New Niche Fragrance Review Serge Lutens Une Voix Noire + Requiem For A Gardenia Draw

Billie Holliday

Expectations are often maddening, especially when it comes to fragrance. When I hear that there is a new Serge Lutens Fragrance coming that sets my expectations at level one. When I hear it is going to be based on famed, and tragic, jazz singer Billie Holliday I am at level two. When it is based on the gardenia she wore in her hair then my expectations are officially off the charts. When I finally received my decant of the new Serge Lutens Une Voix Noire, it met none of my expectations. Which was disappointing but there was something there and over the next week I came to realize my expectations were unrealistic and the reality was something better than what I expected.

Gardenia has certainly been one of the “it” notes to build a fragrance around in 2012 and I should’ve realized that if Serge Lutens and Christopher Sheldrake were going to follow the crowd they were going to do it in a very Lutensian way. Most of the gardenias released this year have focused on the fully flowered and heady version of gardenia. Une Voix Noire seems to focus on the past its prime slowly browning version of gardenia. This is gardenia as it releases its last bit of floralcy into the atmosphere, a poignant reminder of the glory days. That Mssrs. Lutens and Sheldrake surround it mostly with accords of tobacco and rum it makes the gardenia feel as if it has lived a hard drinking life with a halo of cigarette smoke drifting around it. I expected a dark take on the bright of gardenia and instead was treated to an epitaph for gardenia. Once I realized that, Une Voix Noire truly bloomed in my expectations and consciousness.

As I mentioned the gardenia here is of the slightly wilted browning on the edge of the petals variety. As a result the opening moments of Une Voix Noire are all about that gardenia. This is not the almost narcotic white flower version we are used to; the green quality is much attenuated and the indolic core is equally restrained. This makes the gardenia almost come off as a fruity kind of note. It isn’t listed but there seems to be a bit of powdery iris around in the early moments which keep the gardenia more on the floral side of things. As the rum accord rises the gardenia takes on a wistful quality, a world-weary floral having a shot at the bar before closing down for the day. The tobacco adds the nicotinic headiness missing from the gardenia and it takes Une Voix Noire deeper into that good night.

Une Voix Noire has outstanding longevity and above average sillage.

Billie Holiday, last recording session, studio, NYC 1958 by Milt Hinton

After I moved my expectations of a bluesy riff on gardenia out of the way and took the time to appreciate the creativity of focusing on the dying moments of the gardenia on display in Une Voix Noire; that was when it came alive for me.

Disclosure: This review was based on a decant purchased from The Perfumed Court.

Thanks to Serge Lutens I have the famous black card solid  perfume sampler set  direct from Le Palais Royale at 25, Rue de Valois in Paris  which includes Une Voix Noire and 31 of their most wanted  fragrances to giveaway. To be eligible leave a comment on your favorite Serge Lutens fragrance, what appeals to you about this review or your favorite Billie Holiday song.  Draw closes October 16, 2012.

We announce the winners only on site and on our Facebook page, so Like Cafleurebon and use our RSS option…or your dream prize will be just spilt perfume.

-Mark Behnke, Managing Editor

Art Direction, Michelyn Camen, EIC

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


73 comments

  • My favorite Serge Lutens is El Attarine, and Billie Holiday song is Strange Fruit. Thank you for the draw!

  • Easy! Strange fruit is my favorite song! What I have found so strange about une voix noire is that I have read several reviews about it and every reviewer expresses a different angle on the subject. I’ll have to try it myself I guess

  • I’m not familiar with any Serge Lutens fragrances but this one sounds divine. My favorite Billie Holiday song is Gloomy Sunday. Thanks for the great draw!

  • Serge Lutens´ A La Nuit is still my favorite of all, although I love my last drops of Sa Majeste La Rose, as well as Datura Noir. This review was so interesting, particularly in the way that the expectations of the author were so different to his discoveries of the actual scent. In the end, I think the scent as described seems to fit the image of Billie Holiday, and that´s amazing. Thanks again for the draw.

  • This sounds pretty interesting, and what a great prize! I often say that Tom Ford Velvet Gardenia has the corrupt feel of a gardenia past its prime, but more rotten than browning.

    I went from not liking any Serge to owning 5, so not sure what to say is my favorite. Maybe Arabie, since it was my first.

    I love the sultry, painful Billie, but also love the early, happier work. “What a Little Moonlight Can Do” comes to mind.

  • I appreciate how a change in the point of view about the stage of the gardenia’s life changed your opinion of the fragrance. That, and the pitch perfect photographs and artwork used to illustrate the review.

  • Interesting and thought provoking review as it seems the fragrance mirrors Billie Holliday’s last years of drug and booze addiction . Wow that picture of her from 1958 showed how worn out and sad she was. Favorite song My Man and favorite Serge Lutens is Bois de Violette

  • I cannot wait to smell this. My favorite Serge Lutens fragrance is Rose de Nuit, so I suppose I’m still hoping for a bit of that Lutens darkness in this gardenia. Thanks for the draw!

  • My favorite Serge Lutens is Fleurs d’Citronnier–it is so lovely for summer! Thank you for the draw!

  • SL Chergui hands down for me. “April in Paris” has got to be one of my favs from Billie Holliday.

  • My favorite Serge Lutens is Douce Amere (I wish it wasn’t so difficult to track down another bottle!)

    Billie Holiday’s “All of Me” is my favorite song.

    The most appealing part of the review is the description of the rum becoming more prominent and the gardenia lightening. This fragrance sounds truly appealing!

  • My favorite song of Holiday is Summertima and my favorite Lutens fragrance is Santal Majuscule-I’m in love with it <3

  • A boozy smoky gardenia sounds intriguing
    My favorite Billie Holliday song is God Bless the Child and my favorite Serge Lutens is tuberose criminelle
    Thank you for this opportunity !

  • My favorite Serge Lutens is Fille en Aguilles.The pine,incense,and candied fruit make for a memorable scent.Here I love the description of the gardenia being tempered by booze and tobacco notes.Sounds daring!

  • Janet in California says:

    My favorite SL is Tubereuse Criminelle. Billie Holiday favorite is Summertime.

    I can’t wait to try this.

  • I haven’t yet had the opportunity to sniff any SL perfumes but dearly want to.
    My favourite Billie Holliday song is “Strange Fruit”. Thank you!

  • Love, love Billie Holiday. One of my favorites is God Bless the Child. Gardenia can be tricky, so I’m curious about this one. Thanks for the draw.

  • Beautifully written review and such a wonderful prize! I have been looking forward to this release since I first read about it.

    My favorite Serge Lutens is Fleurs d’Oranger.

  • I love your angle on this; it’s very cool to see someone admit that a fragrance didn’t meet their expectations, but that they like it BETTER because of that fact. I haven’t tried any Lutens yet, but I’m holding out hope. 🙂

  • I love Daim Blond because it was the first perfume my husband absolutely loved on me. It was also my first Luten purchase, and now on my second FB!
    My fav part of your review is: “Mssrs. Lutens and Sheldrake surround it mostly with accords of tobacco and rum it makes the gardenia feel as if it has lived a hard drinking life…”
    Now that’s a gardenia I’d like to smell!!

  • My favorite Serge is Fleurs D’oranger
    Favorite Billie is her rendition of I’m a fool to love you

    My favorite note is gardenia, I’m really anxious to try this one !

  • Ahem, I own many SLs, most of them I like except for A La Nuit. It´s tooooo indolic to suit my taste. My HG amongst them is Tubereuse Criminelle and Filles et Aiguilles. I would like to read review of La Myrrhe. Thanks for the drawing.

  • I love Fille en Aiguille (sp?) from Lutens. What I liked about the review is the way you started it, with high expectations that were not met. For Billy Holiday I love “Lover Man” and I play it on my sax. Great review and fingers crossed to win this one.

  • I love SL and all his perfumes. Sincerely I have not yet smelled a perfume that I didn’t like – didn’t suit me yes- but I love them all! I will say Un Lys and Bois et fruits that I an wearing this season as my favorites!!
    Thank you for the draw!!

  • Fumerie Turque is my favourite Serge Lutens, but it is a challenging fragrance and sometimes it is hard to wear.

  • This is my first time hearing Serge Lutens so I do not know which perfume I would like. I like Strange Fruit 😛

  • Billy Holiday is one of the most wonderful voices in the music history! “I’m A Fool To Want You” is immortal….

  • I’ll be seeing you – love that BH song!
    Don’t have any favorites among SL frags but maybe this one will work for me as I love gardenias 🙂

  • My favourite Serge Lutens fragrance is Sarrasins, the dark and fascinating jasmine fragrance.
    I am most interested in smelling Une Voix Noire to see a different side to gardenia. We’re all so used to smelling gardenia as a lush, creamy floral scent, so a darker side would be most intriguing, especially when paired with tobacco and rum.

    Thanks for the draw!

  • “Epitaph for a gardenia” seems like the perfect way to characterize this perfume… and the Lady herself. Thanks for the draw!

  • just breathe says:

    as a newbie I have only sampled on serge Lutens (nuit de cellophane) and I love it but I have a list a mile long of other serge’s I would love to try…31 samples? Wow! I would love to win this draw 🙂

  • Un Lys is the only Serge Lutens I have tried (and I love it) so I would love to win this draw too and give some other frags a try.

  • My favorite Lutens is Fourreau Noir, but Sarrasins is so close. I never tried a Lutens that I don’t like, and Sheldrake is one of the most talented noses of the generation without a doubt.

    Thank you for the draw!

  • I like the gingerbread one of theirs ^^

    But zomg I LOVE gardenia. Always have since I was a kid. So would love to smell this fragrance!

  • Lutens and Billie, it’s hard to have a favorite in those two cases! So many wonderful and touching creations, nuanced, profound. Today I feel nostalgic and cold, so I love Autumn in New York and Ambre Sultan, but tomorow
    I might feel otherwise… Thanks for the fantastic review and for the very tempting draw!

  • Muscs Koublaï Khän is easily my favorite offering from Mr. Lutens. I am already looking forward to the cooling weather, the time is almost right to begin donning this furry beloved of mine. The darkest of scents move me in ways the light and fresh never can, so naturally this description of an “epitaph for gardenia” makes me want to know more. In that vein I must say that it may be a bit cliche’ but Billie’s song Strange Fruit holds some special memories for me, and may well be my favorite… Thanks for the draw.

  • there is great tragedy in the beauty of some art (or vice versa) and the more i read about Une Voix Noire the more i am understanding they perfectly captured this.

    ok, no one THROW anything, but i have never smelled a Serge Lutens.

    my favorite billie holiday song is Strange Fruit.

  • My very first FB and favourite SL is Chergui, my favourite BH song is Summertime (somehow ominous yet beautiful), and the thing that appeals to me about this review? GARDENIA!! Yum! Thanks for the draw. 🙂

  • My favorite SL is De Profundis. God Bless The Child is my absolute fave Billie Holiday song.
    Thanks for the draw.

  • funny you should ask that, Mark! I just fell into the bell jars! OMG!!!!! Iris Silver Mist? Sarassins! De Profundis!!!

    It’s LOVE, baby. LOVE. Don’t make me choose. I’ll take all three!

    xoxoxoA

    ps. I can multiply! yay!

  • Excited expectations can really throw off your opinion of something. I really do like gardenia fragrances. Would love to have a favorite SL to mention, but have not had the pleasure of sniffing this line yet. Soon, I hope!

  • One of my favourite serge fragrances is their wonderful boxeuses – thank you for the chance of the draw!

  • I can not pick a favorite Serge … hellz, I can’t even pick my favorite ten Serges!

    i love this quote from the review: “This is gardenia as it releases its last bit of floralcy into the atmosphere, a poignant reminder of the glory days.” We all have glory days that we remember.

  • My favorite Lutens…hmm… pretty much impossible to pick only one…MKK or Santal de Mysore, followed closely by Vetiver Oriental.

    I love the image of a world-weary flower surrounded by tobacco and rum. Would very much like to try this scent!

  • Love the review, and thanks for the draw! I adore Billie Holiday, got into her music many years ago. I always loved “Don’t Explain.” My favorite Serge Lutens fragrance would have to be a tie between Cedre and Arabie.

  • My favorite Serge Lutens is Deuce Amere, which doesn’t seem to get a lot of love but I find it uniquely alluring. The Billie Holliday song I respect the most is Strange Fruit. Thanks for the draw!

  • I haven’t tried every Serge and my favorites always seem to change, but I love Chergui on my other half and am a big fan of Cuir Mauresque myself. Also love Fille en Aiguilles and Five O’Clock au Gingembre.

  • My favorite Billie Holiday song is God Bless the Child. No favorite SL yet. Too many choices to choose just one.

  • So hard to choose favorites on both counts, but I love Arabie and the song “Strange Fruit” moves me every time I hear it.

  • Favorite song from Billie Holiday is “I’m A Fool To Want You”.

    Serge Lutens favorite: Fleur de Citronnier.

    Thank you 😀

  • My favorite SG at the moment is Vitriol d’oeillet. Funny thing is that I had no interest in it based on reviews. I so happened to recieve a sample of it on my last trip to Barneys. There is something peppery and pleasant about it. My favorite Billie song is My Man. This review did not just praise the fragrance. It was descriptive enough to make me think I had also tried it. lol Thanks for the draw.

  • This review just shows when dealing with complex products such as fragrances or wines sometimes you need to revisit frequently as you will pick up more nuances you may have missed in the first trys.