the great review Ida.

    I like how you mention that this fragrance does not necessary remind you of books/paper but rather everything adjacent to it.

    Your writeup makes me remember the times I’ve sat in a park or forest in the shade of a tree with a book.

    I would be very excited to try this scent out.

    My favourtie Commodity fragrance is Orris

    Cheers from WI, USA

  • theronmwilliams says:

    I love how Ida was able to explain the role each wood played in this fragrance. The mention of rosewood and the short side note of West Indian Sandal wood was also insightful. Book is my favorite commodity fragrance was able to get a sample from Sephora before they left shelves, received major compliments but couldn’t find this fragrance again.

  • IvanVelikov says:

    Pungent grapefruit, cedar, cypress is a classic combination. I’m in tailoring business, and such fragrance i could easily wear while working with clients.
    I have not smelled Commodity Fragrances before.
    Thanks
    USA

  • I am obsessed with these paintings! I am not familiar with this particular Commodity scent, although I have liked several from the brand. Books have been such a huge part of my life’s enjoyment, I am interested in this interpretation. Thanks for a lovely review. USA

  • I rarely wear suits, but Book to me is well suited for formal occasions. Balsamic notes and citruses i presume will make it more lively.
    Appreciate the review, and the giveaway campaign
    USA

  • Ida very well described Book , I have nothing more to say. Usually we’re not on the same page , different perception and taste i guess, but not this time.
    “you can continue to enjoy any favorites you may already have, or explore them if you haven’t yet done so.”
    Well … NO , not exactly. Some were discontinued , including Whiskey, to me , by very far the best Commodity fragrance. I sincerely don’t get why Europerfumes decided to not bring it back , I can only hope they will in the future.
    I already follow @cafleurebon @ idameister @commodity and @official_europerfumes
    Thanks
    USA

  • m.r.everything says:

    Another beautiful review from Ida. She makes everything sounds o beautiful and worth trying. Book is such a fantastic fragrance… so much so that I have 2 bottles of it in my collection. It is definitely reminiscent of Santal 33 by Le Labo, another one I own and absolutely adore! I am really glad to see that Eden Square/Europerfumes acquired Commodity Fragrances as it is such a lovely brand. I have 2 bottles of Whiskey, a bottle of Oak, 2 bottles of Book, a bottle of Mimosa, and a bottle of Gold, so I am definitely glad to see the brand live on! Please do NOT enter me in the draw as I already own this one and would love for someone else to get their nose on this beauty! I just had to comment on Ida’s wonderful words and this fantastic brand! Thank you Ida, for bringing us your take on Book. Thank you Europerfumes/Eden Square for your generosity and for giving everyone this opportunity! Thank you Michelyn, for everything you do and for bringing us this content! Sending warm wishes from Delaware, US. Good luck all and stay safe friends!

  • There’s time and place for fragrances like Book. Not every fragrance should be overwhelmingly strong . Casual scent for a chilly autumn days, meet up with friends at the coffee shop.
    Thanks Ida , USA
    Regards

  • “It’s a way of maintaining artistic integrity as well as the brand’s reputation; while they are no longer on Sephora’s shelves”

    Absolutely
    Personally i can’t take seriously a niche brands selling at Sephora , it doesn’t feel right.
    Cedar with bergamot, Iso E Super and soma balsamic elements, fragrance for confident people.
    Thanks for the giveaway
    USA

  • Love Ida’s poetic brilliant writing, her story always intriguing and interesting and this one also special it’s about literature, books and fragragrance with specific name “Book” Ida say:”Artist friend Gina Litherland depicts the mood precisely in her oil painting Book Garden: I want to be that faunal creature conversing with my fox in the forest, where books bloom atop hardy stalks surrounded by an aromatic carpet of autumn leaves – festooned with a foliage crown and an opossum for additional company.” So lovely!
    Commodity Fragrances Book
    Notes: Virginia cedarwood, bois de rose, eucalyptus, bergamot, Alaskan cypress, amyris, amber, musk, sandalwood, velvet.
    Very special!!! Commenting from Florida USA

  • I rather liked Book when it first came out, though I have to agree with Ida, that painting matches the fragrance very well! I own Tonka but also enjoy Gold as well. I live in the USA. Thanks for the giveaway!

  • Book i known well , because it’s one of my fathers favorite fragrances. I don’t smell any sweetness in it . It could be because of my father is wearing it , but i think about well groomed late 40’s and above guys with an old book in their hands.
    If i happens to be the winner, I’ll give my dad the bottle for his birthday early
    December .
    Thank you
    USA