ÇaFleureBon Modern Masterpieces: Parfum d’Empire Musc Tonkin (Marc-Antoine Corticchiato) 2012 + La petite Tonkinois Draw

 

Parfum d'Empire Musk Tonkin extrait de parfum

Parfum d’Empire Musc Tonkin extrait de parfum ©Parfum d’Empire

“Je l′appelle ma p’tite bourgeoise

“I call her my little bourgeois
Ma Tonkiki, ma Tonkiki, ma Tonkinoise

My Tonkiki, my Tonkiki, my Tonkinoise
Y en a d’autres qui m′font les doux yeux

There are others making goo-goo eyes at me
Mais c′est elle que j’aime le mieux

But it’s she I love better”-Writer(s): Christine Henri, Villard Georges

Zia Graziella, a friend and a former Soubrette who drove the audience of Operetta theaters crazy for more than 40 years introduced me to this French tune of yore.  Her French maman used to sing it to her as a lullaby, she told me with shining eyes. The song was sung also by Maurice Chevalier and Josephine Baker, who made it an international hit. All the times this jingle rolls in my head in Graziella’s charming voice, it is a sweet reminder of how music and perfumery have so much in common. Actually, more than one could think, as they sometimes share a common history. That’s the case with this debut du siècle melody and musk Tonkin, a mythical raw material I was lucky to smell long time ago in the early days of my fragrant training. Its intoxicating smell all about sinful tenderness is bound in my memory to Auntie Graziella and “La petite Tonkinoise”.

Parfum d'Empire Musc Tonkin

Tonkin – L’Indochine Française, 1931by illustrator Joseph-Henri Ponchin (1897-1962)

Nowadays you can find plenty of information on the web about this traditional ingredient in ancient perfumery, spanning from sources like Marco Polo “The Million” to classic perfumery manuals that used it for its fixative power and it purported properties as an aphrodisiac. It is less talked how musk from Tonkin (the current Vietnam)  became a signature ingredient in French Perfumery after the Sino-French war (1883-1885) that gained France the Tonkin protectorate (1886-1945), meaning profitable imports of the finest tea, opium and musk as well. Travels by sea to those faraway lands also inspired music and arts, along with perfumery.

vintage perfumes that use Musk Tonkin

Coco Chanel et La Marquise de la Flaconnerie, 1923 by SEM (1863-1934)

 During the same time period, the discovery of aliphatic aldehydes led to what I consider the most exquisite musk pairing of the XX century: aldehydic musky florals. The suggestion of a heated feminine body still smelling of the finest floral soap made socially acceptable fragrant eroticism, yet teasing the dirtiest, forbidden bourgeois fantasies. My beloved Chanel No. 5 eau de cologne is probably the most famous and abstract example of this mix of soapy floralcy and troubling intimacy. Musky florals were still en vogue in the late 1950s, as also confirmed by a 1961 Firmenich interpretation of the Chanel No. 5 theme (via the knowledgeable Octavian Coifan) featuring 15/1000 of natural musk Tonkin tincture (quite a significant amount). Originally coming from the musk deer perineal glands, it was then banned in 1979, and animal cruelty concerns have prevented it from being used. Fortunately.

 The Tibetan musk, Edinburgh 1866 by Sir William Jardine (1800-1874) 

Back in 2012 Parfum d’Empire Musc Tonkin extrait de parfum not only wanted to play homage to the eponymous raw material, but also succeeded in bringing us to a fantasy boat trip to the mysterious Vietnam, discovering beauty, and love. Perfumer Marc-Antoine Corticchiato ethically sublimates the magic of moschus moschiferus secretions backing the notorious skunk side of musk with the original cleanness of a sparkling marine bouquet. Parfum d’Empire Musk Tonkin is the ultimate redefinition of musk in perfumery, resulting in an unprecedented, unique fragrance worthy of entering the CaFleureBon Modern Masterpiece Hall of fame.

Musk deer is not really a deer

Parfum d’Empire Musc Tonkin Extrait de Parfum (2012) and Parfum d’Empire Musk Tonkin edp (2014) ©Emmanuelle Varron

Initially released as a 1000 bottles limited edition extrait de parfum almost 10 years ago (read the original review by Mark Behnke here), Musc Tonkin was later released in 2014 as a less challenging eau de parfum. It later returned to its extrait de parfum concentration, as uncompromising as ever.

Parfum d’Empire Musc Tonkin opens with the most memorable erotic funk of the past several decades, but it’s far from being a mere muscular exercise on animalcy. Its roaring warmth is interwoven with heady white flowers, possibly tuberose and ylang-ylang along with a luscious confectionery of honeyed rose and osmanthus absolute that melts on skin like a sumptuous liqueur. What makes Musc Tonkin really break through is the sparkle of orange blossom boosted by a genius marine note bridging the urinous mineralcy of African stone. The endless salty skin base accord softens in the hay-like hues of coumarin and patchouli, hinting in my mind to the languorous opium smokers of French Indochina.

This miraculous balance of immaculate and dirty is the very soul of the XX century French perfumery featuring the (back then) widely available musk Tonkin and the key ingredient. As many perfume reviews on the web point out,  that there is common ground with classics like Guerlain Mitsouko, Femme de Rochas,1000 de Jean Patou and many others is no surprise. The vintage vibe is a happy result in this case, not a goal.

Woman Smoking Opium, Hanoi, French Indocina c.a. 1915 by Léon Busy

Of course, vintage perfume lovers have been unknowingly exposed to musk Tonkin, so its smell is an acquired taste as previously explained. Nowadays though, very few people had the chance to smell it, so I was happy that perfumer Marc-Antoine Corticchiato answered my questions about this legendary raw material.

Marc-Antoine Corticchiato of Parfum d’Empire

 Marc-Antoine Corticchiato, image ©Parfum d’Empire

Ermano Picco: What is your relationship with musk in perfumes in general and with your perfumes in particular?

 Marc-Antoine Corticchiato: First I shall mention that real musk, the only natural musk, namely musk Tonkin  has been banned for a very longtime It’s an incredible raw material I had the chance to smell thanks to an old friend who is also a  perfumer. Nowadays we don’t realize that it  was used in many iconic perfumes since the beginning of the XX century. It’s a raw material that’s part of our olfactory heritage. It is so rich, dense, powerful, deep, sensual, animalic, unique!  It has nothing to do with modern musks. About synthetic musks, today there’s a wide palette available to perfumers. Every molecule has its specific technical features. Some give a “clean” impression, especially because they have been implied in huge amounts in detergents and fabric softeners since longtime. I confess they aren’t my favorite musks, even if some of them are technically interesting for their cloudy aspects.

I prefer more sensual musks, like musk ketone, muscenone, cosmone, or again muscone which incidentally naturally occurs in musk Tonkin. They are the warmest musks, the closest ones to the smell of skin. They are the most expensive as well, unfortunately.

African Stone is called Hyraceum

African Stone aka Hyraceum @Ermano

EP: How did you compose Musc Tonkin to make it such a sensual, animalic perfume?

MAC: After smelling on several occasions musk Tonkin and having understood its impact on the great perfumery, I made a great consideration. This musk Tonkin, so mythical and mysterious is the ghost of perfumery: it disappeared but it never stopped haunting the imagination of perfumers. I wanted to retrieve this very animalic, erotic indefinable aura. As natural musk Tonkin is forbidden since the 1970s for animal cruelty concerns, I tried to find animality in a differently. First with muscone, the molecule naturally occurring in musk extraction, but also with some flower absolutes I chose that, balanced in a certain way, offer a palette of animal notes (osmanthus, tuberose, rose, jasmine, narcissus). Lastly, I worked with a very rare natural raw material, African stone that can be found in Eastern Africa. It is an extraordinary product also knows as golden stone or hyraceum. Those stones are actually fossils resulting from a symbiosis between the environment (vegetal and mineral exudates) and hyrax scraps and need hundreds of years to be formed. The extraction from these stones is rarely used in perfumery. It is a very animalic mineral raw material with a mysterious smell that’s also totally ethical as it doesn’t endanger the specie.

EP: How it is possible nowadays for perfumers to work with musks and still comply with more and more strict regulations?

MAC: As I  mentioned, many so-called musky molecules are available in the perfumer’s palette. Some are increasingly monitored for biodegradability and tend to be used less (these are polycyclic musks, such as galaxolide or tonalide). But macrocyclic musks degrade very well and have very different facets: we find muscenone, but also woodier habanolide, fairly neutral T musk, more earthy exaltolide…. Alicyclics degrade easily too, I particularly like helvetolide in this family, a bright and rising musk. To work with musk from an animal point of view (as was the original musk, tonkin musk), we have witnessed a shift in recent years: the animal notes are now transferred to the vegetal. This animality can indeed be found in certain flower absolutes. There are also extracts of cistus which can be very sensual. It is a plant which touches me a lot and which has always been very present in my life since it is a major component of the perfume of the Corsican maquis (with the immortelle). There are also spices, such as cumin, or pyrogenic extracts of plants such as cade, birch or styrax. And also this oud wood, some extracts of which can be particularly animalic.”

Musc Tonkin has above average projection and outstanding overnight longevity.

Notes include marine notes, tuberose, ylang-ylang, rose, osmanthus, African stone, musk

The writing is based on a personal sample of Parfum d’Empire Musc Tonkin extrait de parfum, opinions as always my own

Ermano Picco, Editor and Perfume Expert

Parfum d'empire Musc Tonkin

Thanks to the generosity of Marc-Antoine Corticchiato, we have a 50 ml bottle of Parfum d’Empire Musc Tonkin Extrait for one registered reader worldwide. To be eligible please leave a comment with if you have smelled Musc Tonkin , where you live and  what interested you about Ermano’s essay and mini interview. Draw closes 12/8/2021

Editor’s Note: I chose Parfum d’Empire Musc Tonkin for the Jovoy Paris X CaFleurebon box. There are only a few left  so please buy our 14 sample box here. Please read my interview with Marc-Antoine Corticchiato here. Michelyn Camen, Editor-in-Chief who translated M. Cortichiatto’s  third question from French to English, so any error is mine. Also the Musk deer is not really a deer belonging to the family Cervidae but rather their family is closely related to Bovidae, the group that contains antelopes, bovines, sheep and goats according to wikipedia

A Big merci to CaFleureBon Senior Contributor Emmanuelle Varron for photos and assistance.

Please Like our CaFleureBon Modern Masterpieces Page on Facebook here and your comment will count twice. Please say that in your comment

Follow us on Instagram @cafleurebon @magnificent @monbazarunlimited @parfumdempire

PLEASE NOTE OUR INSTAGRAM ACCOUNT is now @cafleurebonofficial

 Follow us on Instagram @cafleurebonofficial @idameister @aftelierperfumes

This is our Privacy and Draw Rules Policy

We announce the winners only on site and on our Facebook page, so Like ÇaFleureBon and use our Blog feed…or your dream prize will be just spilled perfume

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


62 comments

  • Thanks for the article Michelyn!

    My partner and I have had a love for Musk fragrances for many years. We love smelling it on each other and we love reading about new fragrances we can enjoy together.

    As I was reading about Musc Tonkin in the introduction, I wondered how Parfum d’Empire would have been able to create this perfume without a main banned ingredient. I was glad to read ,further on, that Ermano asked all the questions I had and Marc-Antoine’s answers were satisfying and comprehensive.

    We haven’t tried Musc Tonkin yet.
    Greetings from the UK!

  • I have not smelled Musc Tokin but love musk fragrances. I live in VA USA. I liked that the essay referred to how many classic perfumes like Mitsoku originally used musk as an ingredient, which I didn’t realize. I also liked in his interview how he balanced the musk in his fragrance with flowers which I wouldn’t have thought he would do. Thanks for the draw.

  • I have not smelled Musk Tonkin but it is the Parfum D’empire perfume I am definitely most interested in! I was so pleased to read that Marc-Antoinne makes an effort to use more biodegradable musks as that has been a concern of mine. I also dislike clean laundry musks and am much more drawn to warm and animalic scents. I would be so thrilled to have this. Thank you for the generous draw. In Brooklyn, NY

  • I haven’t smelled Musk Tonkin,and in my quest for a peculiar facet of African stone, i very much want to test it.And indeed, Marc-Antoine Corticchiato nailed it, we witnessed a shift of animal notes witch are transferred to the vegetal in the last years.Thanks from Romania with love!

  • As a big fan of Parfum D’Empire and Corticchiato’s artistry, it was a treat that a portion of Ermano’s review included direct Q&A with Marc-Antioine. I also really appreciated learning more about the history around musk, and especially Ermano’s description of the emergence of the aldehydic musky florals as a fragrance family. Powerful and sensual stuff for sure. I live in California, USA.

  • Ermano! ❤️❤️❤️ I Adore your review! It’s so beautifully written & I learn so much! I first experienced Parfum d’Empire Musc Tonkin in the Jovoy Paris X CaFleurebon box and have fallen head over heels in love with this scent! It is on my wish list for Christmas! I LOVE the mineral animality of this scent! It’s just gorgeous! I love the idea that musk Tonkin is the “ghost of perfumery.” That feels instantly true (the grasping memories of grandma’s perfumes and how there’s just something “missing” in modern versions… something so beautiful). This fragrance has given me great elation: one CAN find something like that vintage beauty in today’s world (something that scratches that particular itch). Of course, so many new & brilliant things are being made every day, but when you want that sense memory…. Wow! I LOVE this perfume! Thank you SO much for this opportunity to own a whole bottle! ❤️❤️❤️ USA

  • Really Good Article Michelyn!

    I have not smelled Real musk. May it be Tonkin, Tibetan, Siberian or Himalayan. But yes I have smelled the synthetic musks that are available. The clean ones and the one which are almost identical to original Deer Musk. Just love the funky animalic smell.
    Really like this interview with Marc and got to know more about the musk and how well it can be composed with florals, thank you for this opportunity to win the draw. From India.

  • A very nice piece of history! Thanks for the review!
    I have never tried Musc Tonkin, but I would love to! I have two scents from Parfum d’Empire, Cuir Ottoman and Tabac Tabou.
    I live in Romania, EU.

  • I haven’t smelled Musc Tonkin. I live in Poland, EU. The amazing details interested me in Ermano’s essay and mini interview.

  • emorandeira says:

    One more time a great post! Congratulations!
    About the Ermano’s essay i am interested by the comparation between musk tonkin and the typical perfumes from the XX century, this catch my attention!

    On the interview I like when M. Corticchiato explains about different ways to get the musky vibe with all the restriccions un perfumery and the IFRA norm.

    My name is Edgar (parfum_sindromico), I live in Tenerife (Spain, EU) and, unfortunately, I hace never smelt any Parfums d’Empire fragrance.

    Regards!!

  • I haven`t tried Musc Tonkin, unfortunately. I love the Ermano’s comparison of perfumery and music. There are, indeed, many things in common here. It was also interesting to learn about the history of the origin of such musk and the history of its usage in perfumery. And many thanks to Marc-Antoine Corticchiato for the fact that despite the ban on this perfume ingredient, he tried to recreate its real scent. I also learned about the African Stone aka Hyraceum for the first time. It is very good that the perfumer cares about the ethical aspects of perfume production, I agree that many animalic facets of musks can now be excellently replaced with plant components, so Costus and Cyperus smell for me with completely sensual animal motifs. I read this interview and essay with interest, thanks for the informativeness.
    UK

  • Beautiful article! I consider myself a musk lover, but mostly when it is modern and synthetic musks. I would love to try Musc Tonkin to broaden my point of view on this note and educate myself. So no, I never tried this one, unfortunately.
    I live in the EU.

  • This review reminds me how one can experience lot of surprises by smelling vintage perfumes that had materials now banned. Moreover, the vintage ingredients like musk may have been banned but they continue to haunt the memories of perfumers who are inspired to use modern materials to recreate their impression. I am in US.

  • It later returned to its extrait de parfum concentration, as uncompromising as ever.

    Parfum d’Empire Musc Tonkin opens with the most memorable erotic funk of the past several decades, but it’s far from being a mere muscular exercise on animalcy. Its roaring warmth is interwoven with heady white flowers, possibly tuberose and ylang-ylang along with a luscious confectionery of honeyed rose and osmanthus absolute that melts on skin like a sumptuous liqueur. What makes Musc Tonkin really break through is the sparkle of orange blossom boosted by a genius marine note bridging the urinous mineralcy of African stone. The endless salty skin base accord softens in the hay-like hues of coumarin and patchouli, hinting in my mind to the languorous opium smokers of French Indochina.
    This miraculous balance of immaculate and dirty is the very soul of the XX century French perfumery featuring the (back then) widely available musk Tonkin and the key ingredient. As many perfume reviews on the web point out, that there is common ground with classics like Guerlain Mitsouko, Femme de Rochas,1000 de Jean Patou and many others is no surprise. The vintage vibe is a happy result in this case, not a goal. I am afraid I have not tried Musc Tonkin but I am intrigued by the notes and the perfumer. I have liked CaFleureBon modern masterpieces page. Thanks a million from the United Kingdom

  • I have not tried musc to tonkin but an engaging read with the perfumer about musks in perfumery. I am intrigued by the notes including marine notes, tuberose, ylang-ylang, rose, osmanthus, African stone, musk. Thanks a lot from the UK

  • I have not smelled Musc Toskin yet, but after this review would love to. I love the idea of an animalic sensual perfume, and this one really got my attention. Loved this description: Parfum d’Empire Musk Tonkin is the ultimate redefinition of musk in perfumery. At least i gotta try it. Also loved the introduction and the history that it shares with the music. I am in the U.S.

  • Love musk and don’t see it often with marine notes, that’s sounds inviting to me. Like Mr. Corticchiato I prefer the sensual musks also, figured they’d be the most expensive. Enjoyed much the musk history. US

  • Haven’t tried it, but I find it interesting that it’s actually banned? I wouldn’t have known that if I hadn’t read this interview. I’m from EU. ❤️

  • Ermano’s questions were insightful and Marc-Antoine’s discussion about how be created animality for this perfume is fascinating, as is the overall history of musc in perfume and his use of African stone. I have smelled and loved Musc Tonkin thanks to the Jovoy Paris X CaFleurebon box (which is excellent for anyone still on the fence). I’d adore winning this draw! In NC USA.

  • I didn’t try anything from Perfum d’Empire yet, but I would love to. Also, this interview makes me want to buy a book about history of fragrances. Really inspiring! I live in France

  • I haven’t smelled Musc Tonkin but am very interested. I own Osmanthus Interdite by Parfum d’Empire and it is one of my all-time favorite perfumes. What surprised me most about this information-packed article was Marc-Antoine Corticchiato’s description of using florals to create animalic notes, especially with rose and osmanthus. Skill and artistry! MA, USA

  • I haven’t smelled Musc Tonkin, neither the raw material nor the perfume. The essay describes the perfume very well : honey rose, hyrax, ornge and a bit of sal sound on a dirty musc base sound wonderful. And the interview with M. Corticchiato sheds some light on how contemporary perfumery works.

  • I haven’t tried Musk Tonkin, but I have tried most of the line before the switch to the new bottle format was made, and out of those, I have to say that my favourite was Cuir Ottoman with Wazamba being a close runner.
    This combination of intoxicating flowers with musk sounds really intriguing to me, and I would love to give Musk Tonkin a try.
    I am in Europe. Thank you!

  • Sorohan Adriana says:

    I have not smelled Musc Tokin but love musk fragrances with flowers and I am curious how is this parfume.
    Iam from EU Bucharest Romania Europe

  • I am familiar with African stone through Zoologist Hyrax. Never would I have thought that a marine accord would go with it. And the addition of the floral bouquet sounds beautiful. I love the vintage sensuality. I learned a lot from the interview with Corticchiato and his analysis of animalic notes.
    I live in Denmark, EU.

  • I really enjoyed this article. I have never semelled Musc Tonkin, but I really want to.
    Hope I win. Thanks for the opportunity.
    Regards from Mexico!

  • What I like about CaFleureBon reviews is that I learn something new every time! I’ve never heard of musk Tonkin before. I love animalistic perfumes, but I do love animals even more, it’s great to know that perfumers find cruelty-free ways to give us a chance to discover what legendary raw materials smell like.

    Same as Ermano, I love Chanel No. 5 eau de cologne very much, but I couldn’t point out what makes it seem like a distant member of No.5 family: apparently, it’s the musky facets that give it a whole new vibe.

    Parfum d’Empire Musc Tonkin appears to have it all (I haven’t smelled it, but boy, do I want to): luscious white florals, a salty accord, and a vintage feel. Color me excited!

    Thank you for the draw! Liked and subscribed a long time ago. I’m from Russia

  • I have smelled Musc Tonkin and adore it. I ordered the Musc CaFleureBon box from Jovoy! It was my favorite. I love this response from Mac “After smelling on several occasions musk Tonkin and having understood its impact on the great perfumery, I made a great consideration. This musk Tonkin, so mythical and mysterious is the ghost of perfumery: it disappeared but it never stopped haunting the imagination of perfumers. I wanted to retrieve this very animalic, erotic indefinable aura. As natural musk Tonkin is forbidden since the 1970s for animal cruelty concerns, I tried to find animality in a differently. ” I live in the US.

  • I have not tried Musc Tonkin yet but I do love musk fragrances. I gravitate towards the more animalistic musk found in perfumes like Narciso Rodriguez for Her. It’s interesting how modern perfumers are able to get around the stricter regulations. I’m in MD, USA.

  • What an intriguing fragrance! I have not had the chance to smell Musc Tonkin. I was aware that true musk cannot be harvested any longer, and had discerned that it must be chemically synthesized for its use in fragrance. I had no idea about the huge range of musk molecules, each of which has its own unique scent and traits. It’s interesting to think about how some synthetic musks, such as muscone and musk ketone are still more expensive than cheaper alternatives. What an intriguing history and essay! From NC, USA.

  • I have not smelled Musc Tonkin but it’s been on my list for a long while. I’m especially intrigued by the African stone, a material I’ve smelled elsewhere and am captivated by. I live in Chicago.

  • I have actually smelled the Eau de Parfum concentration of Musc Tonkin and I loved it, but reading all the reviews of the Extrait concentration, it seems right up my alley – dark, animalic, uncompromising.

    I truly do believe that Mr. Corticchiato, along with Sorcinelli, is one of the most exciting perfumers in the perfume world. As I said, I smelled the EDP concentration, but I would love, LOVE to be able to win this bottle of the extrait!

    As for Ermano’s essay/review, I think it was wonderfully written, full of life, details and with a great sense of perfume history! I especially loved the beginning – a short poem from Christine Henri and Villard Georges which evokes the feeling of this perfume EXCEPTIONALLY WELL! I also loved a short history lesson about musk in perfumery, especially how it shaped classic french perfumery!

    I loved Mr. Corticchiato short interview because it is rare to read something from a perfumers perspective! I love reading the editor on Cafleurebon, but it’s always a special treat to read something from a perfumer! I especially loved his retelling of his inspirations for the perfume as well as the process of making this perfume! Great read altogether!

    I live in Croatia, EU.

  • Great article that helped us understand a bit how the we can recreate nowadays the ancient smells. I have never tried Musc Tonkin, but musk is my favorite perfume ingredient, so I would definitely like to try this one as it seems like a reference in the genre.
    Thank you for the generous give away, from Romania.

  • scentrified says:

    This is such a classy brand. I haven’t tried Musc Tonkin specifically, but several others. I really like what I’ve sniffed so far, but don’t own any bottles (yet).

    Super interesting to read about the African golden stone! Love how mythical and rare it is. I also find it so curious how musk is often seen as an erotic or sensual note, seeing as where it originally came from. Overall great interview and essay by Ermano.

    I’m in Lisbon, Portugal.

    @scentrified on IG

  • This does it for me: The vintage vibe is a happy result in this case, not a goal.
    I am in Europe. Thank you!

  • Such great knowledge of musks and especially the ones used in the past. I really appreciated Mr Cortichiatto explaining how he smelled the real one and looked to make something similar
    Big fan of the house and Ambre Russe I am wearing all winter. I did not know that musk Tonkin wasn’t a deer so I learned that too
    EU

  • I liked most of this review, the next paragraph: ‘Parfum d’Empire Musc Tonkin opens with the most memorable erotic funk of the past several decades, but it’s far from being a mere muscular exercise on animalcy. Its roaring warmth is interwoven with heady white flowers, possibly tuberose and ylang-ylang along with a luscious confectionery of honeyed rose and osmanthus absolute that melts on skin like a sumptuous liqueur. What makes Musc Tonkin really break through is the sparkle of orange blossom boosted by a genius marine note bridging the urinous mineralcy of African stone. The endless salty skin base accord softens in the hay-like hues of coumarin and patchouli, hinting in my mind to the languorous opium smokers of French Indochina.’
    I am not familiar with this house at all, so this is a great chance to test one of their finest! Many thanks!

  • I didn’t know all this history behind musk Tonkin, so it was a pleasire to read this article. Haven’t tried it yet… I’m from the city Zapresic in EU.

  • I have not smelled Musc Tonkin, however I have heard so many great things about it! I quite enjoy musky fragrances, so I found this review quite informative! Hyraceum is such an interesting ingredient. Thank you from Canada!

  • Fragrance Capital says:

    Thanks, Ermano for this wonderful article. You took me to this majestic world of Musk, I really enjoyed reading your mini-meeting with MAC. It is the first time to know about African Stone and how it is used in perfumery. I liked the idea and looking forward to smelling the extraction from these stones in Musc Tonkin. Actually, I’ve never smelled any real Musk before. Greetings from Sarajevo, Bosnia.

  • Thanks for the article Michelyn! Very interesting !!
    I haven’t smelled Musk Tonkin,and would like test it peculiar African stone.
    I am sure I will like this perfume , because I am fan of Marc-Antoine Corticchiato perfumes (Tabac Tabou is masterpiece) – tried some – very unique style and second- I love musc.
    I am from Armenia

  • I seem to enjoy musc scents but could not really describe them if I needed to. This sounds like a lovely scent and one I could enjoy. In maryland.

  • Thank you for an awesome review Ermano! I haven`t tried Musc Tonkin, unfortunately nor anything from Perfum d’Empire yet but I would love to explore this brand! What an interesting combination of notes : musk, marine notes and African stone!! Sounds so intriguing!! Thank you. Dubai, UAE

  • sephrenia300 says:

    Lovely article and interview! I have not yet smelled Musc Tonkin, although I have sampled many Pafums D’empire fragrances, and am particularly enamoured of the stunning Cuir Ottoman and Odalisque. I live in the US.

    What interested me about Ermano’s essay and mini interview is his description of Musc Tonkin as the most remarkable balance of dirty and clean, of raunchy and delicate, of naughty and nice. That is my favorite type of fragrance! I can’t wait to try it.

  • macaroni023 says:

    What a great read!!! I loved learning about the origin of Tonkin and Ermano Picco thoughts about ingredients and the creation process. Very interesting information indeed!!! Also special thanks to Michelyn Camenfor for a great selection of illustrations. I have never tried any of Parfum d’Empire fragrances but if I ever get the chance the Musc Tonkin is first on my list. It looks like such an animatic sensual fragrance!’

  • Thanks Ermano (and Michelyn and Emmanuelle) for the lesson on musks, the old and forbidden ones and all the palette the perfumers have available now, of course thanks to Marc-Antoine for the elaborate answers! I have not smelled Musk Tonkin but I love M. Cortichiatto’s Parfum D’empire perfumes, above all the Corsican collection. I like musks, but as M.Cortichiatto says, I prefer the sensual, animalic musks, the warmest ones (not the clean and laundry ones), and as he says “.. the closest ones to the smell of skin”. I was amazed with the use of African Stone and the possibilities of using new natural raw materials! . I live in Spain, EU.

  • Lastly, I worked with a very rare natural raw material, African stone that can be found in Eastern Africa. It is an extraordinary product also knows as golden stone or hyraceum. Those stones are actually fossils resulting from a symbiosis between the environment (vegetal and mineral exudates) and hyrax scraps and need hundreds of years to be formed.

    I am curious about this African stone, as I never heard of it. Thank you! Europe

  • I have not smelled Musc Tokin but I have liked and own other Parfum d’Empire fragrances. I was pleased to learn about the history using musk in perfumery. Also using biodegradable musk is an interesting fact. I live in Finland, I also follow and like the Facebook page.

  • It was interesting to read how the effect of musk can be achieved now that it is forbidden, with other notes and elements that could mimic a similar animalic essence.
    I have never smelled Musc Tonkin but would love to.
    I live in Denmark.

  • It’s quite a history and chemistry lesson. Short lesson 🙂
    Very interesting to read about the history of musc tonkin, the material and the perfume and I’m utterly impressed by the way talented perfumers find a way to give back to us the forbidden treasures of the past.
    Never tried Musc Tonkin, but I’d love to.
    I am living in Europe.

  • Very informative article and interview wih Marc-Antoine Corticchiato… it was interesting to learn of the different synthetic varieties of musk and how the use of florals created a more natural smelling musk, without using any natural animal-derived musks. Not sure if I have smelled Musc Tonkin. Thanks Ermano for the interview and for a generous draw for a 50 ml bottle of Parfum d’Empire Musc Tonkin Extrait. From USA.

  • msnitechemist says:

    A fascinating read. Thank you, Ermano. As they say, when life hands you lemons, make lemonade, and perfumers had to figure out a way around a banned ingredient…and they have, instead of giving up and calling it a day. Marc-Antoine was faced with a challenge and he met it superbly. I love the way he talks about fragrance, equal parts scientist and artist.

    So far I have not enjoyed marine perfumes and I’m guessing this one is going to be too musky for me, so please exclude me from the draw. Good luck to everyone else!

  • Never smelled it before.
    Living in Germany, EU
    I found most interesting the thoughts about scents being part of our heritage!

  • I have never smelled Musc Tonkin and I enjoyed reading Ermano’s essay and interview because it was the first time I had ever heard of Parfum d’Empire as well. I always enjoy reading these essays because they are often my first entry point into exploring other brands and scents, so thank you!
    And thank you for the draw, I am from Canada

  • redwheelbarrow says:

    This was a really interesting read on how musks are now created and replicated. I had never heard of African Stone and headed over to google and was so surprised! This fragrance sounds interesting and special and I would love to experience it. Thank you for the draw. From the US.

  • wallygator88 says:

    Thank you for the wonderful writeup Ermano.

    I really enjoyed reading your interview with Marc-Antoine Corticchiato on all things musk and the creation of Musc Tonkin.

    Also loved the French lullaby in the introduction and the wonderful backstory.

    It’s always fascinating to see a trained hand wield these materials to recreate the olfactive signatures of materials that can no longer be used because of different reasons. Musks in particular can be easily overwhelming and I love that Hyraceum was used along with narcotic florals to do this.

    I’ve unfortunately not smelt Musc Tonkin and would love to.

    Cheers from WI, USA

  • The collected works of Parfum d’Empire has been something which I’ve been wanting to sample for a while now, especially the fragrance “Fougere Bengale”. I still haven’t tried anything from them yet. I found Ermano’s essay, and mini interview, to be informative, and it was a good way for me to become more familiar with a fragrance house whose releases are towards the top of my list of fragrances to try. I’m very interested in trying “Musc Tonkin” for different reasons, e.g. the part of the essay which said “Parfum d’Empire Musk Tonkin is the ultimate redefinition of musk in perfumery, resulting in an unprecedented, unique fragrance worthy of entering the CaFleureBon Modern Masterpiece Hall of fame.” I live in MD., U.S.A. Thanks for the giveaway opportunity.

  • O mon Dieu!, this is such an enchanting subject. I’m in the wilderness right now, feel like I’m reaching back through ancient times… so to think about such an important vintage material seems particularly serendipitous. It’s good to know that there are perfumers who are so excited about this. I have not smelled Musc Tonkin. Following on Facebook as Maren McConnell.
    (USA)

  • Never smelled musc Tonkin… Nice review. Very interesting notes, love learning about the history around musk!! I enjoyed the interview also. USA

    Thanks Cafleurebon for the opportunity good luck everyone!!

  • I have not had a chance to get my nose on this fragrance yet. I learned that African Stone, a rare raw material used provides a raw animalic raw mineral that provides a mysterious scent. I learned a lot from Ermano’s interview. Thank you. I live in the US.

  • I haven’t smelled Musk Tonkin,and in my quest for a peculiar facet of African stone, i very much want to test it.And indeed, Marc-Antoine Corticchiato nailed it, we witnessed a shift of animal notes witch are transferred to the vegetal in the last two years.Thanks from Pakistan Love.